[新聞] 女權人士: 敦克爾克缺乏女角 淪父權論述消失

看板Gossiping作者時間8年前 (2017/08/16 19:53), 編輯推噓11(92推 81噓 77→)
留言250則, 207人參與, 最新討論串1/17 (看更多)
來源： The daily caller 標題： Feminist Says Dunkirk Is A Bad Movie Because It Screams ‘Men-Only’ 女權人士: 敦克爾克缺乏女角 淪父權論述 內文： Christopher Nolan’s “Dunkirk” is being celebrated as one of the strongest m ovies of the year—and may perhaps rank among one of the best war movies ever made alongside “Saving Private Ryan,” “Hacksaw Ridge,” and “Black Hawk Do wn.” Like the other great films, it doesn’t glorify war, but instead emphasi zes the tragedy of war. But because male critics are praising it, women’s mag azine Marie Claire has seen fit to trash the film for “celebrating maleness” —asking instead why war movies aren’t being made for women. 敦克爾克被譽為最偉大的戰爭電影，與搶救雷恩大兵等電影齊名。但女性雜誌Marie Clai re卻批評本電影「高抬男性氣質」，並質疑戰爭片為什麼無法讓女性感動。 Writing for Marie Claire, Mehera Bonner declared “Dunkirk” to be “basic.” “And look, it’s not like I need every movie to have ‘strong female leads.’ Wonder Woman can probably tide me over for at least a year and I understand t hat this was dominated by brave male soldiers. I get that,” she wrote, before slamming the film for its “general vibe.” Despite enjoying the film’s intense moments and even the performances of its actors, including One Direction’s Harry Styles in his first big screen appear ance, the Marie Claire writer slams Dunkirk for being “designed for men to ma n-out over.” 雜誌專欄作家Mehera Bonner表示，敦克爾克很平庸的一部片。她說：「我不是要每部電 影都有女強人當主角，我很喜歡神力女超人，但我也了解戰爭是男人打的。」 但她也批評敦克爾克是為男人而拍的電影。 “The tenor of the people applauding it just screams ‘men-only’,” she conti nued, citing that the only reason male critics liked it was because it allowed them to feel manly. 她表示，只有男人才能欣賞此片，男人之所以喜歡，是因為看完會覺得有男子氣概。 Bonner continues: “To me, Dunkirk felt like an excuse for men to celebrate ma leness—which apparently they don’t get to do enough. Fine, great, go forth, but if Nolan’s entire purpose is breaking the established war movie mold and doing something different—why not make a movie about women in World War II?” The Marie Claire writer argues that it’s the responsibility of top-tier dire ctors like Nolan to make the films she wants more of. 敦克爾克成了男人高抬男子氣概的藉口。 如果諾蘭導演想要打破戰爭片傳統，何不拍部二戰中的女性？ This year’s “Wonder Woman” and “Atomic Blonde” are both highly rated film s, revealing little gender bias among film critics. Likewise, the female-drive n “Mad Max: Fury Road” was equally enjoyed by critics of either sex, earning it a spot as one of the highest rated films ever made. Films about women in t imes of war have been made, several to critical acclaim—including “Zero Dark Thirty” and “The English Patient.” According to film reviewers, each of th ese films broke the mold by taking typically male settings and centering them around female protagonists. Dunkirk was a prominent event in military history, but is rarely given notice in pop culture. To anyone who’s heard of Dunkirk, the evacuation is largely r emembered as both a miracle and a disaster for the Allied forces in Europe dur ing World War II. Failing to defend France against the Germans, the British we re forced to evacuate over 338,000 troops with the aid of private civilians. However, over 30,000 troops were left behind to be captured as prisoners of wa r to the German army. The British press managed to turn the loss into a sort o f victory with the “Dunkirk Spirit” that showed the solidarity of the Britis h people in saving the lives of their countrymen. With “Dunkirk,” Christophe r Nolan shed light on an event that would’ve otherwise relegated to the histo ry books. https://tinyurl.com/ybutwwoh -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 101.9.137.174 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1502884404.A.72B.html
→
08/16 19:53, , 1F
幹你媽笑死，女權智障
08/16 19:53, 1F
推
08/16 19:53, , 2F
船上有女服務生啊
08/16 19:53, 2F
推
08/16 19:54, , 3F
可憐女權
08/16 19:54, 3F
噓
08/16 19:54, , 4F
................
08/16 19:54, 4F
→
08/16 19:54, , 5F
神力女超人太過裸露，淪為父權遺毒
08/16 19:54, 5F
→
08/16 19:54, , 6F
智障女權
08/16 19:54, 6F
→
08/16 19:54, , 7F
工三小
08/16 19:54, 7F
推
08/16 19:54, , 8F
有啊 船上的護士
08/16 19:54, 8F
噓
08/16 19:54, , 9F
那年代前線是有幾個女的拉 填屍體都不夠
08/16 19:54, 9F
→
08/16 19:54, , 10F
無條件支持女性代替男性當兵 以後你們都是戰場的主角
08/16 19:54, 10F
推
08/16 19:54, , 11F
二戰男性死了一堆
08/16 19:54, 11F
推
08/16 19:54, , 12F
被派出去當炮灰的都男的 幹
08/16 19:54, 12F
→
08/16 19:54, , 13F
怎麼會有人搶著要當砲灰
08/16 19:54, 13F
推
08/16 19:54, , 14F
Food權foodfoodfood權
08/16 19:54, 14F
→
08/16 19:54, , 15F
太好了，加個慰安婦
08/16 19:54, 15F
→
08/16 19:54, , 16F
很高興女生想爭取版面 以後也請女生上戰場 後人才有戲拍
08/16 19:54, 16F
→
08/16 19:54, , 17F
智障,神力女超人怎麼不叫男的演主角
08/16 19:54, 17F
推
08/16 19:55, , 18F
..........
08/16 19:55, 18F
推
08/16 19:55, , 19F
這樣也行？！
08/16 19:55, 19F
噓
08/16 19:55, , 20F
原來當時有女大兵參戰喔
08/16 19:55, 20F
推
08/16 19:55, , 21F
幹 這篇新聞工三小 女主角是護士阿
08/16 19:55, 21F
→
08/16 19:55, , 22F
二戰結束前的確是父權啊?
08/16 19:55, 22F
推
08/16 19:55, , 23F
不想有男子氣概的話，不會去看人妖打排球喔~
08/16 19:55, 23F
推
08/16 19:55, , 24F
來當兵啊
08/16 19:55, 24F
→
08/16 19:55, , 25F
誰去貼在徐閉的臉書
08/16 19:55, 25F
→
08/16 19:55, , 26F
英軍打到逃回老家 這算哪門子的男子氣概........?
08/16 19:55, 26F
→
08/16 19:55, , 27F
所以是有女童軍背軍人游過多佛海峽嗎？
08/16 19:55, 27F
→
08/16 19:55, , 28F
第一次看到有人為了這種理由想上戰場的 女權真的很智障
08/16 19:55, 28F
推
08/16 19:55, , 29F
幹！拍個片都要問妳意見？
08/16 19:55, 29F
推
08/16 19:56, , 30F
到底有什麼好不滿的我真的看不懂
08/16 19:56, 30F
噓
08/16 19:56, , 31F
未來不拍女性片的都是沙豬，壞
08/16 19:56, 31F
噓
08/16 19:56, , 32F
雞排咧 女的來當義務役啊
08/16 19:56, 32F
推
08/16 19:56, , 33F
戰爭片要女角幹嘛 女兵還是女護士? 這就是女權腦嗎???
08/16 19:56, 33F
推
08/16 19:56, , 34F
...這三小 就是個歷史事件 女權這也能嘴？
08/16 19:56, 34F
→
08/16 19:56, , 35F
戰場就不是女權的主場他是在哭喔 豬隊友
08/16 19:56, 35F
→
08/16 19:56, , 36F
你有本事叫女人去開噴火式擊墜敵機啊
08/16 19:56, 36F
→
08/16 19:56, , 37F
根本無病呻吟
08/16 19:56, 37F
推
08/16 19:56, , 38F
全都了解，照樣批評？這是在搞啥飛機
08/16 19:56, 38F
噓
08/16 19:56, , 39F
公三小，女森那時候當兵嗎
08/16 19:56, 39F
還有 171 則推文
還有 1 段內文
→
08/16 22:47, , 211F
。現在講話大聲了連歷史都要扭曲嗎？
08/16 22:47, 211F
噓
08/16 22:47, , 212F
有女人啊 負責發送食物而已哈哈
08/16 22:47, 212F
噓
08/16 22:48, , 213F
無聊
08/16 22:48, 213F
→
08/16 22:48, , 214F
女沙豬真噁心
08/16 22:48, 214F
→
08/16 22:53, , 215F
要看二戰中的女性，不會去看英倫情人喔，北七膩
08/16 22:53, 215F
噓
08/16 22:54, , 216F
去當兵啊
08/16 22:54, 216F
→
08/16 22:55, , 217F
女權自己出個導演去拍不會喔 什麼都要男的服務你
08/16 22:55, 217F
→
08/16 22:57, , 218F
Food權foodfoodfood權
08/16 22:57, 218F
推
08/16 22:59, , 219F
自己去拍啊...
08/16 22:59, 219F
噓
08/16 23:10, , 220F
打仗請男人去前線擋子彈才算個男人，但拍戰爭電影要拍得
08/16 23:10, 220F
→
08/16 23:10, , 221F
出女人的偉大。
08/16 23:10, 221F
推
08/16 23:10, , 222F
要不要看看死傷的性別比?
08/16 23:10, 222F
推
08/16 23:11, , 223F
女拳:強烈質疑nba,mlb,世界足球賽充斥男人，淪父權論述
08/16 23:11, 223F
推
08/16 23:20, , 224F
東線戰場有很多女兵
08/16 23:20, 224F
噓
08/16 23:25, , 225F
媽的智障
08/16 23:25, 225F
推
08/16 23:32, , 226F
女權豬隊友真的超級多
08/16 23:32, 226F
噓
08/16 23:38, , 227F
突破天際的低能
08/16 23:38, 227F
推
08/17 00:19, , 228F
不會自己去拍一個抬高女性氣質的喔,只會出一張嘴真爽
08/17 00:19, 228F
推
08/17 00:23, , 229F
這到底是在走火入魔什麼
08/17 00:23, 229F
噓
08/17 00:24, , 230F
這種女權主義者為什麼不會自己去拍啊，都只會出一
08/17 00:24, 230F
→
08/17 00:24, , 231F
張嘴而已，難怪大家看不起啊
08/17 00:24, 231F
噓
08/17 00:31, , 232F
亂源。
08/17 00:31, 232F
噓
08/17 03:15, , 233F
女權現在看起來根本跟宗教沒兩樣，不支持就妖魔化對方
08/17 03:15, 233F
推
08/17 09:03, , 234F
支持女權義務役，男生不需要義務當兵，以後電影戰場主
08/17 09:03, 234F
→
08/17 09:03, , 235F
角都給女性演
08/17 09:03, 235F
噓
08/17 10:31, , 236F
開倒車耶
08/17 10:31, 236F
噓
08/17 10:56, , 237F
9487 94狂
08/17 10:56, 237F
噓
08/17 13:45, , 238F
諾蘭一直都不會描繪女性角色 乾脆不放不是比較好ㄇ
08/17 13:45, 238F
噓
08/17 14:05, , 239F
就跟美國影集每部都有同性戀角色一樣智障
08/17 14:05, 239F
噓
08/18 02:18, , 240F
女角戲份 基本上只有德蘇戰爭而已 而且放太多容易失焦
08/18 02:18, 240F
→
08/18 02:20, , 241F
畢竟上戰場不是女性 不然就是很多餘的愛情戲
08/18 02:20, 241F
推
08/18 08:55, , 242F
肥希：女生才是最大的受害者，因為她們失去了丈夫跟孩
08/18 08:55, 242F
→
08/18 08:55, , 243F
子
08/18 08:55, 243F
→
08/18 08:55, , 244F
男：sorry？
08/18 08:55, 244F
噓
08/18 10:10, , 245F
女拳為何不考慮自己籌錢拍
08/18 10:10, 245F
噓
08/18 10:57, , 246F
工啥小
08/18 10:57, 246F
噓
08/18 19:17, , 247F
智障女權 唉
08/18 19:17, 247F
推
08/18 22:44, , 248F
為什麼拍得有男子氣概就一定是父權，腦子破洞喔
08/18 22:44, 248F
推
08/19 01:45, , 249F
講幹話
08/19 01:45, 249F
→
08/20 18:19, , 250F
08/20 18:19, 250F
‣ 更多 fffffff4 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1Pb38qSh (Gossiping)
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文 (最舊先)：
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 17 篇)：
排序： 最新先 | 最舊先 | 留言數
在新視窗開啟完整討論串 (共17篇)
‣ 更多 fffffff4 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1Pb38qSh (Gossiping)