Re: [問題] 桃園軌道地下化派的論點是?
直接從"地下化比高架化好"的地下優越論觀點衍生出來支持地下化的立論通常都很有問題
比方說"台北也有論","二等公民論","桃園國門論","桃園創稅論","區域平衡論"等
族繁不及備載
真要支持地下化的說帖應該要從效益著手會比較有說服力
也就是說明比起高架化 或是路線車站原地改建
地下化在各方面(ex:安全,方便性,噪音,氣候,道路交通,都市發展等)
能確實產生相比前兩者有三倍乃至於十倍的效益
(以地面高架地下鐵路造價1:3:10通則考慮)
否則實在很難說服說桃園市值得花全國納稅人多出以百億至千億為單位的預算
去投資一個效益很可能沒有明顯高出原案甚多的新計畫 就這麼簡單
--
1、2、3~嘿! ㄟ( ̄▽ ̄ㄟ@) ~ 2、2、3~噗!~(@ㄏ ̄▽ ̄)ㄏ
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 49.159.81.170
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Railway/M.1483027913.A.39F.html
※ 編輯: purin820611 (49.159.81.170), 12/30/2016 00:13:28
→
12/30 00:56, , 1F
12/30 00:56, 1F
→
12/30 00:57, , 2F
12/30 00:57, 2F
→
12/30 00:57, , 3F
12/30 00:57, 3F
→
12/30 00:58, , 4F
12/30 00:58, 4F
→
12/30 00:58, , 5F
12/30 00:58, 5F
→
12/30 00:59, , 6F
12/30 00:59, 6F
→
12/30 01:00, , 7F
12/30 01:00, 7F
→
12/30 01:01, , 8F
12/30 01:01, 8F
→
12/30 01:04, , 9F
12/30 01:04, 9F
→
12/30 01:04, , 10F
12/30 01:04, 10F
→
12/30 01:05, , 11F
12/30 01:05, 11F
→
12/30 01:06, , 12F
12/30 01:06, 12F
→
12/30 01:06, , 13F
12/30 01:06, 13F
→
12/30 01:06, , 14F
12/30 01:06, 14F
→
12/30 01:40, , 15F
12/30 01:40, 15F
→
12/30 01:40, , 16F
12/30 01:40, 16F
→
12/30 05:32, , 17F
12/30 05:32, 17F
→
12/30 05:32, , 18F
12/30 05:32, 18F
推
12/30 06:09, , 19F
12/30 06:09, 19F
→
12/30 06:09, , 20F
12/30 06:09, 20F
→
12/30 06:24, , 21F
12/30 06:24, 21F
→
12/30 08:11, , 22F
12/30 08:11, 22F
→
12/30 08:12, , 23F
12/30 08:12, 23F
→
12/30 08:12, , 24F
12/30 08:12, 24F
→
12/30 08:13, , 25F
12/30 08:13, 25F
→
12/30 08:13, , 26F
12/30 08:13, 26F
推
12/30 08:16, , 27F
12/30 08:16, 27F
→
12/30 08:17, , 28F
12/30 08:17, 28F
→
12/30 08:17, , 29F
12/30 08:17, 29F
→
12/30 08:18, , 30F
12/30 08:18, 30F
→
12/30 08:25, , 31F
12/30 08:25, 31F
→
12/30 08:25, , 32F
12/30 08:25, 32F
→
12/30 08:25, , 33F
12/30 08:25, 33F
→
12/30 08:26, , 34F
12/30 08:26, 34F
→
12/30 08:26, , 35F
12/30 08:26, 35F
→
12/30 08:26, , 36F
12/30 08:26, 36F
→
12/30 08:26, , 37F
12/30 08:26, 37F
→
12/30 08:26, , 38F
12/30 08:26, 38F
→
12/30 08:26, , 39F
12/30 08:26, 39F
→
12/30 08:27, , 40F
12/30 08:27, 40F
→
12/30 08:38, , 41F
12/30 08:38, 41F
推
12/30 08:49, , 42F
12/30 08:49, 42F
→
12/30 08:50, , 43F
12/30 08:50, 43F
→
12/30 08:50, , 44F
12/30 08:50, 44F
推
12/30 09:02, , 45F
12/30 09:02, 45F
→
12/30 09:03, , 46F
12/30 09:03, 46F
→
12/30 09:03, , 47F
12/30 09:03, 47F
推
12/30 09:27, , 48F
12/30 09:27, 48F
→
12/30 09:27, , 49F
12/30 09:27, 49F
推
12/30 09:29, , 50F
12/30 09:29, 50F
→
12/30 09:29, , 51F
12/30 09:29, 51F
→
12/30 09:29, , 52F
12/30 09:29, 52F
推
12/30 10:19, , 53F
12/30 10:19, 53F
推
12/30 10:26, , 54F
12/30 10:26, 54F
→
12/30 10:28, , 55F
12/30 10:28, 55F
→
12/30 10:29, , 56F
12/30 10:29, 56F
→
12/30 10:30, , 57F
12/30 10:30, 57F
→
12/30 10:31, , 58F
12/30 10:31, 58F
→
12/30 10:31, , 59F
12/30 10:31, 59F
→
12/30 13:09, , 60F
12/30 13:09, 60F
→
12/30 13:13, , 61F
12/30 13:13, 61F
→
12/30 14:10, , 62F
12/30 14:10, 62F
→
12/30 14:10, , 63F
12/30 14:10, 63F
推
12/30 16:54, , 64F
12/30 16:54, 64F
→
12/30 16:55, , 65F
12/30 16:55, 65F
→
12/30 17:13, , 66F
12/30 17:13, 66F
推
12/30 19:12, , 67F
12/30 19:12, 67F
推
12/30 19:35, , 68F
12/30 19:35, 68F
→
12/30 19:35, , 69F
12/30 19:35, 69F
→
12/30 21:01, , 70F
12/30 21:01, 70F
→
12/31 21:00, , 71F
12/31 21:00, 71F
推
01/01 18:17, , 72F
01/01 18:17, 72F
討論串 (同標題文章)