Re: [新聞] Slayers解散算是預期中的事吧...只是真的解散了還是覺得很難過
TL那篇的第8頁有人翻譯成英文了,我再簡單翻成中文一下XD
Current Situation 現況
- MMA and Alicia have been demoted to B-team.
MMA 跟 Alicia 都被降到B-team了
- Because of recent events surrounding Alicia, he will also be released (have
not been told yet)
因為最近的Alicia事件,他會被放掉~~~(不過還沒告訴他)
- Ryung is currently practicing at home. Yugioh originally also practiced at
home and only practiced in the team house time to time.
Ryung現在都在家練習。Yugioh本來就是在家練習,只有偶爾去宿舍練
- Crank didn't leave but has been released.
Crank沒有離開不過已經到別隊了 (去了個新成立的外國戰隊Axiom)
- Time was given to Puzzle, Coca and Min to think about their career and they
have now switched to League of Legends
給了時間讓Puzzle, Coca 跟 Min考慮自己的職業未來,他們現在轉去打LOL了…(驚!)
- Wanted to give up entering GSTL as half the main players are gone and even
many players who were still bound by a contract refused to play. But
remaining players were eager to play so still entered. We knew it was near
impossible to win but we entered to give players experiences that they
wanted. And this bonded the remaining players.
想要放棄GSTL,因為半數隊員都離開了,另外有些有合約的也拒絕去打。
不過另外剩下的人還是很想打所以還是會參加。我們知道沒什麼可能會羸,
不過參加比賽會可以讓選手吸收經驗而且他們也想打。這也能讓剩下的隊員
團結起來。
- Excluding the three players who wanted time off to consider their career,
we entered the team with 4 B-team players and 4 A-team players. We excluded
Alicia who avoided entering GSTL from the last season.
除了以上3位要求一些時間來考慮自己未來的隊員(Puzzle他們),我們剩下4位B-team
隊員跟4位A-team隊員來參加GSTL。沒有包括Alicia因為他上季不想打。
The reason why Boxer joined SKT
- We need to talk about how SlayerS started
首先講一下SlayerS是怎麼成立的
- Federation and SlayerS didn't get along from the start. We had Intel as the
main sponsor and started off being the wealthiest team. That's when the
federation wanted us to join but we weren't sure about what their goals and
what they were after so told the federation that we will decide to join when
we observe surrounding situations. That's when GanZi incident happened
SlayerS跟由其他戰隊組成的e-Sports Federation從一開始就不太合得來。我們
有Intel當主要贊助商所以一開始就是最富有的隊伍。那時候Federation想要我們
加入,但因為我們不清楚他們的目標跟追求的是什麼,所以我們告訴他們需要看看
大環境如何再考慮。那時就發生了GanZi事件
Ganzi incident
- At the time, Ganzi was in team IM. Ganzi told Knight_Seal (SlayerS coach)
that he was interested in joining Slayers. Both me (Jessica) and BoxeR had no
idea.
那時Ganzi原本在IM戰隊。Ganzi跟SlayerS的教練Knigt_Seal說想要加入,
我(Jessica)跟包哥都不知道。
- IM told the federation and accused that SlayerS tried to steal one of their
players and GanZi had been spreading bad rumours about IM. GanZi had 6 months
ban from entering GSL so he was about to quit as a pro gamer
IM跟federation投訴說SlayerS想要挖角,然後Ganzi到處講一些IM的壞話。Ganzi被
禁賽GSL 6個月,他都想要退役不當選手了。
- Because we were never stealing GanZi, we helped GanZi to get to the bottom
of this to clear out misunderstandings
因為我們不是故意想要挖Ganzi過來,我們就幫Ganzi澄清了這些誤會
- After talking to many other players including MVP and coaches/directors who
were part of the federation, all evidences collected suggested that GanZi was
innocent. IM coach (Mr Gang) couldn't argue about anything so only snuck out
of the situation by saying 'This was my understanding, GanZi - if you wanted
to move why didn't you tell me personally?'
在跟很多屬於Federation的其他選手,包括MVP,還有教練/領隊們談過後,我們
得到了很多可以證明GanZi是無辜的證據。IM戰隊的教練無法反駁,最後只能偷偷
和諧掉說"那是我的理解。GanZi如果你想換隊的話為什麼不私下跟我說?"
- SlayerS wes the second victim of this incident as the majority of people
believed that we were stealing a player but nobody, including Mr Kang,
apologized for anything. We lost our faith in the federation who does not
seem to listen to both sides of the story and make a decision based on
assumptions.
SlayerS是這件事的第二受害人,因為大部份人都覺得我們故意去挖別戰隊的人,
但事後都沒人跟我們道歉。我們失去協會的信任,而協會也沒有去把兩方不同
的說法都了解清楚,只用自己的假設來下決定。
- After this incident we dropped our thoughts of joining in. There were no
appealing reasons for us to join. But another event hit the federation - TSL
coach Mr Lee
這次事件後我們就不打算加入協會了,沒有吸引我們加入的原因。然後另一個事件
又發生了 -- TSL教練Mr Lee
NASL incident NASL事件
- NASL season 1 had started and many players including BoxeR were preparing
to depart the country. Then Mr Won (Startale coach) contacted us that 'NASL
is not paying flights for Korean players only, we should not participate in
NASL with this sort of discrimination.' he hoped that SlayerS boycotts the
tournament. However we were already ready for everything including flights
and hotel accomodation as our sponsor paid to play.
NASL第一季開始,很多選手(包括包哥)都準備離開國家去參賽。Startale的教練
Won先生跟我們說NASL單單不會幫韓國選手付機票錢而已,我們不應該參加NASL,
因為他們歧視我們。Won先生希望我們可以杯葛NASL。但我們已經準備好了所以事
情,贊助商也有幫忙付機票跟住宿的錢
- He claimed that all other teams will be boycotting but they all ended up
participating anyway and Puma won the whole tournament.
Won先生聲稱所有其他隊伍都會杯葛NASL,但結果他們還是有去打,而且Puma羸下
了總冠軍
- As NASL season 2 began, Mr Won once again asked us to boycott and we wanted
to boycott this time. So we told Mr Won that if this boycott will help to
reach a beneficial agreement between NASL and the federation, we will surely
join boycotting.
到了NASL第二季,Won先生又再一次叫我們杯葛這比賽,而這次我們也想要這麼做。
所以我們跟Won先生說如果這杯葛行動可以讓NASL跟協會達到更好的共識,我們就
會參加
- Mr Won promised us that both GomTV and the federation will claim their
rights. However we heard nothing about this incident after. We asked Mr Won
if there had been conversations between two parties, such as e-mails, but Mr
Won said there wasn't anything like that/
Won先生答應我們GomTV跟協會都會利用這次行動來爭取自己的權益。但事後
我們沒有收到任何消息。我們問Won先生雙方是不是有談過,例如e-mail,不
過Won先生說都沒有
- We understood NASL's position about needing deposits as many players who
already disqualfied for the main stage avoid or ditch remaining matches. NASL
season 3 started and because there were no attempts communicate from the
federation and NASL. We entered season 3.
我們明白NASL需要押金的立場,因為很多沒能晉級的選手會直接放棄剩下的比賽。
然後NASL第三季要開打了,因為協會跟NASL似乎沒有要談判,所以我們參加了
- Total 8 players made through the qualifiers, and that's when Mr Choi (MVP
coach) contacted us. He expressed his regrets about us playing in NASL and
mentioned that FXO entered for the qualifiers but dropped the thoughts
immediately. He asked me to drop the 8 players from participating. I
explained to Mr Choi that I only agreed to boycott season 2 as Mr Won
promised me to show results or at least attempts to communicate to reach an
agreement with NASL but have heard nothing from him. I explained the whole
surrounding situations and asked him to tell other team coaches of the
federation who do not know the situation but weirdly enough nothing was
communicated between them.
總共有8位選手晉級,這時候MVP的教練Choi先生來接觸我們。他對於我們參加
NASL感到很遺憾,然後提到FXO戰隊也放棄了參賽。他希望我們這8位選手也放
棄比賽。我跟Choi先生解釋說第二季我同意了要杯葛,因為Won先生答應會跟
NASL談判,但結果什麼消息都沒有。我跟他講了這情況,也希望他可以告訴其
他不知情但又沒有互通消息的戰隊
- Even Mr Won who could have told other teams about how we thought, and when
I asked him why he didn't communicate that to the federation. He claimed that
he doesn't remember the conversation clearly that he didn't want to
communicate something uncertain. I thought the federation was an absurd group.
其實Won先生也可以幫忙把我們的想法告訴別的戰隊,但當我問他為什麼沒有這樣
做的時候,他說他不是很清楚記得我們的對話內容所以不想亂講。我覺得這協會
實在是太不合理了
- We have heard from other players from different teams, that they were told
not to practise with SlayerS players and not even chat on ladder. Players who
were good friends with each other had to use a different account to secretly
help our players to practise. When I heard about this, I asked Mr Won and
argued however he said confidently "it's petty but this is how far we will go
to put restrictions on SlayerS'
我們從別的戰隊的選手處聽說,有人叫他們不要跟SlayerS戰隊的人練習,就算在
天梯上遇到也不能講話。有一些本來是好朋友的選手只能開分身帳號來私下幫我們
的隊員練習。當我聽到這消息時我找Won先生投訴,不過他很自信的說"雖然這樣做
氣量很小,不過為了抵制SlayerS我們也在所不惜"
- When I answered, that is ridiculous as we had not done anything wrong and
this is destroying players personal friendship. And Mr Won simply replied
'this happens because you refused to join the federation and go on separate
ways'. I made several claims to the federation but nobody answered me and
players couldn't find practise partners.
我回答說這太荒謬了因為我們什麼都沒做錯,這樣做會破壞選手之間的友誼。Won先生
只回答說"這樣的事情會發生是因為你拒絕加入協會,自己走上別的路" 我跟協會
投訴了幾次,不過沒有人回應我,隊員們也找不到練習的對象
- As I couldn't take this any longer, I phoned Mr Won and told "I don't want
our players to have unfair disadvantages because of their team. I will
disband the team so take our players to your team. However we will formally
request you (the federation) to be liable for damages you caused to the team
and our sponsors." And that is when we have finally gotten an e-mail saying
that they will lift up the restriction. (Have shown it to the reporter who
wrote this)
因為我再也忍受不下去,我打給Won先生說"我不想我的隊員們因為戰隊而處於不
公平又不利的位置,我會解散我的戰隊,你們把我們的隊員要走吧。不過我們
會正式地要求你們 (協會) 負責我們跟贊助商的損失" 這時我們終於收到協會
的e-mail說他們會停止對我們的抵制 (這e-mail有給寫這文章的人看過)
- But a former OGS player (who is now in a foreign team) told me that though
the restriction was lifted, they still instructed players not to practise
with SlayerS informally.
不過一個前OGS的隊員(現在去了國外戰隊的)告訴我雖然表面上說抵制取消了,
他們私下還是叫選手不要跟SlayerS的人練習
- This is the worst peak between SlayerS and other teams. Then they contacted
us just before the eSports SC2 vision event. They wanted SlayerS to be the
part of it. They have put restrictions on us because they didn't like how we
were operating the team now they needed the BoxeR to be the significant
figure. I have found what they were doing disgusting as they don't seem to
have a sense of guilt. So I refused. They have never apologized me and I kept
asking Mr Won whether the restriction has been lifted and he affirmed that
there were no restrictions. But many players still told me that they were
being instructed by the coach not to help us. I didn't even know who was
telling the truth at this point.. I also was sad that players followed that
instruction. But our players have been always helping other players from the
team whenever they ask, this can be seen from their interviews.
這是SlayerS跟其他戰隊關係最差的時候。然後在eSports SC2 vision活動前他們
才聯絡我們說希望我們參加。他們抵制我們是因為不喜歡我們的運作方式,但現在
他們需要包哥來當活動的亮點。我覺得他們實在太噁心了,因為他們看起來一點
愧疚感都沒有。所以我拒絕了。他們從來沒跟我道歉過,而我一直問Won先生抵制
到底停止了沒有他裹一直跟我確認說沒有任何抵制的行為。不過很多選手還是跟我
說教練吩咐他們不要跟SlayerS練習。我當時都不知道誰講的才是真的了…我也為了
選手們都聽教練話感到很難過。不過我們的隊員還是常常在別隊選手要求時幫助他
們練習,這從他們的訪問可以看到
- Sleep, who is not in any team right now, is suffering the same. Just
because he is staying in our team house. As of now, it is still happening. Mr
Won claims that the restriction have been lifted and if he wants to dispute
what I am claiming now - do so formally. He won't be able to deny as we have
a player who used to be part of the federation.
目前沒有加入任何戰隊的Sleep也受到一樣的對待,只因為他住在我們的宿舍裡。
現在這情況還是持續著,Won先生聲稱已經沒有抵制,如果他想要反駁我的話,
請官方地/正式地這麼做。他沒辦法反駁的,因為我們其中一位隊員曾經是協會
裡的人。
MMA incident
- We had a manager(initial J) who took care of our relationship with overseas
partners/fans. J focused on working with the images BoxeR had. He was not a
good friend with MMA to begin with but since MMA started to perform well, he
always came to the studio when MMA played.
- He wanted to look after SlayerS official Facebook page and Twitter to
communicate with foreign fans more. As he started that, that's when we
promoted him to a manager position where he also took care of overseas
partners. He also took care of negotiations between two of our sponsors with
an extension.
- He kept reporting me that our demands and their demands never seem to meet.
I asked myself 'why are the sponsors doing this to us now when we are
performing better?' after reading what they were offering. So I gave up on
the extension.
- That's when the problems rose, I was sure that I could run and manage the
team without a sponsor so I decided to operate the team as we've been and
planned to seek out for a new sponsor in the future. But I have noticed a
weird atmosphere among players and manager J acted suspiciously. Turns out
manager J was lying to me about what he was telling sponsors and he told
players that I have embezzeled money and goods using reputations of the team
and the players. Everyone knew that BoxeR was spending his own money to run
the team and I don't know how players believed the manager who joined the
team 2 months ago.
懶人包:有個叫 J 的經理,是負責跟國外拉關係拉贊助的,他都跟我說跟國外的
贊助商談不攏。我覺得就算沒贊助我也可以讓戰隊好好的運作下去,所以就覺得
不再去拉贊助了,等將來有機會再找吧。但那時隊員之間的氣氛變得怪怪的,J的
行為也很可疑,原來贊助的事J都對我說謊,他還跟其他隊員說是我利用隊員的名聲
把贊助的錢跟物資都A走。大家都知道包哥是自己貼錢來搞戰隊,但不知道為什麼隊
員們都寧願相信這個才加入2個月的經理
- MMA firmly believed that I have embezzled his money from the personal
sponsor and I was very disappointed. I cared every single one of them
sincerely and loved them but they believed the manager... I can't remember
how long I cried. J manager offered players behind my back to form a new team
with him that he could get more sponsors than I did. MMA did not confirm
anything with any means and accepted that offer which he confessed me later.
- More shocking thing was that no players told me about this. I was going to
formally sue the manager but I couldn't because I didn't want to disturb
young players with a court case. If I had never found about this.. then
players would have left the team without knowing.. That's when I lost my
faith in MMA
- MMA and others, who often participated in a foriegn tournament, claimed
that whenever he says hell to other players from the federation, they would
ignore him and that they kept mocking SlayerS and themselves. MMA, Alicia,
Crank and GanZi have all told me the same thing. And this was the cover-up
reason he told others and the medias
MMA堅信我A走了贊助他的錢,我感到非常失望(哭哭)。經理J私底下遊說隊員們去
組一隊新的戰隊,還說他可以拉到更多贊助。MMA居然答應了(崩潰)。更崩潰的是
完全沒有隊員跟我說這件事。我本來想要告下去但不想影響到年輕的隊員們所以沒
有這麼做,這時候我對MMA失去信任了。MMA跟其他有去國外打比賽的隊員都說當他
們跟其他戰隊的人打招呼時大家都不理他們,而且還會取笑他們跟SlayerS。MMA在
跟其他媒體交待時就是用這個當借口
- The reason why MMA got demoted was not that. I have explained why he was
being bullied and mocked and got him comprehended. That's when Crank and MMA
hung around alot after that. Crank visited me and complained that the team
atmosphere was so bad, he felt pressured and stressed. That's when I asked
BoxeR, who at the time was resting to sort out his shoulder problem, to stay
in the team house and look after them.
- However, Crank complained once again that talking to the coach and BoxeR's
presence did not make any difference and asked me what I actually did. I felt
very sorry to him. My player is complaining and all I did didn't help him..
- Crank told me that because his neck is sore, he needed to rest. This was
right before GSTL quarter finals. He said as he finished preparing for his
game and he can pratise that only. I asked Cella if it's ok for him to go
home and Cella told me that he has got his build order prepared for a map so
he may go home.
不過這不是MMA被降到B隊的原因。我有跟MMA解釋說為什麼他會被孤立他也明白了,
然後這時他跟Crank就變成好朋友了。Crank跟我抱怨說隊員們的氣氛很差,他覺得
很有壓力,這時我就叫在為了肩患休養的包哥回去宿命住。不過Crank還是抱怨說
跟教練談/包哥回來住都沒用,後來GSTL準決賽時他就說他脖子酸痛需要休息。他說
他有準備好戰術了,所以Cella也同意讓Crank回家休養。
- That weekend, he texted me requesting to be removed from the entry. Because
he seemed so ill, I talked to him on messenger to see if he was ok. He didn't
answer so I left a message saying 'Rest well physically and mentally
peacefully and see you at the stadium'. He then texted Cella 'what is she
doing this to me?' .. I don't know what I did
- That's when Cella told me that he wanted to quit and is not practising at
home. He wanted to quit and rest and he has no intention of moving to another
team so he begged me to release him from the contract. I had no intention of
holding his back and I agreed that he wanted to rest so I let him go.
- But.. I was told by others that he is streaming and looking for a foreign
team. So I asked him why he had to lie and what his unprofessional attitutes
are for. I asked him if he knew why MMA wanted to leave the team. He answered
'it's because of me - when I told MMA that I want to move to another team
because of the team atmosphere, MMA wanted to join me'. I asked MMA whether
it was true and he denied.
那周末他傳簡訊跟我說想要退賽,因為他好像病重所以我想用MSN跟他談看他怎麼樣。
他沒有回我所以我留言叫他多休息,結果他跟Cella說"為什麼她要這樣對我"…我不知
道我是做了什麼。這時Cella跟我說Crank想退役休養,還保證他沒有要加入別隊的意
圖所以希望我可以跟他解約。我沒有要綁住他所以同意了如果他要休息就讓他離開。
結果其他人告訴我Crank有在開直播,還在找國外的戰隊,所以我問他為什麼要說謊,
也問他知不知道MMA想要離隊。他說那是因為我,我跟MMA說我想要加入別隊,MMA也
想跟我一起跳槽。我問MMA說是不是真的,他否認了
- Recently, Crank rang me and screamed 'why are you relating me with Ganzi,
Alicia and MMA's problem? do you want to ruin my progamer life?' I lost my
words. I knew he wasn't happy with me and the team. But I asked 'Do you know
where you are yelling at? I have looked after you and cared for you as the
team owner and the manager for years'.. but he yelled back saying 'who do you
think you are? where are you yelling at?'. Boxer who was right next to me got
the phone off me after listening to him, but then he also yelled at BoxeR
saying 'what were you doing during all this?' and then claimed that he will
only play SC2 for this year and he just wanted to enjoy the game and that's
why he left the team. I have this on recording and I will see what he does in
the future. (T/N : I am sure that Crank can get into a trouble if he enters
into another team as he lied to get out of the contract)
最近Crank打給我怒吼說為什麼你要把我跟Ganzi, Alicia和MMA的問題扯在一起?你
是不是想破壞我的職務生涯?我都不知道要說什麼了。在我旁邊的包哥把電話接過去
不過Crank還是一樣對他發火"這一切發生時你到底在做什麼",還說他SC2只玩到今年
了他只想開心地玩遊戲所以他離隊。我有把這段錄音了,如果Crank將來要加入別隊
那他就有麻煩了
- BoxeR spent all his time and more than one hundred million(won) to grow the
team and when players are mocking me and him, he was very shocked. Although
we were in the GSTL finals, the atmosphere was the worst. I had to make a
decision on Crank and MMA, who were affecting the team atmosphere, so I sent
MMA back home and removed crank. I wanted to notify MMA but he never came
back to the team house over weekends and never helped anyone for GSTL.
Because we couldn't tell MMA, BoxeR and I told Ganzi about this. Ganzi used
to joke around with me but during the time he couldn't even make an eye
contact with me. I asked him what the problem was as I have explained to him
about everything as MMA problems progressed.
- BoxeR told GanZi painfully that MMA is a cancer to this team at the moment
and he wanted to GanZi to make the right decision. GanZi was very lost and he
also told us that he will try to concentrate practising at home.
- MMA came back the next day, he probably have heard his expulsion from
A-team from Ganzi. He had already packed all his belongings. BoxeR called MMA
and started to talk but MMA cut him off and said there are nothing to talk
about. BoxeR told him MMA had been moved to B-Team and to return home, MMA
simply said there was no need as he is leaving the team.
- When BoxeR told him that he is still a SlayerS player who was bound by the
contract, MMA claimed that it was not a contract but a slavery note. We have
a clause determining the share of prize money, which already allows players
to keep the majority, but we didn't even take our share of the prize money.
We didn't write contracts to make money. When he called the contract a
slavery note, I was simply lost. We had 5 players in total who had a contract
including Ganzi and MMA.
包哥花了那麼多時間跟金錢在這隊伍上結果隊員這樣對我們,他覺得很震驚。雖
然我們還在GSTL裡不過隊裡氣氛差到不能再差了。我需要對Crank跟MMA的去留做
決定,因為他們影響了隊上的氣氛,所以我讓MMA回家然後讓Crank離隊了。後來
跟GanZi交待這件事,他覺得很混亂不過他說會盡力在家專心練習。第二天MMA回
來了,大概是從GanZi那得知自己被降到B-team。他都收拾好自己的東西了,包哥
想要跟MMA談,結果MMA打斷包哥說沒什麼好談的了。包哥跟他說他被降到B-team
然後要回家住,不過MMA說不需要了因為他要離隊。當包哥跟MMA說他還是隊員而且
有合約在身時,MMA說那不是合約而是奴隸的賣身契。我們有跟隊員協議好獎金的
分配,讓他們留下大部份的錢,我們甚至自己沒拿錢。所以當他這麼說的時候我
覺得很驚訝,連GanZi和MMA在內我們總共跟5個隊員有合約。
※ 引述《Woorissica (包子臉)》之銘言:
: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=376041
: http://www.inven.co.kr/webzine/news/?news=48785
: Slayers在11月9號跟MVP戰隊的GSTL比賽後解散
: 韓文來源內還有佳妍姐的聲明以及Slayers的一些狀況說明
: 包括包哥離隊加入SKT1,阿勇事件,MMA事件還有NASL第一季的紛爭
: 更詳細的訊息只能等翻譯或韓文高手支援了
: Bye, Slayers.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 183.178.116.58
→
10/17 22:12, , 1F
10/17 22:12, 1F
推
10/17 22:14, , 2F
10/17 22:14, 2F
推
10/17 22:14, , 3F
10/17 22:14, 3F
推
10/17 22:15, , 4F
10/17 22:15, 4F
推
10/17 22:16, , 5F
10/17 22:16, 5F
推
10/17 22:16, , 6F
10/17 22:16, 6F
推
10/17 22:16, , 7F
10/17 22:16, 7F
推
10/17 22:16, , 8F
10/17 22:16, 8F
推
10/17 22:16, , 9F
10/17 22:16, 9F
推
10/17 22:16, , 10F
10/17 22:16, 10F
推
10/17 22:16, , 11F
10/17 22:16, 11F
推
10/17 22:17, , 12F
10/17 22:17, 12F
推
10/17 22:17, , 13F
10/17 22:17, 13F
→
10/17 22:17, , 14F
10/17 22:17, 14F
推
10/17 22:18, , 15F
10/17 22:18, 15F
※ 編輯: hitsuji611 來自: 183.178.116.58 (10/17 22:54)
推
10/17 22:18, , 16F
10/17 22:18, 16F
推
10/17 22:19, , 17F
10/17 22:19, 17F
推
10/17 22:19, , 18F
10/17 22:19, 18F
推
10/17 22:19, , 19F
10/17 22:19, 19F
推
10/17 22:19, , 20F
10/17 22:19, 20F
→
10/17 22:19, , 21F
10/17 22:19, 21F
→
10/17 22:19, , 22F
10/17 22:19, 22F
推
10/17 22:19, , 23F
10/17 22:19, 23F
推
10/17 22:19, , 24F
10/17 22:19, 24F
推
10/17 22:19, , 25F
10/17 22:19, 25F
推
10/17 22:20, , 26F
10/17 22:20, 26F
推
10/17 22:20, , 27F
10/17 22:20, 27F
→
10/17 22:20, , 28F
10/17 22:20, 28F
推
10/17 22:20, , 29F
10/17 22:20, 29F
推
10/17 22:21, , 30F
10/17 22:21, 30F
推
10/17 22:21, , 31F
10/17 22:21, 31F
→
10/17 22:21, , 32F
10/17 22:21, 32F
推
10/17 22:21, , 33F
10/17 22:21, 33F
推
10/17 22:22, , 34F
10/17 22:22, 34F
推
10/17 22:23, , 35F
10/17 22:23, 35F
→
10/17 22:23, , 36F
10/17 22:23, 36F
推
10/17 22:23, , 37F
10/17 22:23, 37F
推
10/17 22:23, , 38F
10/17 22:23, 38F
還有 40 則推文
→
10/17 22:34, , 79F
10/17 22:34, 79F
→
10/17 22:34, , 80F
10/17 22:34, 80F
→
10/17 22:35, , 81F
10/17 22:35, 81F
→
10/17 22:35, , 82F
10/17 22:35, 82F
推
10/17 22:36, , 83F
10/17 22:36, 83F
推
10/17 22:37, , 84F
10/17 22:37, 84F
推
10/17 22:39, , 85F
10/17 22:39, 85F
→
10/17 22:39, , 86F
10/17 22:39, 86F
推
10/17 22:42, , 87F
10/17 22:42, 87F
推
10/17 22:44, , 88F
10/17 22:44, 88F
推
10/17 22:44, , 89F
10/17 22:44, 89F
→
10/17 22:45, , 90F
10/17 22:45, 90F
推
10/17 22:48, , 91F
10/17 22:48, 91F
推
10/17 22:49, , 92F
10/17 22:49, 92F
→
10/17 22:51, , 93F
10/17 22:51, 93F
→
10/17 22:51, , 94F
10/17 22:51, 94F
→
10/17 22:52, , 95F
10/17 22:52, 95F
→
10/17 22:53, , 96F
10/17 22:53, 96F
推
10/17 22:55, , 97F
10/17 22:55, 97F
推
10/17 22:59, , 98F
10/17 22:59, 98F
推
10/17 23:12, , 99F
10/17 23:12, 99F
推
10/17 23:25, , 100F
10/17 23:25, 100F
推
10/17 23:41, , 101F
10/17 23:41, 101F
推
10/18 00:27, , 102F
10/18 00:27, 102F
推
10/18 00:45, , 103F
10/18 00:45, 103F
推
10/18 00:55, , 104F
10/18 00:55, 104F
推
10/18 00:56, , 105F
10/18 00:56, 105F
推
10/18 01:15, , 106F
10/18 01:15, 106F
→
10/18 01:18, , 107F
10/18 01:18, 107F
→
10/18 01:18, , 108F
10/18 01:18, 108F
推
10/18 01:19, , 109F
10/18 01:19, 109F
→
10/18 01:19, , 110F
10/18 01:19, 110F
推
10/18 01:24, , 111F
10/18 01:24, 111F
→
10/18 01:25, , 112F
10/18 01:25, 112F
→
10/18 01:26, , 113F
10/18 01:26, 113F
推
10/18 01:29, , 114F
10/18 01:29, 114F
推
10/18 03:28, , 115F
10/18 03:28, 115F
推
10/18 08:31, , 116F
10/18 08:31, 116F
推
10/18 10:25, , 117F
10/18 10:25, 117F
推
10/18 14:15, , 118F
10/18 14:15, 118F
討論串 (同標題文章)
本文引述了以下文章的的內容:
新聞
126
248
完整討論串 (本文為第 3 之 6 篇):
新聞
126
248
新聞
11
14
新聞
77
118
新聞
41
105
新聞
42
83
新聞
196
472