Fw: [爆卦] 歐洲商會–台灣軍事改革不足，預算過低
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1c8D8B-z ]
作者: usnavyseal (usmarine2008) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [爆卦] 歐洲商會–台灣軍事改革不足，預算過低
時間: Thu Apr 18 15:55:52 2024
https://www.ecct.com.tw/factors-affecting-taiwan-us-and-china-relations/
https://i.imgur.com/fWyAG8R.png
剛看到歐洲在台商會舉辦的座談會「台灣、中國和美國：未來風險」
其中有一段提到了台灣的現況和軍事改革
https://i.imgur.com/BLUKvmv.png
Taiwan's new president will be inaugurated on 20 May and Americans will go to
the polls in November. Despite an increase in grey zone tactics in the Taiwan
Strait in recent years and rising concerns in the west, there is no apparent
sense of an impending crisis in Taiwan. This has led to some concerns that
Taiwanese are too complacent about the threats, especially since the response
of Ukrainians to Russia's invasion has raised the bar of expectations for
other countries facing external threats.
台灣的新總統將於5月20日就職，美國將於11月舉行大選。儘管近年來台灣海峽採取的灰
色地帶戰術有所增加，西方國家的關注也在上升，但在台灣並未明顯感受到迫在眉睫的危
機。這引起了一些人的擔憂，認為台灣人對於威脅過於自滿，特別是因為烏克蘭對俄羅斯
入侵的反應提高了其他面臨外部威脅國家的期望標準。
Taiwan also does not compare favourably to Israel, where there is an
overwhelming commitment to national survival. While Taiwan has taken some
actions in recent years to bolster its defences, including increasing defence
spending and the length of compulsory military service from four months to
one year, critics in the west view this as insufficient. For example,
Israelis do much longer periods of military service and 60-90 days of annual
service in reserve forces thereafter. Taiwan's military establishment has
been described as conservative and too enamoured with flashy and expensive
military hardware that may not survive a large-scale enemy attack. This has
led Taiwan's military to begin paying more attention to asymmetric warfare
and related hardware but the limited budget leaves many gaps in Taiwan's
overall defence.
相比之下，台灣與以色列的情況，後者對國家生存有壓倒性的承諾，顯得不夠積極。雖然
台灣近年來採取了一些行動來加強防禦，包括增加國防開支和將義務兵役服役時間從四個
月延長到一年，但西方批評者認為這還不夠。以色列人進行的軍事服役時間更長，之後每
年還有60至90天的預備役服役。台灣的軍事機構被認為是保守的，過於迷戀華而不實和昂
貴的軍事硬體，這些硬體可能無法抵禦大規模敵人攻擊。這使得台灣軍方開始更加關注非
對稱戰爭和相關硬件，但有限的預算使台灣的整體防禦存在許多空白。
備註
這次換國防部被點名了，會繼續自我感覺良好嗎
鋼盔、防彈衣都被批評
人員不足導致國軍過勞，近期一堆自殺
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 111.248.217.218 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1713426955.A.FBD.html
→
04/18 15:56,
1周前
, 1F
04/18 15:56, 1F
→
04/18 15:56,
1周前
, 2F
04/18 15:56, 2F
推
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 3F
04/18 15:57, 3F
→
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 4F
04/18 15:57, 4F
推
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 5F
04/18 15:57, 5F
→
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 6F
04/18 15:57, 6F
→
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 7F
04/18 15:57, 7F
→
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 8F
04/18 15:57, 8F
推
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 9F
04/18 15:57, 9F
推
04/18 15:57,
1周前
, 10F
04/18 15:57, 10F
推
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 11F
04/18 15:58, 11F
→
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 12F
04/18 15:58, 12F
噓
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 13F
04/18 15:58, 13F
→
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 14F
04/18 15:58, 14F
→
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 15F
04/18 15:58, 15F
推
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 16F
04/18 15:58, 16F
→
04/18 15:58,
1周前
, 17F
04/18 15:58, 17F
推
04/18 15:59,
1周前
, 18F
04/18 15:59, 18F
推
04/18 16:00,
1周前
, 19F
04/18 16:00, 19F
噓
04/18 16:00,
1周前
, 20F
04/18 16:00, 20F
噓
04/18 16:02,
1周前
, 21F
04/18 16:02, 21F
推
04/18 16:03,
1周前
, 22F
04/18 16:03, 22F
→
04/18 16:03,
1周前
, 23F
04/18 16:03, 23F
噓
04/18 16:03,
1周前
, 24F
04/18 16:03, 24F
→
04/18 16:03,
1周前
, 25F
04/18 16:03, 25F
推
04/18 16:03,
1周前
, 26F
04/18 16:03, 26F
推
04/18 16:04,
1周前
, 27F
04/18 16:04, 27F
→
04/18 16:04,
1周前
, 28F
04/18 16:04, 28F
→
04/18 16:04,
1周前
, 29F
04/18 16:04, 29F
→
04/18 16:05,
1周前
, 30F
04/18 16:05, 30F
→
04/18 16:05,
1周前
, 31F
04/18 16:05, 31F
推
04/18 16:05,
1周前
, 32F
04/18 16:05, 32F
推
04/18 16:05,
1周前
, 33F
04/18 16:05, 33F
推
04/18 16:05,
1周前
, 34F
04/18 16:05, 34F
→
04/18 16:06,
1周前
, 35F
04/18 16:06, 35F
推
04/18 16:07,
1周前
, 36F
04/18 16:07, 36F
推
04/18 16:07,
1周前
, 37F
04/18 16:07, 37F
→
04/18 16:07,
1周前
, 38F
04/18 16:07, 38F
→
04/18 16:07,
1周前
, 39F
04/18 16:07, 39F
還有 113 則推文
還有 1 段內文
→
04/18 17:17,
1周前
, 153F
04/18 17:17, 153F
→
04/18 17:17,
1周前
, 154F
04/18 17:17, 154F
推
04/18 17:25,
1周前
, 155F
04/18 17:25, 155F
推
04/18 17:26,
1周前
, 156F
04/18 17:26, 156F
推
04/18 17:28,
1周前
, 157F
04/18 17:28, 157F
推
04/18 17:33,
1周前
, 158F
04/18 17:33, 158F
推
04/18 17:35,
1周前
, 159F
04/18 17:35, 159F
噓
04/18 17:36,
1周前
, 160F
04/18 17:36, 160F
→
04/18 17:36,
1周前
, 161F
04/18 17:36, 161F
推
04/18 17:38,
1周前
, 162F
04/18 17:38, 162F
推
04/18 17:44,
1周前
, 163F
04/18 17:44, 163F
推
04/18 18:05,
1周前
, 164F
04/18 18:05, 164F
→
04/18 18:05,
1周前
, 165F
04/18 18:05, 165F
推
04/18 18:08,
1周前
, 166F
04/18 18:08, 166F
→
04/18 18:08,
1周前
, 167F
04/18 18:08, 167F
→
04/18 18:08,
1周前
, 168F
04/18 18:08, 168F
→
04/18 18:08,
1周前
, 169F
04/18 18:08, 169F
推
04/18 18:11,
1周前
, 170F
04/18 18:11, 170F
→
04/18 18:20,
1周前
, 171F
04/18 18:20, 171F
推
04/18 18:38,
1周前
, 172F
04/18 18:38, 172F
推
04/18 18:43,
1周前
, 173F
04/18 18:43, 173F
→
04/18 18:43,
1周前
, 174F
04/18 18:43, 174F
推
04/18 18:51,
1周前
, 175F
04/18 18:51, 175F
→
04/18 19:45,
1周前
, 176F
04/18 19:45, 176F
→
04/18 19:49,
1周前
, 177F
04/18 19:49, 177F
→
04/18 21:22,
1周前
, 178F
04/18 21:22, 178F
推
04/18 22:13,
1周前
, 179F
04/18 22:13, 179F
噓
04/18 22:59,
1周前
, 180F
04/18 22:59, 180F
→
04/18 22:59,
1周前
, 181F
04/18 22:59, 181F
→
04/18 22:59,
1周前
, 182F
04/18 22:59, 182F
→
04/18 22:59,
1周前
, 183F
04/18 22:59, 183F
→
04/18 22:59,
1周前
, 184F
04/18 22:59, 184F
→
04/18 23:02,
1周前
, 185F
04/18 23:02, 185F
→
04/18 23:02,
1周前
, 186F
04/18 23:02, 186F
→
04/18 23:02,
1周前
, 187F
04/18 23:02, 187F
→
04/18 23:02,
1周前
, 188F
04/18 23:02, 188F
推
04/18 23:18,
1周前
, 189F
04/18 23:18, 189F
推
04/18 23:37,
1周前
, 190F
04/18 23:37, 190F
推
04/19 06:06,
1周前
, 191F
04/19 06:06, 191F
推
04/19 10:20,
1周前
, 192F
04/19 10:20, 192F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文：
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇)：
