Re: [心得] 武術套路之我見
※ 引述《takano (唐獅子牡丹)》之銘言:
: 唉...
: 套路說穿了就是為了表演的啊
何以見得? 如果你有看過那些流傳下來的拳譜拳歌 你可以發現裡面的招式是有順序的
而且有些招式還會重複好幾遍 為什麼? 就是為了將這些招式組合成一整個套路 方便記憶
: 這麼多人推文,講了一大堆招式連招假想敵啥的
: 就是沒講到重點,是糊塗還是國王的新衣啊?!
: 我反問
: 要對敵要練單招,然後單招與單招之間連起來成為連續動作...
: 那我只練"單招"與"連續動作"而不練套路的話
: 有任何影響嗎??看起來沒有吧?!下文中所有提到的"套路需求"
: 都可以透過"單招"與"數個單招接連起來的連續動作"達成
: 不是嗎?
: 方便記憶連續動作??這更是莫名其妙的本末倒置說法
我沒有說過方便記憶連續動作啊 我說的是方便記憶整套拳
: 到底是我把"想練的連續動作"拿出來單練好記
: 還是我把整套套路背起來然後自我說服說"其中的這一段是連續攻擊動作"
: 比較好記??
如果你把想練的連續動作拿出來記 當然好記 因為動作少很多
可是這樣對你記憶整套拳有幫助嗎?
: 真要更進一步說,或許套路同時兼具了教材歸納以及分級(特別是某壇)的意味在
: 有一點類似空手道跆拳道要分各種色帶的意味在
: 方便老師歸納教材以及進行教學的差別化
: ※ 引述《spring69953 (開開)》之銘言:
: : 標題: [心得] 武術套路之我見
: : 時間: Fri Sep 10 04:57:24 2010
: : 大家好 小弟我學習國術已有五年多
: : 從甚麼都不會的初學者 到現在略懂一二的入門者
: : 這之間有許多的心得感想 今天想跟大家分享我對於套路的看法
: : 有說的不對的地方可以提出來討論 以下是我的淺見:
: : 套路的用處在於方便練習記憶 一套拳那麼多招式 要怎麼才好記 就是要靠套路
: : 套路就是將招式組合起來成為連續動作
: : 看到這一定有人會想問:那學套路怎麼用在實戰上呢?
: : 其實嚴格說起來 套路不是用在實戰上的 用在實戰上的是招式
: : 想要在實戰中把所學的招式用出來 那就要靠不斷的練習
: : 把招式用身體記住 當別人突然一拳打來才會來得及反應
: : 接著回到套路上 為什麼套路要這樣編?原因就是順暢跟方便記憶
: : 如果有一個套路打個兩招就轉身一次那打起來一定很不順而且相當難記
: : 而且某些招式之間是可以連續施展的 這些招式在套路中就會被排在一起
: : 練習時這段就可以一口氣連續打完 用電玩的講法就是接段 這就是套路的功用
: : --
: : ◆ From: 140.117.193.59
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.117.193.59
→
09/11 00:27, , 1F
09/11 00:27, 1F
→
09/11 00:28, , 2F
09/11 00:28, 2F
→
09/11 00:29, , 3F
09/11 00:29, 3F
→
09/11 00:30, , 4F
09/11 00:30, 4F
→
09/11 01:36, , 5F
09/11 01:36, 5F
→
09/11 01:38, , 6F
09/11 01:38, 6F
→
09/11 01:38, , 7F
09/11 01:38, 7F
→
09/11 01:39, , 8F
09/11 01:39, 8F
→
09/11 01:39, , 9F
09/11 01:39, 9F
→
09/11 01:40, , 10F
09/11 01:40, 10F
→
09/11 01:41, , 11F
09/11 01:41, 11F
→
09/11 01:42, , 12F
09/11 01:42, 12F
→
09/11 01:42, , 13F
09/11 01:42, 13F
推
09/11 01:45, , 14F
09/11 01:45, 14F
→
09/11 01:45, , 15F
09/11 01:45, 15F
→
09/11 01:48, , 16F
09/11 01:48, 16F
推
09/11 01:53, , 17F
09/11 01:53, 17F
→
09/11 01:54, , 18F
09/11 01:54, 18F
→
09/11 02:05, , 19F
09/11 02:05, 19F
→
09/11 02:05, , 20F
09/11 02:05, 20F
→
09/11 02:08, , 21F
09/11 02:08, 21F
→
09/11 02:09, , 22F
09/11 02:09, 22F
→
09/11 02:09, , 23F
09/11 02:09, 23F
→
09/11 02:10, , 24F
09/11 02:10, 24F
→
09/11 02:10, , 25F
09/11 02:10, 25F
→
09/11 02:12, , 26F
09/11 02:12, 26F
推
09/11 10:10, , 27F
09/11 10:10, 27F
→
09/11 10:10, , 28F
09/11 10:10, 28F
推
09/11 10:14, , 29F
09/11 10:14, 29F
→
09/11 10:14, , 30F
09/11 10:14, 30F
→
09/11 10:15, , 31F
09/11 10:15, 31F
→
09/11 10:16, , 32F
09/11 10:16, 32F
推
09/11 10:19, , 33F
09/11 10:19, 33F
→
09/11 10:55, , 34F
09/11 10:55, 34F
→
09/11 10:56, , 35F
09/11 10:56, 35F
推
09/11 12:58, , 36F
09/11 12:58, 36F
→
09/11 12:58, , 37F
09/11 12:58, 37F
→
09/11 12:58, , 38F
09/11 12:58, 38F
→
09/11 12:59, , 39F
09/11 12:59, 39F
推
09/11 21:47, , 40F
09/11 21:47, 40F
→
09/11 21:47, , 41F
09/11 21:47, 41F
→
09/11 21:47, , 42F
09/11 21:47, 42F
→
09/11 21:47, , 43F
09/11 21:47, 43F
推
09/11 22:10, , 44F
09/11 22:10, 44F
→
09/11 22:10, , 45F
09/11 22:10, 45F
→
09/11 22:11, , 46F
09/11 22:11, 46F
→
09/11 22:11, , 47F
09/11 22:11, 47F
推
09/11 22:13, , 48F
09/11 22:13, 48F
→
09/11 22:14, , 49F
09/11 22:14, 49F
→
09/11 22:14, , 50F
09/11 22:14, 50F
推
09/11 22:18, , 51F
09/11 22:18, 51F
→
09/11 22:19, , 52F
09/11 22:19, 52F
推
09/11 22:19, , 53F
09/11 22:19, 53F
→
09/11 22:20, , 54F
09/11 22:20, 54F
→
09/11 22:20, , 55F
09/11 22:20, 55F
→
09/11 22:20, , 56F
09/11 22:20, 56F
→
09/11 22:21, , 57F
09/11 22:21, 57F
→
09/11 22:21, , 58F
09/11 22:21, 58F
→
09/11 22:21, , 59F
09/11 22:21, 59F
→
09/11 22:21, , 60F
09/11 22:21, 60F
→
09/11 22:21, , 61F
09/11 22:21, 61F
→
09/11 22:22, , 62F
09/11 22:22, 62F
→
09/11 22:22, , 63F
09/11 22:22, 63F
推
09/11 22:24, , 64F
09/11 22:24, 64F
→
09/11 22:24, , 65F
09/11 22:24, 65F
推
09/11 22:26, , 66F
09/11 22:26, 66F
→
09/11 22:27, , 67F
09/11 22:27, 67F
→
09/11 22:27, , 68F
09/11 22:27, 68F
→
09/11 22:28, , 69F
09/11 22:28, 69F
推
09/11 22:29, , 70F
09/11 22:29, 70F
→
09/11 22:29, , 71F
09/11 22:29, 71F
→
09/11 22:29, , 72F
09/11 22:29, 72F
→
09/11 22:30, , 73F
09/11 22:30, 73F
→
09/11 22:30, , 74F
09/11 22:30, 74F
→
09/11 22:30, , 75F
09/11 22:30, 75F
→
09/11 22:30, , 76F
09/11 22:30, 76F
推
09/11 22:35, , 77F
09/11 22:35, 77F
→
09/11 22:35, , 78F
09/11 22:35, 78F
推
09/11 22:40, , 79F
09/11 22:40, 79F
推
09/11 22:40, , 80F
09/11 22:40, 80F
→
09/11 22:40, , 81F
09/11 22:40, 81F
→
09/11 22:41, , 82F
09/11 22:41, 82F
→
09/11 22:41, , 83F
09/11 22:41, 83F
→
09/11 22:42, , 84F
09/11 22:42, 84F
→
09/11 22:43, , 85F
09/11 22:43, 85F
→
09/11 22:43, , 86F
09/11 22:43, 86F
→
09/11 22:44, , 87F
09/11 22:44, 87F
推
09/11 23:31, , 88F
09/11 23:31, 88F
→
09/11 23:31, , 89F
09/11 23:31, 89F
→
09/11 23:32, , 90F
09/11 23:32, 90F
→
09/12 00:15, , 91F
09/12 00:15, 91F
推
09/12 10:58, , 92F
09/12 10:58, 92F
→
09/12 10:59, , 93F
09/12 10:59, 93F
→
12/06 04:18, , 94F
12/06 04:18, 94F
討論串 (同標題文章)
本文引述了以下文章的的內容:
心得
13
66
完整討論串 (本文為第 3 之 17 篇):
心得
14
53
心得
13
66
心得
19
94
心得
1
1
心得
1
3
心得
9
24
心得
3
20
心得
5
41
心得
2
2