[新聞] 全台施工捷運 台中進度最慢
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2011/new/dec/10/today-center9-2.htm
全台施工捷運 台中進度最慢
目前全台施工中捷運,台中烏日北屯線進度最落後(記者詹朝陽攝)
〔記者唐在馨/台中報導〕民進黨市議會黨團昨天批評,台中捷運烏日北屯線,目前進度
九%,不但比原訂進度十二.五二%落後,也是目前全台施工中捷運最落後的,而唯一的
一條捷運工程進度都落後,要如何相信BRT的績效?
對此,市府交通局長林良泰說,目前進度仍照既有的目標進行,市府會持續要求台北市捷
運局,一定要在一○四年完成試營運的目標。
民進黨議員邱素貞昨則表示,有民眾向她陳情,指根據市府說法「BRT的營運速度,每
小時約十五到二十五公里」,邱素貞質疑,台中港路平常車流量已經很大,如今大遠百即
將開幕,未來勢必衝擊交通順暢,台中港路交通恐癱瘓,陷入黑暗期。
邱素貞指出,BRT車站過多會拖延整體的行車時間,而每小時約十五到二十五公里的速
度,較自己開車或騎車還慢,對捷運運量的培養可能沒有太多實質的幫助。
對此,林良泰則表示,基本上上述數據是指交通尖峰期,他估計如果BRT上路,平均時
速會到一小時五十公里。
而台中市議會連日來各黨派幾乎都已對大眾捷運政策表態,包括議長張清堂、無黨籍議員
黃錫嘉等人,都已要求「只要把捷運二字拿掉」,承認BRT是公車,就會接受BRT預
算。
胡︰BRT失敗就下台
而民進黨團則是質疑市政府意圖以「公車」換「捷運」,同時反對只拿一條中港路來做B
RT的「試驗道路」,國民黨團則是支持BRT,林良泰說,會努力爭取預算過關,而市
長胡志強昨天在議員追問下,也再次擔保「如果BRT失敗,就辭職下台」。
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
疑點:
BRT車站過多會拖延整體的行車時間,而每小時約「十五到二十五」公里的速度
林良泰則表示,基本上上述數據是指交通尖峰期,他估計如果BRT上路,「平均時
^^^^^^^^^^
速」會到一小時「五十」公里。
平均時速50km/h?? 飆車?? 充美麗數字?? 欺騙市民?
1. 不包含上下站:
尖峰時段 15~25 km/h (太慢)=遊樂園小火車→沒有捷運功能(用騎車開車的還比較快)
50km/h (較合理),扣掉停站時間 平均時速下降 跟捷運平均速率差不多
2.包含上下站:
尖峰時段 15~25 km/h (合理)
50km/h?? 是飆車?? 最高行駛時速多少?? 比MRT快?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 122.117.45.182
推
12/10 20:54, , 1F
12/10 20:54, 1F
→
12/10 20:56, , 2F
12/10 20:56, 2F
→
12/10 20:56, , 3F
12/10 20:56, 3F
→
12/10 20:58, , 4F
12/10 20:58, 4F
推
12/10 20:59, , 5F
12/10 20:59, 5F
→
12/10 20:59, , 6F
12/10 20:59, 6F
噓
12/10 21:02, , 7F
12/10 21:02, 7F
→
12/10 21:02, , 8F
12/10 21:02, 8F
→
12/10 21:03, , 9F
12/10 21:03, 9F
→
12/10 21:04, , 10F
12/10 21:04, 10F
→
12/10 21:04, , 11F
12/10 21:04, 11F
→
12/10 21:05, , 12F
12/10 21:05, 12F
→
12/10 21:05, , 13F
12/10 21:05, 13F
推
12/10 21:06, , 14F
12/10 21:06, 14F
→
12/10 21:06, , 15F
12/10 21:06, 15F
→
12/10 21:07, , 16F
12/10 21:07, 16F
→
12/10 21:08, , 17F
12/10 21:08, 17F
→
12/10 21:09, , 18F
12/10 21:09, 18F
推
12/10 21:10, , 19F
12/10 21:10, 19F
→
12/10 21:11, , 20F
12/10 21:11, 20F
→
12/10 21:17, , 21F
12/10 21:17, 21F
推
12/10 21:18, , 22F
12/10 21:18, 22F
→
12/10 21:21, , 23F
12/10 21:21, 23F
→
12/10 21:21, , 24F
12/10 21:21, 24F
→
12/10 21:22, , 25F
12/10 21:22, 25F
→
12/10 21:42, , 26F
12/10 21:42, 26F
推
12/10 21:45, , 27F
12/10 21:45, 27F
→
12/10 21:45, , 28F
12/10 21:45, 28F
→
12/10 21:54, , 29F
12/10 21:54, 29F
推
12/10 21:55, , 30F
12/10 21:55, 30F
→
12/10 21:59, , 31F
12/10 21:59, 31F
→
12/10 22:00, , 32F
12/10 22:00, 32F
→
12/10 22:04, , 33F
12/10 22:04, 33F
→
12/10 22:04, , 34F
12/10 22:04, 34F
→
12/10 22:11, , 35F
12/10 22:11, 35F
推
12/10 22:13, , 36F
12/10 22:13, 36F
→
12/10 22:14, , 37F
12/10 22:14, 37F
→
12/10 22:14, , 38F
12/10 22:14, 38F
→
12/10 22:14, , 39F
12/10 22:14, 39F
還有 204 則推文
→
12/11 00:04, , 244F
12/11 00:04, 244F
→
12/11 00:04, , 245F
12/11 00:04, 245F
→
12/11 00:04, , 246F
12/11 00:04, 246F
→
12/11 00:05, , 247F
12/11 00:05, 247F
→
12/11 00:05, , 248F
12/11 00:05, 248F
→
12/11 00:05, , 249F
12/11 00:05, 249F
→
12/11 00:05, , 250F
12/11 00:05, 250F
→
12/11 00:06, , 251F
12/11 00:06, 251F
→
12/11 00:06, , 252F
12/11 00:06, 252F
→
12/11 00:06, , 253F
12/11 00:06, 253F
推
12/11 00:07, , 254F
12/11 00:07, 254F
→
12/11 00:08, , 255F
12/11 00:08, 255F
→
12/11 00:08, , 256F
12/11 00:08, 256F
→
12/11 00:09, , 257F
12/11 00:09, 257F
→
12/11 00:10, , 258F
12/11 00:10, 258F
→
12/11 00:10, , 259F
12/11 00:10, 259F
→
12/11 00:10, , 260F
12/11 00:10, 260F
→
12/11 00:11, , 261F
12/11 00:11, 261F
→
12/11 00:12, , 262F
12/11 00:12, 262F
→
12/11 00:12, , 263F
12/11 00:12, 263F
→
12/11 00:13, , 264F
12/11 00:13, 264F
→
12/11 00:13, , 265F
12/11 00:13, 265F
→
12/11 00:14, , 266F
12/11 00:14, 266F
→
12/11 00:14, , 267F
12/11 00:14, 267F
推
12/11 00:14, , 268F
12/11 00:14, 268F
→
12/11 00:14, , 269F
12/11 00:14, 269F
→
12/11 00:15, , 270F
12/11 00:15, 270F
→
12/11 00:15, , 271F
12/11 00:15, 271F
→
12/11 00:15, , 272F
12/11 00:15, 272F
→
12/11 00:16, , 273F
12/11 00:16, 273F
→
12/11 00:17, , 274F
12/11 00:17, 274F
→
12/11 00:17, , 275F
12/11 00:17, 275F
→
12/11 00:20, , 276F
12/11 00:20, 276F
推
12/11 00:22, , 277F
12/11 00:22, 277F
→
12/11 00:22, , 278F
12/11 00:22, 278F
推
12/11 00:27, , 279F
12/11 00:27, 279F
→
12/11 00:29, , 280F
12/11 00:29, 280F
→
12/11 00:30, , 281F
12/11 00:30, 281F
→
12/11 00:32, , 282F
12/11 00:32, 282F
→
12/11 10:07, , 283F
12/11 10:07, 283F
討論串 (同標題文章)