Re: [討論] Doc可以稱得上目前現役投手最強嗎

看板MLB作者 (Hella Days)時間12年前 (2012/06/11 00:44), 編輯推噓36(36014)
留言50則, 40人參與, 最新討論串5/5 (看更多)
剛好最近看一份電子雜誌有做MLB歷史上最具有掌控全場能力的100位投手, 但是沒什麼提到數據分析,提供版友參考他們的說法,並非他們就是正確答案 因為資歷尚淺又很多上古神獸,認識不多,僅先標上現役投手 http://goo.gl/ix7mp 每一個slide都有簡單的介紹 100. Dennis Martinez 099. Chuck Finley 098. Fernando Valenzuela 097. Burleigh Grimes 096. Herb Pennock 095. Clayton Kershaw 094. Jimmy Key 093. Mike Cuellar 092. Rube Marquard 091. Charlie Buffinton 090. Al Spaulding 089. Babe Ruth 088. Bret Saberhagen 087. Tim Lincecum 086. Waite Hoyt 085. Andy Pettitte 084. Jack Chesbro 083. Eppa Rixey 082. Roy Oswalt 081. Rollie Fingers 080. Lefty Gomez 079. Dwight Gooden 078. Mickey Lolich 077. Jerry Koosman 076. Chief Bender 075. Amos Rusie 074. Johan Santana 073. Catfish Hunter 072. Vic Willis 071. Clark Griffith 070. David Cone 069. Billy Pierce 068. Tim Hudson 067. Jim Kaat 066. Bob Lemon 065. Red Ruffing 064. Tommy John 063. Red Faber 062. Jack Morris 061. Smokey Joe Wood 060. CC Sabathia 059. Stan Coveleski 058. Hal Newhouser 057. Trevor Hoffman 056. Dave Stewart 055. Kevin Brown 054. Ted Lyons 053. Mickey Welch 052. Curt Schilling 051. Orel Hershiser 050. Roy Halladay 049. Dizzy Dean 048. Joe McGinnity 047. Dazzy Vance 046. Jim Bunning 045. John Smoltz 044. Rube Waddell 043. Early Wynn 042. Luis Tiant 041. Dennis Eckersley 040. Phil Niekro 039. Tom Glavine 038. Robin Roberts 037. Justin Verlander (現役SP最前排名) 036. Don Drysdale 035. Mike Mussina 034. John Clarkson 033. Addie Joss 032. Gaylord Perry 031. Don Sutton 030. Pud Galvin 029. Ed Walsh 028. Bert Blyleven 027. Old Hoss Radbourn 026. Tim Keefe 025. Fergie Jenkins 024. Whitey Ford 023. Juan Marichal 022. Carl Hubbell 021. Jim Palmer 020. Bob Feller 019. Mordecai Brown 018. Pedro Martinez 017. Nolan Ryan 016. Kid Nichols 015. Eddie Plank 014. Randy Johnson (偶像特別標一下XD 很希望看到5000K才退休) 013. Steve Carlton 012. Mariano Rivera (ERA+ 206, all time MLB leader) 011. Roger Clemens 010. Bob Gibson 009. Warren Spahn 008. Lefty Grove 007. Greg Maddux 006. Sandy Koufax 005. Tom Seaver 004. Christy Mathewson 003. Cy Young 002. Grover Cleveland Alexander 001. Walter Johnson -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 111.240.101.5

06/11 00:46, , 1F
Tom Seaver!!!!!
06/11 00:46, 1F

06/11 00:46, , 2F
best mets ever
06/11 00:46, 2F

06/11 00:47, , 3F
MO神好威
06/11 00:47, 3F

06/11 00:48, , 4F
MO!!!!
06/11 00:48, 4F

06/11 00:49, , 5F
其實這種東西就像...張飛打岳飛 甚至是張飛打張菲 XD
06/11 00:49, 5F

06/11 00:49, , 6F
尤其是裡面要放進黑人聯盟那些半傳說的奇怪生物後 XD
06/11 00:49, 6F

06/11 00:51, , 7F
還真的好多上古神獸不認識 (默
06/11 00:51, 7F

06/11 00:53, , 8F
V壯!!! 繼續再投個10年吧!!! XD
06/11 00:53, 8F

06/11 00:54, , 9F
怎麼沒有Cliff Lee 近幾年跟季後賽的表 應該也有百名吧!
06/11 00:54, 9F

06/11 00:54, , 10F
沒有King Felix....?
06/11 00:54, 10F

06/11 01:02, , 11F
看到NMaddux跟一堆神獸排一起
06/11 01:02, 11F

06/11 01:08, , 12F
Bleacher Report XD 這網站和PTT棒球板差不多
06/11 01:08, 12F

06/11 01:10, , 13F
只有麥狗前10..
06/11 01:10, 13F

06/11 01:11, , 14F
賽揚那麼多敗。。。排名那麼前
06/11 01:11, 14F

06/11 01:12, , 15F
這裡面並非只有現役.剛退役的現代和上古神獸三種啊
06/11 01:12, 15F

06/11 01:12, , 16F
這份名單占最多的其實是中古神獸(無誤) XD
06/11 01:12, 16F

06/11 01:13, , 17F
沒有剛爺嗎@@a
06/11 01:13, 17F

06/11 01:13, , 18F
嘴炮也排太後面了吧
06/11 01:13, 18F

06/11 01:14, , 19F
火箭人贏過MO喔~~~
06/11 01:14, 19F

06/11 01:21, , 20F
賽揚先發815場完投749場,511勝316敗…他的手臂是為棒球而生!
06/11 01:21, 20F

06/11 01:22, , 21F
在我心目中 koufax 是第一
06/11 01:22, 21F

06/11 01:27, , 22F
什麼!!賽揚竟沒拿過賽揚獎!?
06/11 01:27, 22F

06/11 01:45, , 23F
MO果然是神界...
06/11 01:45, 23F

06/11 01:55, , 24F
這個看看就好 光是老火箭 麥狗 RJ Pedro就很難比了(各
06/11 01:55, 24F

06/11 01:55, , 25F
有長處) 更何況不同年代的
06/11 01:55, 25F

06/11 01:56, , 26F
Santana 在 Hudson後面 ?
06/11 01:56, 26F

06/11 01:59, , 27F
算一算只認得43個..
06/11 01:59, 27F

06/11 02:18, , 28F
089. Babe Ruth 上古神獸無誤
06/11 02:18, 28F

06/11 02:30, , 29F
STEWART比CATFISH. KOOSMAN高那麼多 ..這認真的嗎...
06/11 02:30, 29F

06/11 04:43, , 30F
威一兩年就能進前百 這份到底在比啥小....
06/11 04:43, 30F

06/11 05:27, , 31F
要大亂鬥沒有 Satchel Paige 就是失敗
06/11 05:27, 31F

06/11 06:38, , 32F
2005太空人有一年有三隻
06/11 06:38, 32F

06/11 07:27, , 33F
Babe Ruth 應該是少數能投手 打擊都排上榜的人...@@
06/11 07:27, 33F

06/11 10:19, , 34F
Moose 排35名!!
06/11 10:19, 34F

06/11 10:21, , 35F
Ruth應該算是結束上古時期(死球時代)的關鍵人物吧XD
06/11 10:21, 35F

06/11 10:22, , 36F
大火車~~
06/11 10:22, 36F

06/11 10:41, , 37F
ya Maddux
06/11 10:41, 37F

06/11 10:46, , 38F
未看先猜Bleacher Report
06/11 10:46, 38F

06/11 11:06, , 39F
#35排35名.....................QQ
06/11 11:06, 39F

06/11 11:06, , 40F
第七名,我心滿意足。
06/11 11:06, 40F

06/11 11:31, , 41F
Moose!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
06/11 11:31, 41F

06/11 11:41, , 42F
Moose!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
06/11 11:41, 42F

06/11 19:10, , 43F
怎麼沒有Lee = =
06/11 19:10, 43F

06/11 19:10, , 44F
Sandy Koufax大概會是這100人中除現役外勝場最少的
06/11 19:10, 44F

06/11 19:22, , 45F
165勝可以排到200名左右 上面還有rp跟球神..
06/11 19:22, 45F

06/11 21:31, , 46F
這種排名是排爽的...
06/11 21:31, 46F

06/11 22:47, , 47F
其實我對於 Pete Alexander 排到那麼前面一直都很不以為然
06/11 22:47, 47F

06/11 22:51, , 48F
不過基本上非常多棒球排名都會把他放前三就是了...
06/11 22:51, 48F

06/12 00:05, , 49F
why?
06/12 00:05, 49F

06/13 20:24, , 50F
我還有第68名耶
06/13 20:24, 50F
文章代碼(AID): #1FrCxqIr (MLB)
討論串 (同標題文章)
文章代碼(AID): #1FrCxqIr (MLB)