Re: [問題] 請問目前到底有沒有板務站長?
※ 引述《betel5566 ()》之銘言:
: 1.如題
有,自己爬
: 2.板務站長判決是否可以違背目前中華民國法律?
不可以,站規、板規等頂多只能視為自治規則
位階低於法律
若由其仍受教育部相關法令之限制
其位階甚至低於命令
: 3.板務站長認為有所懷疑是否不需要明確證據,
: 由板務站長自由心證即可?
法官本於發見真實之本旨
對於罪名成立之證據有必要詳為調查
並基於調查所得之心證以為判斷基礎
(上開意旨見於最高法院刑事判決八十九年度台上字第四五七四號 )
如果你要拿法官的標準來要求一個板務站長
那麼,答案是不行
但板務站長是法官嗎?
法官為追查證據而享有的資源之多,恐怕不是你能理解的
光是可以調出一個人的戶籍資料,查閱其身家背景
就已經是極難估計其影響力的權限了
而即使這樣,法官尚且難以發現完全的事實
僅能就其調查所得之證據進行判決
台端案例中
是否與該ID原持有者不為同一人確實難以定論
唯此事之調查已超出板務權限
若板務站長窮其能力調查所得而生心證,並據以判決
尚難謂其所為判決僅為"自由心證"
: 4.板務站長即使憑自由心證認為有罪,是否可任意隨意量刑?
: 不用查詢所犯何項規定?該規定該處以何種處罰?
: 由板務站長自己決定該怎樣罰就怎樣罰?
: 也就是規定或法律由他自己訂定即可?
量刑為裁量權,於法律規定範圍內自可任意為之
量刑之前須先定罪,定罪就需要查詢違犯何規定
事實符合該規定所指涉要件,就依該規定處罰之
既然已經認為有罪,那就沒有[無查詢所犯何項規定]之成立
: 5.與判決無關的板務問題是否適宜在判決中提出?
: 應該是板務內檢討時提就可以了吧?!
: 在判決中提出似乎有故意引導眾人被判決人是在鑽漏洞的假象與汙衊吧?!
依PTT申訴層級,板務站長為最高位階
本國上級法院於裁判書中糾正下級法院所為裁判之疏失不在少數
板務站長並非該板實任板務,僅於申訴案件成立時權充中立裁判官
若其認為該案件中板務處理上有疏失,於裁判書中一併闡明並無不妥
: 以上
: 請熟悉PTT運作者或熟悉中華民國法律者告知愚昧小弟在下敝人我
: 謝謝!
[維持原判]
表示上訴方所提之事實與證據不足以推翻原判決
原判決適用之規定亦無不妥
又,案件經最高裁判層級裁判確定便無再上訴管道
台端案例中,板務站長已為PTT申訴管道最高層級
除非台端確實能提出足以推翻判決之事由與證據
即[與該ID原持有人不為同一人]之證明,始得申請再議
----
要訴諸法律,你該去法院才對
PTT上規定就是如此
你這樣不斷擴大事端,鬧到無關的板面上
只會讓人對你觀感更差
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 101.13.106.2
推
02/12 12:13, , 1F
02/12 12:13, 1F
推
02/12 12:14, , 2F
02/12 12:14, 2F
推
02/12 13:41, , 3F
02/12 13:41, 3F
推
02/12 14:57, , 4F
02/12 14:57, 4F
推
02/12 15:01, , 5F
02/12 15:01, 5F
推
02/12 21:23, , 6F
02/12 21:23, 6F
推
02/13 00:59, , 7F
02/13 00:59, 7F
推
02/13 01:27, , 8F
02/13 01:27, 8F
→
02/13 01:28, , 9F
02/13 01:28, 9F
→
02/13 01:29, , 10F
02/13 01:29, 10F
→
02/13 01:30, , 11F
02/13 01:30, 11F
→
02/13 01:30, , 12F
02/13 01:30, 12F
→
02/13 01:32, , 13F
02/13 01:32, 13F
→
02/13 01:32, , 14F
02/13 01:32, 14F
→
02/13 01:33, , 15F
02/13 01:33, 15F
→
02/13 01:33, , 16F
02/13 01:33, 16F
→
02/13 01:34, , 17F
02/13 01:34, 17F
→
02/13 01:34, , 18F
02/13 01:34, 18F
推
02/13 01:39, , 19F
02/13 01:39, 19F
→
02/13 01:40, , 20F
02/13 01:40, 20F
→
02/13 01:41, , 21F
02/13 01:41, 21F
推
02/13 01:44, , 22F
02/13 01:44, 22F
推
02/13 01:47, , 23F
02/13 01:47, 23F
→
02/13 01:48, , 24F
02/13 01:48, 24F
→
02/13 01:49, , 25F
02/13 01:49, 25F
推
02/13 01:54, , 26F
02/13 01:54, 26F
→
02/13 01:54, , 27F
02/13 01:54, 27F
→
02/13 01:55, , 28F
02/13 01:55, 28F
→
02/13 01:56, , 29F
02/13 01:56, 29F
→
02/13 01:56, , 30F
02/13 01:56, 30F
→
02/13 01:57, , 31F
02/13 01:57, 31F
→
02/13 13:19, , 32F
02/13 13:19, 32F
推
02/13 14:42, , 33F
02/13 14:42, 33F
→
02/13 14:42, , 34F
02/13 14:42, 34F
→
02/13 15:28, , 35F
02/13 15:28, 35F
→
02/13 15:29, , 36F
02/13 15:29, 36F
→
02/13 15:29, , 37F
02/13 15:29, 37F
→
02/13 15:30, , 38F
02/13 15:30, 38F
推
02/13 15:47, , 39F
02/13 15:47, 39F
→
02/13 15:47, , 40F
02/13 15:47, 40F
推
02/13 17:32, , 41F
02/13 17:32, 41F
→
02/13 20:26, , 42F
02/13 20:26, 42F
推
02/13 22:29, , 43F
02/13 22:29, 43F
→
02/13 22:43, , 44F
02/13 22:43, 44F
推
02/13 22:46, , 45F
02/13 22:46, 45F
推
02/13 22:48, , 46F
02/13 22:48, 46F
→
02/13 22:49, , 47F
02/13 22:49, 47F
→
02/13 22:50, , 48F
02/13 22:50, 48F
推
02/13 22:52, , 49F
02/13 22:52, 49F
→
02/13 22:53, , 50F
02/13 22:53, 50F
推
02/13 23:12, , 51F
02/13 23:12, 51F
→
02/13 23:20, , 52F
02/13 23:20, 52F
→
02/13 23:37, , 53F
02/13 23:37, 53F
推
02/13 23:46, , 54F
02/13 23:46, 54F
→
02/13 23:46, , 55F
02/13 23:46, 55F
→
02/13 23:51, , 56F
02/13 23:51, 56F
→
02/13 23:52, , 57F
02/13 23:52, 57F
推
02/13 23:55, , 58F
02/13 23:55, 58F
→
02/13 23:56, , 59F
02/13 23:56, 59F
→
02/13 23:57, , 60F
02/13 23:57, 60F
→
02/13 23:57, , 61F
02/13 23:57, 61F
→
02/13 23:57, , 62F
02/13 23:57, 62F
→
02/13 23:58, , 63F
02/13 23:58, 63F
推
02/14 00:35, , 64F
02/14 00:35, 64F
→
02/14 00:35, , 65F
02/14 00:35, 65F
→
02/14 00:35, , 66F
02/14 00:35, 66F
→
02/14 00:36, , 67F
02/14 00:36, 67F
→
02/14 00:36, , 68F
02/14 00:36, 68F
→
02/14 00:37, , 69F
02/14 00:37, 69F
→
02/14 00:37, , 70F
02/14 00:37, 70F
→
02/14 00:38, , 71F
02/14 00:38, 71F
→
02/14 00:38, , 72F
02/14 00:38, 72F
推
02/14 05:58, , 73F
02/14 05:58, 73F
→
02/14 05:59, , 74F
02/14 05:59, 74F
推
02/14 08:41, , 75F
02/14 08:41, 75F
→
02/14 10:39, , 76F
02/14 10:39, 76F
推
02/14 15:54, , 77F
02/14 15:54, 77F
推
02/14 20:10, , 78F
02/14 20:10, 78F
→
02/14 20:10, , 79F
02/14 20:10, 79F
→
02/14 20:11, , 80F
02/14 20:11, 80F
→
02/14 20:11, , 81F
02/14 20:11, 81F
→
02/14 20:11, , 82F
02/14 20:11, 82F
→
02/14 20:12, , 83F
02/14 20:12, 83F
→
02/14 20:12, , 84F
02/14 20:12, 84F
→
02/14 20:13, , 85F
02/14 20:13, 85F
→
02/14 20:13, , 86F
02/14 20:13, 86F
→
02/14 20:14, , 87F
02/14 20:14, 87F
→
02/14 20:15, , 88F
02/14 20:15, 88F
推
02/15 01:38, , 89F
02/15 01:38, 89F
→
02/15 06:16, , 90F
02/15 06:16, 90F
推
02/15 20:31, , 91F
02/15 20:31, 91F
→
02/16 17:37, , 92F
02/16 17:37, 92F
推
10/17 03:51, , 93F
10/17 03:51, 93F
討論串 (同標題文章)
本文引述了以下文章的的內容:
完整討論串 (本文為第 2 之 3 篇):