Re: [題目] With 和 After在這句裡的文意判斷！
※ 引述《IamNoTaStaR (男人不能沒肩膀！)》之銘言：
: ※ 引述《hanchieh (河馬打哈欠)》之銘言：
: : ____ collecting health data from thousands of nurses,Michels and
: : colleagues reported in 1997 that women had weighed about 5.5 pounds at birth
: : had half the risk of breast cancer in women aged 50 or younger.
: : (A) after
: : (B) with
: : 疑問：為甚麼是A而不是B
: : 我同意選A無誤
: : 但不是B的理由是？
: : 多謝幫忙！
: With the health data collected from thousands of nurses, Michels reported.....
: With ~~~, SV
: 在這種句子結構下 with 的後面是要加名詞才行
為了尋求更多人的答案
我也po在托福版詢問板友
得到一個能說服我的答案
前句是 After Michel and colleages collected...分詞省略的結果（與連接主詞相同）
所以變成After collecting…
至於不能用with的關係在於
沒錯！with 要接名詞
但這裡的collecting 是分詞過後的動詞ing化
所以After無誤！
如果有別的更好的解釋歡迎討論
如果沒有 就謝謝各位了！
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.81.198.47
→
02/01 00:07, , 1F
02/01 00:07, 1F
→
02/01 00:08, , 2F
02/01 00:08, 2F
→
02/01 00:22, , 3F
02/01 00:22, 3F
→
02/01 00:24, , 4F
02/01 00:24, 4F
→
02/01 00:26, , 5F
02/01 00:26, 5F
→
02/01 01:50, , 6F
02/01 01:50, 6F
→
02/01 01:50, , 7F
02/01 01:50, 7F
→
02/01 01:50, , 8F
02/01 01:50, 8F
→
02/01 01:54, , 9F
02/01 01:54, 9F
→
02/01 01:54, , 10F
02/01 01:54, 10F
→
02/01 01:55, , 11F
02/01 01:55, 11F
→
02/01 01:55, , 12F
02/01 01:55, 12F
→
12/02 20:15, , 13F
12/02 20:15, 13F
討論串 (同標題文章)