Re: [討論] 關於模聯 (恐英文者慎入)
※ 引述《backpacker18 (犀牛好可愛)》之銘言：
: 引用原文
: 「
: To the MUN community.
: First, right off the bat, I’m stating that I respect each and everyone’s o
pi
: nions. I also understand that we all see things in a different limelight- th
er
: efore I’m writing this to express mine. Hope that others will treat me with
t
: he same amount of respect, but also feel free to share your opinions in a “
di
: plomatic courtesy”. (Also, yes. I’m writing this in english, because it’s
t
: he language I’m most comfortable using. Not because I’m a “Western wannab
e
: ”, believe it or not. Though I’m contemplating posting a Mandarin version.
..
: )
: 1. Regarding how “MUN is now only a rich man’s game”.
: If you’re going to be complaining about the ridiculous prices of some confe
re
: nces, please, um, don’t when you’ve CHOSEN to go to those conferences. Yes
,
: I agree. There are some conferences that I would really like to go to, but,
un
: fortunately, they are overpriced. Now, idk why they’ve come to be this expe
ns
: ive or wth they are doing with the money, but, here’s a thing: don’t choos
e
: to go to them. Pretty simple, right? You can find conferences ranging from 2
00
: NT to 6000+ NT. Why not choose going to the cheaper ones? It’ll save you a
l
: ot of saliva and typing. Who knows, maybe if lesser people are going to expe
ns
: ive conferences they’ll end up lowering the price (?
: 2. Regarding how “MUN is only for people who are good at English”.
: Here’s the thing: there are so many aspects to MUN. It’s not just about ho
w
: good your english is, it’s also about articulating your thoughts, approachi
ng
: people with diplomatic courtesy, thinking critically, putting yourself in d
if
: ferent POVs...etc. However, I’ll admit that people with better english can
ac
: hieve all these easier in an ENGLISH conference. And vice versa, in a CHINES
E
: conference. If I attended a conference in Chinese, tbh I don’t think I’ll
be
: able to perform as well compared to English conferences. Yes, I’ll still h
av
: e my own critical thinking intact, but it’s merely just because I’m (1) no
t
: confident enough in using it and (2) I’m not as fluent in it compared to my
E
: nglish. Nowadays, practically every conference has at least one chinese comm
it
: tee. It’s a CHOICE. I don’t think being good in english is something to br
ag
: about, and vice versa with chinese, too. Just because a person speaks engli
sh
: well, doesn’t mean that they have anything in their brains to offer.
: 3. Regarding “Westernization”.
: I honestly think that the people that are making a fuss about this are child
is
: h and have not taken anything from MUN at all. If some people want to speak
mo
: re “western” or act more “western”, LET THEM BE. Honestly, is it hurting
y
: ou? Is it hurting your cat? Your dog? The environment? The world? No. Some p
eo
: ple might just respect more cultures more than others. What about 韓流 or 日
流
: or whatever- 流？I don’t see anything wrong with that. And regarding peopl
e
: who think westernization equals international. First off, westernization doe
s
: not equal to international. Take Donald Trump for example. Enough said.
: 4. Regarding how “some delegates just follow around delegates that are more
w
: ell-spoken”.
: It’s true that this happens a lot. But I think that everyone’s abilities a
nd
: experiences with MUN are different. Some might be less experience, therefor
e
: they’d naturally want to latch onto an experienced delegate that makes them
f
: eel more at ease or someone they think can guide them. Thinking back at when
I
: first started MUN as a 7th grader, it was something I was guilty of, too. A
nd
: I think a lot of people will experience when first starting out. Just becau
se
: now you get BDs all the time or you’re a bloc leader or you get offers to
ch
: air doesn’t mean that you are in any way better than them. Instead of posti
ng
: on FB and complaining about this, why not actually approach those certain d
el
: egates and ask why they’ve chosen to join a certain bloc or give some encou
ra
: gement? You could even yield some time to them. All of us were beginners at
fi
: rst. How high of a pedestal do you put yourself on that you’d actually disc
ri
: minate or dislike the delegates that are doing the things you previously did
?
: 5. Regarding how “MUN is not about the academics anymore”.
: I agree. Completely. It’s not just about the academics. It’s about how pro
fe
: ssional the conference room is. If the social event is “dope” enough. If t
he
: guys/girls in your committee are hot. If the page notes they give you are c
ut
: e. If you meet new friends. If you meet old friends. If you get a t-shirt. I
f
: you make unforgettable memories. If the food there is good. If you spent a l
on
: g time researching and preparing. If it’ll look good on your college applic
at
: ion form. If you improved from your last conference. If the photographers ta
ke
: good photos that make you look taller than you actually are (Is this one ju
st
: me? Kay.). What I’m trying to say is- everyone sees MUN differently, and e
ve
: ryone attends MUN for different reasons. Some might see the importance in ac
ad
: emics, some might not. If you really want to attend a conference with impres
si
: onable academics, ask a friends for some reviews or do some research. I’m p
re
: tty sure if you’ve been in the MUN community long enough, you already have
a
: basic impression on most conferences. Regardless of people’s motives for at
te
: nding MUN, we should just respect each other. At the end of the day, it’s t
he
: ir money, not yours.
: Lastly, some people might disagree with me or think that I’m just naive or
wh
: atever. But coming from a fairly young MUNer that started out in 7th grade a
nd
: is now a rising 10th grader, I think that all the so-called problems are se
lf
: -inflicted. We all have a part in why the MUN society in Taiwan has become t
hi
: s way. I admit that sometimes I’m very under-prepared or I use English as a
n
: advantage in conferences. Therefore, what I’m just trying to say is:
: Don’t bitch about it if you are one of the causes of these so-called proble
ms
: - start by changing yourself first . 」
: 這是一個模聯社的副社長寫的
: 本人看完雖也有些微詞，但自己本身也沒參加過模聯，不太好做評論
: 想請問板上參加過模聯的大大給點意見，自己參加過的模聯是否像她說的這樣？
: 原文網址
: https://m.facebook.com/notes/sidney-khoe/to-the-mun-community/72437574770342
8/
: 英文頗多抱歉惹
: 不習慣看英文的也可以趁機會練閱讀（？
以下是我在此文筆者fb個人頁面的留言，跟大家分享一下，請各位不吝賜教
1、文中提到從200元到6000元的mun都有，但事實上價格低於1000元的mun並不多而低價的
會議通常不包含住宿，但我自己辦過會議，我知道這可能是難以避免的，資金的部分可能
需要外界的金援(ex 企業 政府)，但大部分的會議對於高中生以及一般家庭來說非常昂貴
我相信是不爭的事實。
2.文中提到英文能力在模聯中不是唯一，我不否認，但事實上在會議中若無法流暢的
使用英文，便無法適當的表達自己的言論，也無法成功的使自己的想法被傾聽，而中
文會在台灣似乎也並不是發展的十分完善，往往僅僅是用以作為“模聯新手村來使用
”，因此就算有妳提出的兩個方案，英文不流利的人要展開模聯之路困難度還是非常
高的。
3.關於文中提到所謂韓流日流等流行文化的類比，我相信這和模聯中常見的“歐
美主流化”是不同面向的東西，常見的日流和韓流多為強勢的主流文化，影響的
面向包括穿著、用語、飲食等，而“歐美主流化”則是由於歐美國家掌握強勢媒
體以及新聞話語權所造成的，影響就觸及了我們對於國際事件的看法，長久之下
的影響自然嚴重於流行文化所能造成的，而模聯參與者中又有許多人誤將歐美化
認為國際話，便更加使人擔憂。
總規下來，模聯的確是一個充滿階級的活動，能夠在模聯場上看見的高中生
，通常來自私立高中、前段國立高中、以及國際或雙語學校，而這些學生自
己本身除了代表在高中生社群中的特定階級之外，他們所出身的家庭在社會
上也多半為中上階級，才有辦法培養一個能夠參加模聯的孩子(ex：英文能
力培養、教育資源)
因此，模聯便形成了一個充滿階級成分的活動，不論其立意多麼良善，
現階段的模聯活動能觸及的只有特定階層或身份的學生，因為這個活動
的門檻實在太高了，而我們身為參與者，認知到這個問題之後應該要開
始檢討的是現今的模聯活動要如何觸及更多不同來源的學生。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 111.83.80.135
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/SENIORHIGH/M.1472028859.A.908.html
推
08/24 17:53, , 1F
08/24 17:53, 1F
→
08/24 17:53, , 2F
08/24 17:53, 2F
晚會其實應該是在模擬實際的社交場合，一方面也是給予會議參加者一些休閒機會和空間
，我覺得是不錯的，但是常常有些人本末倒置，將社交晚宴作為第一考量，但目前有些會
議已經將社交晚宴作為可自由選擇參加與否的項目
※ 編輯: CrystalCastl (111.83.80.135), 08/24/2016 18:20:16
推
08/24 22:33, , 3F
08/24 22:33, 3F
推
08/25 21:00, , 4F
08/25 21:00, 4F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 3 之 4 篇)：
討論
14
36