Re: [外電] 今日光芒紅襪戰使用的投手調度操作
※ 引述《youngluke (luke)》之銘言:
: https://www.mlb.com/news/red-sox-rays-substitutions-confusion-protest
: ST. PETERSBURG -- Adam Kolarek stood on the mound, confused as to what the
: discussion was on the field. He had warmed up three times over the last 20
: minutes and was waiting on word from the umpires before he resumed throwing.
: Adam Kolarek站在丘上,對於場上的爭議感到困惑,他在20分鐘內熱身了3次
: 目前正在重新投球前等待裁判的指示
: “Travis [d’Arnaud] was asking me, ‘Hey, do you want to throw a couple?’
: and I told him that I was just going to hold off until it’s over,” Kolarek
: said. “I was pretty much content waiting until it was over. I think
: everybody understood that I needed a couple, so I threw three [warmup
: pitches] and I was good.”
: The Rays and the Red Sox have played some wacky games, but perhaps the most
: unique part of the season series occurred on Wednesday in Tampa Bay’s 3-2
: win over Boston at Tropicana Field.
: 今天光芒3:2打敗紅襪的比賽或許是今年最有趣的比賽之一
: In the eighth inning, with the Rays holding a one-run lead, manager Kevin
: Cash went with Kolarek to start the frame on the mound. Kolarek was tasked
: with retiring Sam Travis, and after he got him to pop out, Cash went back out
: to the mound to bring in the right-handed Chaz Roe while moving Kolarek to
: first base. Ji-Man Choi was removed from the game.
: 八局上半,一分領先的光芒,讓Kolarek先上場投球,他成功解決了Travis
: 之後,Cash上來換人,讓Roe接替投球,Kolarek去守一壘,讓崔志萬退場
從原文來解讀應該比較準確
讓Roe接替投球,Kolarek去守一壘,崔志萬退場
當然可以解讀為取消DH,這時影響的會有Roe/Kolarek/Meadows/崔志萬
這時光芒選擇的是崔志萬退場,但Meadows被隱藏著沒被動到
如果沒有後續的狀況,直接進入到下半局,光芒也不再做其他動作的話
就會發現Roe是P/Kolarek是1壘/Meadows是DH,感覺好像沒問題
但
Kolarek是投過球的,不是直接上場接替一壘,這就是Cora所提的問題
崔志萬退場是事實,那代表投手指定打擊的Meadows呢?
紅襪問:難道不需要先指定一名選手
但感覺光芒心想:反正就算判定是Roe是P/Kolarek打DH位置而取消DH去打1壘,對他們也ok
: Once Roe retired Mookie Betts, Cash went back to Kolarek to face the
: lefty-hitting Rafael Devers, with Nate Lowe coming in to play first base.
: During the substitutions, the Rays lost their designated hitter by moving
: Kolarek to first base, as he was placed in the No. 3 spot in the lineup --
: where DH Austin Meadows previously was -- and slated to lead off in the
: bottom of the eighth.
: Roe解決了Betts,Cash再度上來調度,讓Kolarek面對Devers,讓Lowe上場守一壘
: 這過程中,他們取消了DH,Kolarek被放到了Meadows的3棒DH打序
而光芒所堅持的是,其實他們在這半局中自行解決了這個問題
形成了一個timing double switch
只是這又跟國聯常發生的double switch有點差異
畢竟又多牽扯進了一個DH打者
但我想,原則上應該光芒是沒問題的,因為至少上場球員人數並沒有錯
就算Cora抗議成功,其實也就只是提前取消DH,讓Kolarek去打3棒
這跟最後呈現的結果並無差異,只是多了Cora抗議的20分鐘而已(菸~)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.233.114.164 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/MLB/M.1564029414.A.53D.html
→
07/25 12:45,
4年前
, 1F
07/25 12:45, 1F
→
07/25 12:46,
4年前
, 2F
07/25 12:46, 2F
→
07/25 12:55,
4年前
, 3F
07/25 12:55, 3F
→
07/25 13:12,
4年前
, 4F
07/25 13:12, 4F
→
07/25 13:13,
4年前
, 5F
07/25 13:13, 5F
→
07/25 13:14,
4年前
, 6F
07/25 13:14, 6F
推
07/25 13:19,
4年前
, 7F
07/25 13:19, 7F
→
07/25 13:19,
4年前
, 8F
07/25 13:19, 8F
→
07/25 13:20,
4年前
, 9F
07/25 13:20, 9F
→
07/25 13:37,
4年前
, 10F
07/25 13:37, 10F
推
07/25 13:49,
4年前
, 11F
07/25 13:49, 11F
→
07/25 13:50,
4年前
, 12F
07/25 13:50, 12F
推
07/25 14:36,
4年前
, 13F
07/25 14:36, 13F
→
07/25 14:37,
4年前
, 14F
07/25 14:37, 14F
推
07/25 16:08,
4年前
, 15F
07/25 16:08, 15F
→
07/25 16:08,
4年前
, 16F
07/25 16:08, 16F
→
07/25 16:09,
4年前
, 17F
07/25 16:09, 17F
推
07/25 16:54,
4年前
, 18F
07/25 16:54, 18F
推
07/25 17:10,
4年前
, 19F
07/25 17:10, 19F
推
07/25 21:31,
4年前
, 20F
07/25 21:31, 20F
→
07/25 21:31,
4年前
, 21F
07/25 21:31, 21F
推
07/25 22:06,
4年前
, 22F
07/25 22:06, 22F
→
07/26 00:37,
4年前
, 23F
07/26 00:37, 23F
→
07/26 00:37,
4年前
, 24F
07/26 00:37, 24F
→
07/26 00:37,
4年前
, 25F
07/26 00:37, 25F
→
07/26 00:38,
4年前
, 26F
07/26 00:38, 26F
討論串 (同標題文章)