[文法] I felt my life meaningless 這句文法

看板Eng-Class作者 (叫我歐批踢~)時間15年前 (2010/09/02 02:34), 編輯推噓0(0推 0噓 27→)
留言27則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
因為英文的語法有些混淆，所以請問一下 版上英文強者 I felt that my life was meaningless. 可以簡寫成 I felt my life meaningless 嗎 ? 不知道改寫的英文正不正確，是語法對的句子嗎? 請幫忙解答了。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 122.117.187.251
→
09/02 03:11, , 1F
古今以來會做出那種敘述的人不會少，換句話說會以文字寫出
09/02 03:11, 1F
→
09/02 03:12, , 2F
那種心情的例子不應該少。如果你的寫法是*慣用寫法*，理論
09/02 03:12, 2F
→
09/02 03:13, , 3F
上英文出版物會出現那種寫法的比率不應該低，但是....
09/02 03:13, 3F
→
09/02 03:13, , 4F
09/02 03:13, 4F
如果是I felt my life was meaningless. 這句話文法正確無誤。 因為只是省略that. 我的焦點在於I felt something wrong. 是對的， 不知道I felt my life meaningless. 可不可行。 就請各位幫忙解答了^^ ※ 編輯: optimistic13 來自: 122.117.187.251 (09/02 03:16)
→
09/02 03:45, , 5F
I felt something wrong.應是省略felt後的that跟sth.後的
09/02 03:45, 5F
→
09/02 03:48, , 6F
(忘記我上面的恍神發言吧 囧)
09/02 03:48, 6F
→
09/02 03:49, , 7F
網路找到的feel例句：I felt myself unable to leave the
09/02 03:49, 7F
→
09/02 03:50, , 8F
city. myself代換成my life unable代換成meaningless
09/02 03:50, 8F
→
09/02 03:52, , 9F
(unable後的部分主要是形容unable 可無視)
09/02 03:52, 9F
→
09/02 03:53, , 10F
所以我想I felt my life meaningless是可行的 (..如果我
09/02 03:53, 10F
→
09/02 03:54, , 11F
找到的例句沒錯的話..)
09/02 03:54, 11F
→
09/02 12:42, , 12F
慣用用法來說feel + ____ + adj，空格中一般是代名詞
09/02 12:42, 12F
→
09/02 12:42, , 13F
你覺得文法對...但是不見得
09/02 12:42, 13F
→
09/02 12:44, , 14F
應該說不見得會有人這樣講，有可能是語感的問題
09/02 12:44, 14F
→
09/02 12:45, , 15F
通常這句的講法應該是I feel like my life is meaningless.
09/02 12:45, 15F
→
09/02 12:45, , 16F
學到一定程度的時候就不能只是判定文法對還是錯了
09/02 12:45, 16F
→
09/02 13:53, , 17F
我說I felt my life was meaningless.這句文法正確
09/02 13:53, 17F
→
09/02 13:54, , 18F
是因為，遠東高一單字是用這樣的句型當例句，所以
09/02 13:54, 18F
→
09/02 13:55, , 19F
你覺得教科書例句有問題就是了?
09/02 13:55, 19F
→
09/02 13:59, , 20F
對不起可能誤導你了...
09/02 13:59, 20F
→
09/02 13:59, , 21F
我是說I felt my life meaningless這樣的句子，文法正確
09/02 13:59, 21F
→
09/02 13:59, , 22F
可是卻不一定有人會說
09/02 13:59, 22F
→
09/02 14:00, , 23F
至於I felt my life was meaningless沒問題
09/02 14:00, 23F
→
09/02 18:58, , 24F
I felt that my life was meaningless.
09/02 18:58, 24F
→
09/02 18:58, , 25F
=I felt (that) my life was meaningless.
09/02 18:58, 25F
→
09/02 18:58, , 26F
=I felt (that) my life (which was) meaningless.
09/02 18:58, 26F
→
09/02 19:00, , 27F
上面寫錯 應該是 I felt my life (which was) meaningless
09/02 19:00, 27F
‣ 更多 optimistic13 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1CVfpBVN (Eng-Class)
‣ 更多 optimistic13 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1CVfpBVN (Eng-Class)