Re: [閒聊] 港台人的民主思維陷阱
※ 引述《esolve (nobbb)》之銘言:
: 希特勒是民主制度的德國選民選上台的
: 烏克蘭也是民主國家,結果革命分裂,人民顛沛流離
: 土耳其的總統也是民主選舉選上的
: 叛亂,鎮壓
: 現在走向伊斯蘭極端化
: 非洲一狗票民主國家,暴亂,戰爭不斷
: 當然,台灣人會說,這些不是真民主
: ※ 引述《baboosh (大王椰)》之銘言:
: : 台灣人思路是這樣
: : 專制不好
: : 民主比專制好
: : 至於民主的無效率 是可以接受的 因為跟專制的危害比
: : 問題是也有民主是有效率的
: : 至於有效率的民主 沒人想談
: : 反正沒有專制的危害就好了
: : thats it
: : 可悲的腦子
問題是可簡化成人性上的物質跟心理層次,
環境差或面臨巨大危險壓力就會想快速集權去應付以求早點脫離苦境。
希特勒就是那時德國面臨內部經濟及巨大戰敗賠償問題造成的,
二戰後這類問題小了反而走民主路子走的還不錯, 因本身國民素質
算佳, 日本也差不多這樣。
至於一些國家底子跟國民素質本就不好時,就要看當時掌權者
的素養。想無下限圖謀自身利益? 那什麼制都只是掛羊頭賣狗肉。
台灣跟香港? 發展到這階段再笨也不會想要中國那種體制,
況且中國還是台灣跟香港的最大麻煩源頭。 如果港台是
不受中國威脅的獨立國家,或許有一天看到中國未來改革整體發展到超過港台時,
還會想去參考中國體制, 未來幾十年來看是難上加難。
台灣現以民主運作方式去面對內部轉型正義及外部對抗
來自中國的威脅 , 如果發現效果差時不知會不會演變成
掛著民主但實際卻偏向威權的政治運作 ?
--
懶龍
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 112.104.195.105
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/CrossStrait/M.1473473496.A.E69.html
※ 編輯: nanlong (112.104.195.105), 09/10/2016 10:28:37
→
09/10 12:38, , 1F
09/10 12:38, 1F
→
09/10 12:39, , 2F
09/10 12:39, 2F
→
09/10 12:39, , 3F
09/10 12:39, 3F
推
09/10 13:07, , 4F
09/10 13:07, 4F
→
09/10 13:13, , 5F
09/10 13:13, 5F
→
09/10 13:13, , 6F
09/10 13:13, 6F
→
09/10 13:13, , 7F
09/10 13:13, 7F
→
09/10 13:14, , 8F
09/10 13:14, 8F
推
09/10 14:15, , 9F
09/10 14:15, 9F
→
09/10 14:16, , 10F
09/10 14:16, 10F
→
09/10 14:18, , 11F
09/10 14:18, 11F
→
09/10 14:19, , 12F
09/10 14:19, 12F
→
09/10 14:19, , 13F
09/10 14:19, 13F
噓
09/10 14:55, , 14F
09/10 14:55, 14F
→
09/10 14:55, , 15F
09/10 14:55, 15F
→
09/10 15:28, , 16F
09/10 15:28, 16F
推
09/10 22:57, , 17F
09/10 22:57, 17F
→
09/10 22:58, , 18F
09/10 22:58, 18F
→
09/11 00:38, , 19F
09/11 00:38, 19F
→
09/11 00:38, , 20F
09/11 00:38, 20F
→
09/11 00:39, , 21F
09/11 00:39, 21F
→
09/11 00:39, , 22F
09/11 00:39, 22F
→
09/11 00:40, , 23F
09/11 00:40, 23F
→
09/11 00:40, , 24F
09/11 00:40, 24F
→
09/11 00:40, , 25F
09/11 00:40, 25F
→
09/11 00:41, , 26F
09/11 00:41, 26F
→
09/11 00:41, , 27F
09/11 00:41, 27F
→
09/11 00:42, , 28F
09/11 00:42, 28F
→
09/11 00:42, , 29F
09/11 00:42, 29F
噓
09/11 00:52, , 30F
09/11 00:52, 30F
→
09/11 00:53, , 31F
09/11 00:53, 31F
→
09/11 00:53, , 32F
09/11 00:53, 32F
→
09/11 00:56, , 33F
09/11 00:56, 33F
→
09/11 00:57, , 34F
09/11 00:57, 34F
→
09/11 00:59, , 35F
09/11 00:59, 35F
→
09/11 00:59, , 36F
09/11 00:59, 36F
→
09/11 01:01, , 37F
09/11 01:01, 37F
→
09/11 01:01, , 38F
09/11 01:01, 38F
→
09/11 01:02, , 39F
09/11 01:02, 39F
→
09/11 01:02, , 40F
09/11 01:02, 40F
→
09/11 01:03, , 41F
09/11 01:03, 41F
→
09/11 01:04, , 42F
09/11 01:04, 42F
→
09/11 01:05, , 43F
09/11 01:05, 43F
→
09/11 01:14, , 44F
09/11 01:14, 44F
→
09/11 07:50, , 45F
09/11 07:50, 45F
→
09/11 07:51, , 46F
09/11 07:51, 46F
→
09/11 07:53, , 47F
09/11 07:53, 47F
→
09/11 07:53, , 48F
09/11 07:53, 48F
→
09/11 09:14, , 49F
09/11 09:14, 49F
→
09/11 09:14, , 50F
09/11 09:14, 50F
→
09/11 09:15, , 51F
09/11 09:15, 51F
→
09/11 09:15, , 52F
09/11 09:15, 52F
→
09/11 09:17, , 53F
09/11 09:17, 53F
→
09/11 15:21, , 54F
09/11 15:21, 54F
推
09/11 18:47, , 55F
09/11 18:47, 55F
→
09/11 18:47, , 56F
09/11 18:47, 56F
→
09/11 18:48, , 57F
09/11 18:48, 57F
→
09/11 18:48, , 58F
09/11 18:48, 58F
→
09/11 18:49, , 59F
09/11 18:49, 59F
→
09/11 18:50, , 60F
09/11 18:50, 60F
→
09/11 18:50, , 61F
09/11 18:50, 61F
→
09/11 18:51, , 62F
09/11 18:51, 62F
→
09/11 18:51, , 63F
09/11 18:51, 63F
推
09/11 18:54, , 64F
09/11 18:54, 64F
推
09/11 18:56, , 65F
09/11 18:56, 65F
→
09/11 18:56, , 66F
09/11 18:56, 66F
→
09/11 21:15, , 67F
09/11 21:15, 67F
→
09/11 21:15, , 68F
09/11 21:15, 68F
推
09/12 08:17, , 69F
09/12 08:17, 69F
→
09/12 08:18, , 70F
09/12 08:18, 70F
→
09/12 08:18, , 71F
09/12 08:18, 71F
→
09/12 08:19, , 72F
09/12 08:19, 72F
→
09/12 08:19, , 73F
09/12 08:19, 73F
→
09/12 08:20, , 74F
09/12 08:20, 74F
→
09/12 08:21, , 75F
09/12 08:21, 75F
推
09/12 08:23, , 76F
09/12 08:23, 76F
→
09/12 08:23, , 77F
09/12 08:23, 77F
→
09/12 08:24, , 78F
09/12 08:24, 78F
→
09/12 08:25, , 79F
09/12 08:25, 79F
→
09/12 08:25, , 80F
09/12 08:25, 80F
→
09/12 08:26, , 81F
09/12 08:26, 81F
→
09/12 08:26, , 82F
09/12 08:26, 82F
→
09/12 08:27, , 83F
09/12 08:27, 83F
推
09/14 22:32, , 84F
09/14 22:32, 84F
→
09/14 22:32, , 85F
09/14 22:32, 85F
→
09/14 22:32, , 86F
09/14 22:32, 86F
討論串 (同標題文章)