[期刊] 投稿經驗

看板PhD作者dk191726 (DK狂)時間15年前 (2010/12/08 15:04)推噓13(13推 0噓 2→)

留言15則, 15人參與討論串3/5 (看更多)

1.期刊: Green chemistry 2.結果: minor revised--> accepted 3.reviewer數目: 2 過程: 老闆覺得這次的題目創意性夠因此和老闆討論後一開始先決定嘗試往高點數期刊投稿反正被打槍就算了，就當作是經驗吧! 於是就各別往這些期刊投稿 a. Angewandte Chemie International Edition: b. Journal of the American Chemical Society 之前早有耳聞這類期刊審稿速度很快，就算被rejected 也不會太浪費時間投稿出去後，果然都只要一天就回來了主編覺得應用性太"specific" 沒經過外審，直接rejected c. Advanced materials 這次的審稿時間大概三個禮拜，還以為進入外審階段，有機會了!! 不過回來之後，結果也是一樣主編內審結果，直接rejected 理由也是一樣"specific application" 不過這位主編還推薦了另一個期刊給我參考以下是mail內容: "> Thank you for submitting the above-mentioned manuscript. > > Regretfully, I must inform you that the manuscript will not be considered > further for ADVANCED MATERIALS. > > The reasons for this are that we receive considerably more papers than we > can possibly publish in the limited available space, and that the results > and content of your manuscript seem to be more suitable for a polymer > science-related journal. Therefore what I recommend is that the manuscript is considered for our > journal Macromolecular Rapid Communications (http://www.mrc-journal.de), > which is the journal of choice for rapid publication of high priority > results in the field of polymer science and ranks 2nd by Impact Factor > (2009 IF: 4.3) among all journals predominantly publishing original > research in general polymer science. > The Editor of Macromolecular Rapid Communications has agreed to this > suggestion and would be happy to have your manuscript reviewed for this > journal. > > If you choose to follow this suggestion, please upload your manuscript as > a new submission to Macromolecular Rapid Communications using > http://www.manuscriptxpress.com. In your cover letter, please mention this > correspondence to expedite the handling of your manuscrip 後來老闆覺得如果參考他的期刊投稿，還不是要經過審查而且也會有被rejected的可能，在考慮IF點數下，決定不考慮這期刊繼續往下投，首先比較了Chem.commun. Anal.Chem. 及Green.Chem 的IF，以及這次實驗的主題與期刊scopes，最後決定Green chemistry 在cover letter中強調這次實驗的重點及其應用性最後提出建議的reviewer有三位 1.Prof. Thomas Welton 2.Prof. Vivek Polshettiwar 3.Prof. Alejandro Cifuentes 前兩位算是與我這次實驗有關領域之大師 11/12 submission--> 12/3 回信內容: minor revised I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been recommended for publication in Green Chemistry subject to revision in line with the attached reports 接著是reviewer的問題第一位先說明accept的理由: "This is a greatly improved synthetic methodology resulting in ........, Therefore, I favour publication as a communication in green chemistry." 接著提出五個問題，補一個ref. ，在討論中補上幾句話都不算太刁難第二位reviewer完全沒問題，並稱讚了一下，真是受寵若驚 "It is well-written and an excellent piece of work.... I recommend its publication in Green Chemistry. " 12/7 revised manuscript 12/8 收到accepted letter，速度真是快!! "Thank you for submitting your revised manuscript. I am satisfied with the changes you have made, and I am therefore pleased to inform you that your paper has been accepted for publication in Green Chemistry." -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.135.56.103

推

littlest

12/08 15:54, , 1^F

12/08 15:54, 1^F

推

Diesigy

12/08 15:56, , 2^F

12/08 15:56, 2^F

推

koala1012

12/08 16:47, , 3^F

12/08 16:47, 3^F