Re: [外電] 在十字路口的LBJ
我的內容跟這篇文章關聯性不大
會引用這篇當開頭是因為kart你說的這句話
"如果真的敗在這一輪,我想未來我應該會把看球時間留給別的事情吧"
這篇廢文,只是我個人的一種心情抒發,沒有別的意思
不想看廢文可以跳過下面這段
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
廢文開始
我從1992-93光頭3連霸最後一年開始認識到NBA這個東西
那時候總冠軍戰,國中同學都在問你支持九蛋還是八顆粒
然後就啟蒙了我的NBA球迷粉絲之路
一恍到現在算算也快20年了
其中有幾季很認真地看,也有幾季看得很少且不太有興致
但現在回想這快20的球迷人生,不管看得勤的還是看得少的
都充滿了回憶
我還記得當我開始看球時老喬退休了
後來大歐跟噴泥來到聯盟
後來老喬又復活了,印象中那年老喬跟超音速打總冠軍賽
我剛好考大學,最後一個月(6月)正是最緊張的時候
完全無法看球賽,但每天還是會看報紙相關的新聞止止渴過過癮
看到支持的公牛贏了比賽,就更充滿了鬥志去面對就像總冠軍賽G7的聯考
從球賽中學到面對困難時的勇氣,雖然96年我幾乎沒看幾場比賽
但在內心中依然充滿了回憶
後來老喬退了跟著大歐來到湖人
後面再讓我印象深刻的是2001-2002湖人對籃網的總冠軍戰
那年我在軍中,6月底退伍..6月正是打總冠軍賽的時刻
只記得因為快要重獲自由呼吸著新鮮的空氣跟面對未來的恐慌下
完全沒有心力關注著NBA球賽,只是常常走過中山室或長官辦公室
看到有人在看NBA總冠軍賽的片段畫面
但那也是個讓我記憶深刻的一年
後面就是湖人04年F4失利,熱火06年神奇的偉德喬丹秀
以及2011年得熱火3王團結一心拚到LBJ的第一冠
如果要簡單的描述這20年的球迷心得與回憶
大概就是這麻簡單,但實際上內容遠遠大過於此...
我都不知道自己用了多少時間在NBA球賽上
以上是廢文
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
前幾天看到kart跟小米酒兩位大大在火板"討論"
我覺得兩位看球的年齡也很應該很長,也都看得很多很內行
相信兩位一定都有自己的NBA故事
我無意介入二位的討論,只是有感而發
像kart大一向都是比較樂觀理性
也許你覺得從各種方向客觀來分析,
今年66勝的熱火沒理由輸給只有49勝的溜馬
但我要提醒一點,我剛看NBA的前幾年有一支球隊叫做火箭
在1994-1995年拿總冠軍那年只拿了47勝
我不覺得常規賽的成績,能說明一支球隊的強與弱
如果只看常規賽成績,前幾年熱火根本打不贏公牛跟老賽
我也不覺得只把球員一個一個拿出來看,就可以預測到勝利會屬於誰
當年的火箭,只看球員名單,根本不是最強最猛的那隻
如果今年熱火輸球,只能說明現在的團隊(包含教練團)
就是打不贏溜馬的團隊而已
沒有任何一方的勝利是僥倖或是靠外在因素贏了一整個系列
會輸,就是因為球隊不夠強
或是換個方式說,會輸,就是因為球隊的弱點被對手抓了連續痛打
然後我們毫無解決的辦法
我還記得這個賽季中我跟peterman吵過好幾次架
第一次吵架的緣由就是因為籃板跟Bosh (為了Bosh跟DH互換的八卦吵)
我比較傳統一點,我根本上不相信一個沒有強而有力的防守籃板團隊
可以讓球隊一路走到總冠軍
到現在我也不想翻舊帳來討論到底誰對誰錯
只想說這支熱火隊,這一輪打到現在
讓許多球迷都感到失望!
這也是我某部分也認同kart你的說法的原因
但反過來想想,如果球迷都感受到挫折與失望
那身為當事人的球員們的內心呢?
他們是不是也對自己的表現感到不滿與憤怒?
每個人表現失望的方式不一樣,有些人喜歡發廢文(like me)
有些人喜歡自責(LBJ/Bosh/Spo)
有些人喜歡發牢騷(Wade)
但我相信這並非彼此責怪,而只是情緒的發洩
站在LBJ的角度來看,他付出了無可挑剔所有
面對著年輕但又不如自己的挑戰者(溜馬隊與PG)
LBJ已經捍衛了帝王的顏面展現出統治級的數據
但球隊表現依然如騎士隊時般的掙扎
LBJ有沒有懷疑?有沒有不滿?有沒有情緒?!
一定都有的
站在Wade的角度來看,這幾年先是交出了球隊領導權
再來也慢慢被教練減輕負擔但也代表對於球隊的份量越來越少
同時面對著體能的下滑與數字統計的削減
像極了老的的獅王面對一堆年輕的挑戰者只能威吼幾聲般的無力
這些Wade大多往自己肚子裡吞下去
但這幾場的表現,自己一再的被外面的媒體刺激冷嘲熱諷
他難道不會懷疑自己,難道不會不滿,難道沒有情緒?
站在他的角度想,他難道不會想再給他多一些的球權讓他來證明自己還有實力?
這是老獅王對獅群與年輕獅子的最後怒吼
他覺得他應該得到second chance or last chance to prove himself
於是這篇口水新聞就出現了
當外面的人都在看好戲等著看王者熱火走向敗亡時
在這個最風雨交加的時候...
一切正如神的旨意在考驗著熱火每個球員與球迷
如果這次輸了,三王全部都垮了,沒有人會倖免
CD兩人的表現會讓他們歷史定位大幅下滑
LBJ的歷史地位也蓋棺論定,終究贏不了老喬或甚至是我討厭的kobe
一切又要重新走向沉淪跟黑暗
G7還有機會嗎?
很妙的是,在一片看衰熱火的總版
酸酸們的看法都是溜馬實力比熱火強,但都看好熱火G7勝利
反倒是真正支持熱火看了遠比酸酸更多熱火球賽的球迷
卻認為熱火比溜馬強但G7感覺對於熱火是比較不利的(回想到2011的G6)
不覺得很奇怪嗎,怎麻會有完全相反的表述狀況?
兩方唯一相同的看法竟然都是認為那個實力比較差的會贏得G7的勝利?!
這點真的讓我感到十分的困惑(有高手能分析一下到底這是啥麻情況?!)
我個人的看法依然如賽前預測那樣
G7的考驗跟決勝在兩方的教練
誰能讓自己優勢多發揮一些且保護好自己的缺點
誰就是笑著的贏家!
如何讓Hibbert在防守端移開禁區,
如何利用兩側0度角的進攻來拉開Hibbert一直待在內線的防守
就是勝利的一半保證
剩下的另一半是如何限制G.Hill在進攻上的擋拆與穿針引線到禁區助攻
或甚至能用陷阱包夾掐死G.Hill在進攻上的路線
就是完成防守的重要課題
最後回到前面的廢文
如果今年熱火失利,那我想也是我身為NBA球迷粉絲該退休的時候
快20年的美好回憶跟快樂時光,我想也夠了該走到了盡頭
※ 引述《kart (=\)》之銘言:
: 翻譯這篇外電的心得有點五味雜陳,因為本來我認為下一場如果有人
: 中距離或是外線神準,那熱火還是有希望,又或者LBJ有決心打出
: 去年對Boston G6的神表現,那也很不錯。
: 然而綜合看到的幾篇外電,我對G7非常悲觀。因為我認為LBJ的心態
: 在隊友表態後,絕對不會有去年G6的強韌。
: 這有點想像不到,系列賽前我雖然認為打到G6G7會對熱火不利,
: 但是也只是認為因為健康,體力和士氣的關係會讓原有的優勢變成55或46波。
: 然而沒考量到的一點是以熱火這種冠軍級別以及季賽強大優勢的隊伍
: 竟然被戰績一般的球隊逼到死角時心理上微妙的化學反應的影響:
: 簡單説,就是良好的團隊氣氛產生自我質疑了。
: 這個現象和氣氛跟哪一年的生死戰最像?我想明眼人都知道:
: 2011的總冠軍賽,熱火主場的G6。
: 説實話事到如今我依然認為裁判公平點,這系列G4 or G5就收工了,
: 溜馬絕對是未來有機會挑戰熱火的強權,但是因為裁判幾個「玩味」的判決
: 讓這個現象提早產生。
: 單問溜馬有2009的魔術強嘛?2008或2010的老賽?2011的小牛?
: 顯然溜馬跟上述球隊還差那麼一點,而眼看著熱火可能就要收工了。
: 而這個熱火還是明顯優於2008-2011的騎士或熱火團隊
: 如果真的敗在這一輪,我想未來我應該會把看球時間留給別的事情吧,
: 2010是Lebron輸在手傷,2011也很失望但是至少認為只是第一年,在看下去
: 今年如果這樣輸,會非常不甘心,也認為NBA真的是有劇本的,
: (當然這劇本不見得是要溜馬贏,但是卻要「製造」一個Rivalry增加話題)
: 那就不會在看戲了。
: 前言廢話太多,來看看ESPN隨隊記者BW怎麼觀察的。
: INDIANAPOLIS -- Late Saturday night, LeBron James stepped up onto
: the podium deep inside Bankers Life Fieldhouse and briefly glanced
: at the vacant chair and unused microphone that was next to him.
: Down the hall, Dwyane Wade walked to the Miami Heat's bus in vivid
: designer clothes bought to sit in that seat and considered ways to
: remind James why there was a setting for two.
: 當Lebron踏上G6的賽後記者會現場時,眼睛喵向了旁邊空蕩蕩的椅子。
: 而Wade與此同時正穿著時髦走向隊巴,並且思考著如何提醒Lebron
: 記者會一向都是他們兩人一起是有原因的。
: The Indiana Pacers played strongly in the first elimination game
: they've seen this postseason and earned their 91-77 Game 6 victory
: to stay alive. It's now obvious the Pacers have a bright future
: ahead of them no matter how Monday's Game 7 plays out.
: 溜馬漂亮的克服了他們本季的第一回生死戰,不管下一戰結果如何,
: 沒有人會懷疑溜馬的未來是很光明的。
: But the defending champion Heat aren't just facing an elimination
: game -- they're facing an identity crisis.
: 相反的,衛冕軍則面對了生死戰,也面對了他們自我定位的危機。
: This one is not created by fans who enjoy seeing them fail or by
: media who are attracted to that story. It isn't about their future
: or free agency or luxury taxes or trades. It's about the present,
: the right now, and a big choice.
: 這個危機跟輿論或是酸民都無關。跟他們的未來和合約也無關。
: 這跟他們的現在,就是當下有關,一個重大的選擇來臨。
: It's about them losing sight of their plan and their grand
: agreement and whether or not that is the right thing to do.
: 這跟他們是否失去了他們當初合體意義的認同有關,
: 而放棄這項認同是否正確有關。
: Over the past few games, James has been talking and clearly
: thinking about his days in Cleveland. After Game 5, James launched
: a thousand conversations when he elected to say, "I kind of just
: went back to my Cleveland days" in explaining how he led a game-
: clinching run without the aid of Wade and Chris Bosh.
: 在過去幾場比賽,LBJ明顯的回想到了他還在騎士的日子,
: 尤其在G5賽後他的發言也提到。
: Saturday night and probably into Sunday morning, as the Heat's
: plane flew to Miami, and then maybe into Sunday afternoon, Wade's
: best move would be begging him not to go there. He should make
: James remember why he left Cleveland in the first place, wanting
: him to not repeat the mistakes of the past.
: 然而在G6到G7的中間,Wade最好的辦法就是乞求LBJ不要變回
: 騎士的LBJ,要LBJ不要再重蹈覆轍。
: James is going to have to mull which choice he takes, because the
: answer is not easy and it has some big consequences. Does he stay
: with the plan or does he keep drifting away from it, too concerned
: about the state of his teammates to trust them?
: 而LBJ也不會在媒體面前透漏太明白他的選擇,
: 因為答案並不容易,而這答案關乎甚鉅。
: 他要按照計畫走?隨心而走?還是太過關心隊友的狀態選擇信任隊友?
: When James finally lucidly explained his decision to sign with the
: Heat -- which happened not during "The Decision" when everyone was
: watching and wanted it, but actually in some emotional guard-
: dropping moments when he and the Heat beat the Boston Celtics in
: the 2011 playoffs -- James got to the bottom line.
: 當2011擊敗宿敵老賽時,LBJ說出了他埋藏以久的心底話。
: "I wanted to team up with some guys that would never die down in
: the moment," James said that night.
: 「我想要跟一群關鍵時刻不會神隱的隊友一起作戰。」
: This was a slap in the face of his former Cleveland teammates. It
: was a statement that ended friendships with some of them, or at
: least snapped some already frayed connections.
: 當然因為這句話給了當初騎士的隊友一巴掌,
: 也造成了很多友情的喪失。
: As James sat there alone after Game 6, that old feeling was
: creeping back into his head.
: 然而當昨天的比賽結束,這種過往的感覺又席上心頭。
: "I mean, we can state the obvious, they're both struggling," James
: said about Wade and Bosh. "When you're struggling, the best thing
: to get is a layup or a dunk. [Wade] missed a couple of them. ...
: Chris is struggling with his shot, and him hurting his ankle
: didn't help."
: 「我的意思是,我們可以很明顯的看出,CD都打的不好。當你手感不好時,
: 最好的方法就是接近藍框去攻擊-上籃或是灌籃之類的。然而Wade卻
: 投失了幾個簡單的上籃... 老包也一樣很掙扎,而他受傷的腳踝並沒有
: 幫助他。」LBJ說到CD的狀態時。
: This was the first time he's said it, but James has been playing
: like it for a few games now. Playing like he did in Cleveland.
: Grabbing the ball and trying to do everything. Taking more shots
: and taking away more shots from teammates. And yet having only
: marginal success as his team underachieves.
: 這是LBJ第一次這樣說,但是他已經這樣打了好幾場比賽-打的像他在
: 騎士隊的時候一樣。試著要做所有的事情。投球數上升,這也意味著
: 隊友的投球數下降。但是這樣做往往只有限度的成功。
: In short, not playing like he did when the Heat won the title last
: year. Playing like he did when he wore that Cavaliers uniform.
: 簡言之,並不像去年熱火奪冠時的打法,反而像他在騎士一樣。
: So as Wade sat alone at his locker Saturday -- after shooting 3-
: of-11, he didn't draw an invite to the interview room -- he
: reached out to James. Wade's message was easy to dismiss as hubris
: or downright denial at the state of his knee and the state of his
: game. Looking at it narrowly, it was almost laughable.
: 所以當Wade因為表現不佳而沒有被邀請去聯訪室時,他向LBJ放話了。
: 自然他的訊息你可以用他只是一種發洩或是拒對自己膝蓋和比賽狀態發言的
: 一種表現。如果狹義來看,你或許甚至認為他的發言很可笑。
: Here was Wade, who just had the two of the worst playoff games of
: his career in combination with the three worst games Bosh has had
: since he was a rookie, sending a message to James not to abandon
: them. Not to play the way he played in Cleveland.
: 現在的狀態就是一個剛打出自己史上最爛的兩場季後賽的Wade,
: 加上打了三場生涯最爛比賽的老包,聯合告訴LBJ並不要放棄他們。
: 不要重蹈當年在騎士的覆轍。
: If Wade and the Heat go down, he wants them to go down following
: the pact they made in James' mansion in late June of 2010 when
: they decided to sign together. He wants them to go down playing
: the way they won a championship. He doesn't want James to go down
: the way he did in Cleveland.
: 對Wade來說,就算熱火輸球,也要輸的像是當初合體時組成大夥約定
: 時的打法,輸的像是去年冠軍賽的熱火。他不想要LBJ輸的像是他在
: 騎士隊時的打法。
: "We've got guys individually who want to play better," Wade said.
: "But we've got to try to help each other out in this locker room
: and not leave it up to the individual to self-will it."
: Wade說「我們有很多很有動力想要打好球的個體,我們必須要互相幫助,
: 我們必須要團結,而不是讓一個人想要用自身威能去比賽。」
: That's a tough sell at this very moment. Wade is averaging 13.6
: points in the postseason. His knee is robbing him of his
: athleticism. Bosh is shooting 41 percent in the series and he's
: got a bad ankle. They look nothing like that offensive juggernaut
: that won 27 in a row in the middle of the season.
: 這樣說在現在這個摩門特其實不太具有說服力。
: Wade在這個季後賽平均只有13.6分。他的膝蓋並不給力是主因。
: 老包在這系列賽神隱,他的命中率只有41%,而他現在還有個壞掉的腳踝。
: 簡言之,現在的熱火看起來一點都不像27連勝時期的熱火。
: James is slowly pulling away. He's firing up 24 shots over the
: past few games. Wade and Bosh have seen their shot attempts
: plummet. It's old habits. Old failing habits.
: LBJ正慢慢的拉大和其他兩巨頭的差距。他過去三場平均要投24顆球。
: CD的投籃數則大幅銳減,這是個老現象了。老的,失敗的現象。
: "We've got to do a good job of making sure me and Chris have our
: opportunities to succeed throughout the game," Wade said. "That's
: something we're going to have to look at as a team."
: 「我們必須要讓老包和我有機會去融入比賽中。我們必須用團隊
: 的角度去看待這件事。」Wade如是說。
: That was Wade's coded way of saying: Trust us. Trust how we got
: here.
: 這是Wade的方式去告訴LBJ要信任大家,信任我們是怎麼走到今天這一步的。
: Bosh, as is his personality, was going it alone. He pointed the
: finger at himself.
: 而老包則是一貫的責怪自己。
: "I'm not going to make any excuses. I didn't show up for my
: teammates tonight, and I'm not going to let it happen again," Bosh
: said. "I'm really disappointed in myself."
: 「我並不會找藉口,我今晚神隱了。而我並不會讓這件事再發生。
: 我對自己非常失望。」老包說。
: Bosh has not had a great season by his standards. His fall-off in
: rebounding is inexplicable no matter what excuses he has offered.
: But he is much better than he's been showing, and he is not
: getting the chances he's earned over the past three seasons to
: right the ship.
: 老包本季以他自己的標準來說打的並不好,尤其他的籃板數下降
: 是沒有藉口去解釋的。但是我們也知道老包能打的更好,
: 他只是沒有足夠的機會。
: James can look at the stats and see that he's got more points than
: Wade and Bosh combined in this series. That goes right back to the
: Cavs days. In his final series in 2010, James had as many points
: as Mo Williams and Shaquille O'Neal combined in a losing effort
: against the Celtics.
: LBJ可以看統計然後發現目前得分比CD加起來還多。這跟當時他在騎士打老賽時
: 得分比莫不傳和歐肥加起來還多不是一樣嘛?
: Or James can look at his ring finger and see how the sharing of
: the load, in good times and bad, has worked.
: LBJ也可以選擇看看他手上的戒指是如何來的,看看讓隊友分擔責任,
: 是可以成功的。
: In Game 7, it's going to be one or the other. James is going to
: have to live with the choice and make no mistake, it's his choice.
: 在G7,LBJ會選擇,不論他選擇自己來或是信任隊友,
: 這都是他的選擇。
: "If anything it's on me," Heat coach Erik Spoelstra said. "I've
: got to find way to get those guys comfortable in areas where they
: can be aggressive. And that will be my focus the next 48 hours."
: Spo倒是毫不猶豫的攬下責任
: 「如果有什麼責難的話,這件事都是我的錯。我必須要找到讓CD
: 更舒服更有侵略性的方法。這會是我未來48小時的工作。」
: Spoelstra is trying everything. He's going down his bench and
: rolling out players he hasn't used in months. It's not a bad idea,
: he's not being stagnant. Dusting off Mike Miller and Joel Anthony
: helped a little. He'll be buried in the film room until Monday
: night. He'll come up with some motivational tactics and he'll try
: to sell the vision all over again. That's his job.
: Spo的確試過很多了。他今天甚至把塵封已久的板凳挖出來用。
: 顯然的他在未來兩天都會埋首A片。他會試著一些新方法,他也會
: 再一次用話術激勵人心。畢竟這是他的工作。
: There are some bolts to tighten and some tricky playing-time
: decisions to be made. But it is ultimately not on Spoelstra. It is
: going to be on James and what he feels he has to do.
: 自然的球隊螺絲不夠緊和一些場邊戰術是Spo該要負責的。
: 然後球隊最終的成敗卻不在Spo身上,而是在LBJ身上,在他的「感覺」。
: What's it going to be? Play like he's back in Cleveland and
: dominate the ball and hope for a transcendent Game 7 where he can
: overcome the brick wall that is Roy Hibbert, the wunderkind that
: is Paul George and the wily veteran that is David West? Or trust
: the tenets of the Big Three that James scrapped his life and
: reputation for because he believed in its possibilities.
: 所以他該怎麼打呢?打的像是他在騎士一樣,以一人之力對抗
: 溜馬的三個支柱?還是信任他的隊友,讓三巨頭表現呢?
: 畢竟他為了跟CD一起打球放棄了自己的聲望和一部分的生活。
: Sometimes a one-man transcendent game doesn't work, either. James
: did that once, scored 45 points in a Game 7 in 2008. Lost.
: 別忘了有時候一人之力也是不夠的,就像2008年他G7獨得45分卻輸球。
: "It's going to be tough," James said looking at Game 7. "I
: probably won't be able to relax until the game starts."
: 當LBJ被問到如何準備G7時,他說
: 「一定會很困難,我或許到開賽前都沒辦法鬆懈了。」
: Probably not. He's got a lot to consider between now and then.
: 或許不。從現在開始到開打前,他有非常多東西要考量。
: ===============================
: 心得:其實我不同意記者的觀察,
: 我認為LBJ今年打的一直很團隊,幾乎很少第一節就幹分,
: 這是因為熱火今年團隊戰力空前強大。
: 只要看今年一整季LBJ沒有爆分過就知道,
: 今年季後賽LBJ甚至還沒得過40分咧。
: 所以跟記者的想法相反,我認為在CD狀況可議的時候,LBJ根本還不夠獨!
: 去年的差別是有Wade一起爆氣,LBJ得40分,Wade也可以得個30分,
: 更有去年G6 LBJ那種勝負一肩扛的霸氣才能讓他們「之後」靠團隊
: 逆轉三個系列賽。今年或許是因為對手的關係,並不需要LBJ這樣做太多
: 即使這個系列賽,如同之前板友的說法,LBJ上半場也是在幫隊友找機會居多
: 我不知道Wade的出發點是疼惜LBJ,還是真的認為LBJ不夠信任他們
: 如果是前者,那或許還有點搞頭,如果是後者,那熱火不會有機會。
: 而在Wade這樣發言後,我相信明天的LBJ絕對不會變身成去年G6的LBJ,
: 反而會變成2011打小牛那種進退失據的LBJ,因為LBJ畢竟很看重友情。
: 而在Wade狀態因傷不好,Bosh也不好的狀態下,LBJ把機會給他們單打,
: 基本上就是把勝利拱手讓人。
: 再說一次,我認為今天就算LBJ真的打騎士籃球,也沒有任何藉口闖不過
: 這一支溜馬,66w的騎士打不過的是60w的魔術,61w的騎士打不過的是
: 衛冕軍老賽。66w的熱火即使真的只剩下騎士模式,也不應該打不過49w的溜馬
: 如同昨天Kerr和神米賽中說的,對馬刺就是另壹個系列賽了,
: 我認為認真的騎士模式的確打不贏馬刺,要靠三巨頭,
: 但是要闖過溜馬是可能的,只是要有這樣的決心,而非搖搖擺擺,
: 顧慮隊友太多。
: 今天Wade會這樣說我其實非常驚訝,我希望他的本意是疼惜LBJ的出發點,
: 而不是認為LBJ獨攬球權不給他們機會,畢竟在賽中曾經CD加起來是2/17
: 不是10/17!說沒有給他們機會我認為反而對LBJ的付出成為非常鮮明的對比。
: 這系列賽我其實沒有怪過Wade,我知道他的膝蓋問題,他也給了他的全部
: 但是現在全隊在面對G7,整個心態都亂掉了...
: 除非溜馬近關情怯,否則熱火明天勝算以現狀來看真的不高。=_=
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 122.116.229.29
推
06/03 03:19, , 1F
06/03 03:19, 1F
→
06/03 03:20, , 2F
06/03 03:20, 2F
推
06/03 03:23, , 3F
06/03 03:23, 3F
推
06/03 03:33, , 4F
06/03 03:33, 4F
→
06/03 03:34, , 5F
06/03 03:34, 5F
推
06/03 03:42, , 6F
06/03 03:42, 6F
→
06/03 03:43, , 7F
06/03 03:43, 7F
推
06/03 03:43, , 8F
06/03 03:43, 8F
→
06/03 03:44, , 9F
06/03 03:44, 9F
→
06/03 03:44, , 10F
06/03 03:44, 10F
→
06/03 03:45, , 11F
06/03 03:45, 11F
推
06/03 06:26, , 12F
06/03 06:26, 12F
→
06/03 06:28, , 13F
06/03 06:28, 13F
→
06/03 06:28, , 14F
06/03 06:28, 14F
→
06/03 06:29, , 15F
06/03 06:29, 15F
→
06/03 06:31, , 16F
06/03 06:31, 16F
推
06/03 07:34, , 17F
06/03 07:34, 17F
推
06/03 07:36, , 18F
06/03 07:36, 18F
推
06/03 07:39, , 19F
06/03 07:39, 19F
推
06/03 08:06, , 20F
06/03 08:06, 20F
推
06/03 08:11, , 21F
06/03 08:11, 21F
推
06/03 08:11, , 22F
06/03 08:11, 22F
→
06/03 08:12, , 23F
06/03 08:12, 23F
→
06/03 08:12, , 24F
06/03 08:12, 24F
→
06/03 08:13, , 25F
06/03 08:13, 25F
→
06/03 08:13, , 26F
06/03 08:13, 26F
→
06/03 08:14, , 27F
06/03 08:14, 27F
→
06/03 08:15, , 28F
06/03 08:15, 28F
→
06/03 08:15, , 29F
06/03 08:15, 29F
→
06/03 08:16, , 30F
06/03 08:16, 30F
→
06/03 08:17, , 31F
06/03 08:17, 31F
推
06/03 08:21, , 32F
06/03 08:21, 32F
推
06/03 08:22, , 33F
06/03 08:22, 33F
→
06/03 08:22, , 34F
06/03 08:22, 34F
→
06/03 08:23, , 35F
06/03 08:23, 35F
→
06/03 08:24, , 36F
06/03 08:24, 36F
→
06/03 08:25, , 37F
06/03 08:25, 37F
推
06/03 08:36, , 38F
06/03 08:36, 38F
→
06/03 08:36, , 39F
06/03 08:36, 39F
推
06/03 08:38, , 40F
06/03 08:38, 40F
→
06/03 08:39, , 41F
06/03 08:39, 41F
→
06/03 08:40, , 42F
06/03 08:40, 42F
推
06/03 08:43, , 43F
06/03 08:43, 43F
推
06/03 09:00, , 44F
06/03 09:00, 44F
→
06/03 09:03, , 45F
06/03 09:03, 45F
→
06/03 09:04, , 46F
06/03 09:04, 46F
→
06/03 09:04, , 47F
06/03 09:04, 47F
推
06/03 09:10, , 48F
06/03 09:10, 48F
→
06/03 09:33, , 49F
06/03 09:33, 49F
→
06/03 09:33, , 50F
06/03 09:33, 50F
→
06/03 09:46, , 51F
06/03 09:46, 51F
→
06/03 09:47, , 52F
06/03 09:47, 52F
推
06/03 10:27, , 53F
06/03 10:27, 53F
推
06/03 10:31, , 54F
06/03 10:31, 54F
→
06/03 10:32, , 55F
06/03 10:32, 55F
→
06/03 10:32, , 56F
06/03 10:32, 56F
推
06/03 10:34, , 57F
06/03 10:34, 57F
→
06/03 10:34, , 58F
06/03 10:34, 58F
→
06/03 10:35, , 59F
06/03 10:35, 59F
→
06/03 10:36, , 60F
06/03 10:36, 60F
推
06/03 10:39, , 61F
06/03 10:39, 61F
→
06/03 10:39, , 62F
06/03 10:39, 62F
推
06/03 10:54, , 63F
06/03 10:54, 63F
→
06/03 10:55, , 64F
06/03 10:55, 64F
推
06/03 13:02, , 65F
06/03 13:02, 65F
→
06/03 13:03, , 66F
06/03 13:03, 66F
→
06/03 13:03, , 67F
06/03 13:03, 67F
→
06/03 13:04, , 68F
06/03 13:04, 68F
→
06/03 13:04, , 69F
06/03 13:04, 69F
推
06/03 14:22, , 70F
06/03 14:22, 70F
→
06/03 14:23, , 71F
06/03 14:23, 71F
→
06/03 14:23, , 72F
06/03 14:23, 72F
→
06/03 14:24, , 73F
06/03 14:24, 73F
推
06/03 14:31, , 74F
06/03 14:31, 74F
推
06/03 16:05, , 75F
06/03 16:05, 75F
→
06/03 16:06, , 76F
06/03 16:06, 76F
→
06/03 16:06, , 77F
06/03 16:06, 77F
→
06/03 16:07, , 78F
06/03 16:07, 78F
→
06/03 16:08, , 79F
06/03 16:08, 79F
→
06/03 16:09, , 80F
06/03 16:09, 80F
→
06/03 16:10, , 81F
06/03 16:10, 81F
→
06/03 16:11, , 82F
06/03 16:11, 82F
→
06/03 16:11, , 83F
06/03 16:11, 83F
→
06/03 16:12, , 84F
06/03 16:12, 84F
推
06/03 16:32, , 85F
06/03 16:32, 85F
→
06/03 16:33, , 86F
06/03 16:33, 86F
推
06/03 16:36, , 87F
06/03 16:36, 87F
推
06/03 20:51, , 88F
06/03 20:51, 88F
推
06/04 01:08, , 89F
06/04 01:08, 89F
→
06/04 01:09, , 90F
06/04 01:09, 90F
→
06/04 01:10, , 91F
06/04 01:10, 91F
→
06/04 01:10, , 92F
06/04 01:10, 92F
→
06/04 01:11, , 93F
06/04 01:11, 93F
→
06/04 01:11, , 94F
06/04 01:11, 94F
討論串 (同標題文章)