Re: [新聞] BNT兒童疫苗比莫德納好？何美鄉拿美國數據打臉：這樣的疫苗寄望什麼
看看美國CDC怎麼說的
Pfizer’s Covid-19 vaccine gave children 5 and older strong protection against h
ospitalization and death even during the omicron surge that hit youngsters espec
ially hard, U.S. health officials reported Tuesday.
美國健康官員說輝瑞疫苗在避免住院及死亡上，給予5歲以上小孩強大的保護
The CDC reported Tuesday that between April and early January there were nine de
aths related to Covid-19 among vaccinated children ages 5 to 17 — compared to 1
21 deaths among unvaccinated children that age.
Also, the CDC examined pediatric hospitalizations in 10 states from last April t
o the end of January. The vaccine proved 74 percent effective against hospitaliz
ation in 5- to 11-year-olds. Only two vaccinated children were hospitalized comp
ared to 59 unvaccinated children.
CDC在週二的報告中，從去年四月到今年一月底，5-17歲因新冠病毒死亡的小孩中，8例是打
過疫苗的，121例是沒打疫苗
另外，CDC檢視了去年四月到今年一月底，10個州的小孩住院病例，在5-11歲的小孩中，證
實了疫苗是74%有效。只有2個打過疫苗的小孩住院，有59個未打過的小孩住院。
Tuesday’s study also found that during the time when omicron was predominant, t
he vaccine was 51 percent effective in preventing emergency room or urgent-care
visits by 5- to 11-year-olds. That was fairly similar to the 45 percent effecti
veness for 12- to 15-year-olds who’d gotten their second dose months earlier.
週二的研究也發現，在omicron變流行時，疫苗在5-11歲中，預防重症或急診是51%有效。這
跟幾個月前就接受第二劑的12-15歲的有效率45%差不多。
Unvaccinated 5- to 11-year-olds were 1.3 times more likely to get Covid-19 in Ja
nuary — at the height of the omicron surge — than vaccinated youngsters, accor
ding to new CDC data.
根據CDC的新數據，5-11歲未打疫苗的小孩在一月得到covid-19，也就是omicron高峰時，是
有打疫苗的1.3倍。
CDC是看10個州的數據，不是只有紐約
而且結果證實BNT對於預防重症及住院是有幫助
何說莫比較好 那數據呢？？只看劑量？
這中研院的作法嗎？
文章很長，有興趣的自己看
https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/pfizer-shots-protect-kids-severe-covi
d-even-omicron-cdc-says-rcna18182
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 203.217.121.213 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1650336335.A.E8D.html
推
04/19 10:46,
2年前
, 1F
04/19 10:46, 1F
→
04/19 10:46,
2年前
, 2F
04/19 10:46, 2F
→
04/19 10:47,
2年前
, 3F
04/19 10:47, 3F
推
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 4F
04/19 10:48, 4F
推
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 5F
04/19 10:48, 5F
推
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 6F
04/19 10:48, 6F
→
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 7F
04/19 10:48, 7F
→
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 8F
04/19 10:48, 8F
推
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 9F
04/19 10:48, 9F
推
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 10F
04/19 10:48, 10F
→
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 11F
04/19 10:48, 11F
→
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 12F
04/19 10:48, 12F
→
04/19 10:48,
2年前
, 13F
04/19 10:48, 13F
→
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 14F
04/19 10:49, 14F
推
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 15F
04/19 10:49, 15F
推
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 16F
04/19 10:49, 16F
→
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 17F
04/19 10:49, 17F
→
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 18F
04/19 10:49, 18F
→
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 19F
04/19 10:49, 19F
→
04/19 10:49,
2年前
, 20F
04/19 10:49, 20F
推
04/19 10:50,
2年前
, 21F
04/19 10:50, 21F
→
04/19 10:50,
2年前
, 22F
04/19 10:50, 22F
→
04/19 10:50,
2年前
, 23F
04/19 10:50, 23F
推
04/19 10:50,
2年前
, 24F
04/19 10:50, 24F
推
04/19 10:50,
2年前
, 25F
04/19 10:50, 25F
→
04/19 10:51,
2年前
, 26F
04/19 10:51, 26F
→
04/19 10:51,
2年前
, 27F
04/19 10:51, 27F
→
04/19 10:51,
2年前
, 28F
04/19 10:51, 28F
推
04/19 10:51,
2年前
, 29F
04/19 10:51, 29F
→
04/19 10:51,
2年前
, 30F
04/19 10:51, 30F
→
04/19 10:52,
2年前
, 31F
04/19 10:52, 31F
→
04/19 10:52,
2年前
, 32F
04/19 10:52, 32F
→
04/19 10:52,
2年前
, 33F
04/19 10:52, 33F
推
04/19 10:52,
2年前
, 34F
04/19 10:52, 34F
推
04/19 10:52,
2年前
, 35F
04/19 10:52, 35F
→
04/19 10:53,
2年前
, 36F
04/19 10:53, 36F
推
04/19 10:53,
2年前
, 37F
04/19 10:53, 37F
噓
04/19 10:54,
2年前
, 38F
04/19 10:54, 38F
推
04/19 10:54,
2年前
, 39F
04/19 10:54, 39F
還有 70 則推文
推
04/19 12:17,
2年前
, 110F
04/19 12:17, 110F
→
04/19 12:17,
2年前
, 111F
04/19 12:17, 111F
→
04/19 12:18,
2年前
, 112F
04/19 12:18, 112F
推
04/19 12:18,
2年前
, 113F
04/19 12:18, 113F
推
04/19 12:21,
2年前
, 114F
04/19 12:21, 114F
推
04/19 12:21,
2年前
, 115F
04/19 12:21, 115F
推
04/19 12:23,
2年前
, 116F
04/19 12:23, 116F
推
04/19 12:28,
2年前
, 117F
04/19 12:28, 117F
推
04/19 12:30,
2年前
, 118F
04/19 12:30, 118F
推
04/19 12:31,
2年前
, 119F
04/19 12:31, 119F
推
04/19 12:38,
2年前
, 120F
04/19 12:38, 120F
→
04/19 12:38,
2年前
, 121F
04/19 12:38, 121F
→
04/19 12:42,
2年前
, 122F
04/19 12:42, 122F
→
04/19 12:54,
2年前
, 123F
04/19 12:54, 123F
推
04/19 12:59,
2年前
, 124F
04/19 12:59, 124F
推
04/19 13:02,
2年前
, 125F
04/19 13:02, 125F
→
04/19 13:02,
2年前
, 126F
04/19 13:02, 126F
→
04/19 13:04,
2年前
, 127F
04/19 13:04, 127F
推
04/19 13:05,
2年前
, 128F
04/19 13:05, 128F
→
04/19 13:05,
2年前
, 129F
04/19 13:05, 129F
→
04/19 13:06,
2年前
, 130F
04/19 13:06, 130F
推
04/19 13:12,
2年前
, 131F
04/19 13:12, 131F
→
04/19 13:12,
2年前
, 132F
04/19 13:12, 132F
→
04/19 13:20,
2年前
, 133F
04/19 13:20, 133F
→
04/19 13:30,
2年前
, 134F
04/19 13:30, 134F
推
04/19 13:31,
2年前
, 135F
04/19 13:31, 135F
推
04/19 13:34,
2年前
, 136F
04/19 13:34, 136F
推
04/19 13:50,
2年前
, 137F
04/19 13:50, 137F
→
04/19 13:50,
2年前
, 138F
04/19 13:50, 138F
推
04/19 13:51,
2年前
, 139F
04/19 13:51, 139F
推
04/19 14:16,
2年前
, 140F
04/19 14:16, 140F
推
04/19 14:35,
2年前
, 141F
04/19 14:35, 141F
→
04/19 14:35,
2年前
, 142F
04/19 14:35, 142F
推
04/19 15:09,
2年前
, 143F
04/19 15:09, 143F
→
04/19 15:41,
2年前
, 144F
04/19 15:41, 144F
推
04/19 16:21,
2年前
, 145F
04/19 16:21, 145F
→
04/19 16:21,
2年前
, 146F
04/19 16:21, 146F
推
04/19 16:22,
2年前
, 147F
04/19 16:22, 147F
推
04/19 16:46,
2年前
, 148F
04/19 16:46, 148F
→
04/19 17:00,
2年前
, 149F
04/19 17:00, 149F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文 (最舊先)：
完整討論串 (本文為第 8 之 13 篇)：
