Re: [外絮] Phil Jackson在新書中比較喬神&Kobe已回收
※ 引述《redplum (LIVESTRONG)》之銘言:
: 標題: Re: [外絮] Phil Jackson在新書中比較喬神&Kobe
: 時間: Fri May 17 09:46:03 2013
:
: Quote:
:
: "No question, Michael was a tougher, more intimidating defender," Jackson
: writes. "He could break through virtually any screen and shut down almost any
: player with his intense, laser-focused style of defense."
: Michael毫無疑問的是更強硬,更具恐嚇力的防守者,他可以鑽到任何單擋裡,靠壓迫對方來
: 鎖死任何對手,是個超級專注的防守者
:
: "In general, Kobe tends to rely more heavily on his flexibility and
: craftiness, but he takes a lot of gambles on defense and sometimes pays the
: price."
: 而Kobe的防守比較依賴他的靈活性跟創造性,常常做賭博式防守,也時常付出代價
:
: "One of the biggest differences between the two stars from my perspective was
: Michael's superior skills as a leader," Jackson writes. "Though at times he
: could be hard on his teammates, Michael was masterful at controlling the
: emotional climate of the team with the power of his presence. Kobe had a long
: way to go before he could make that claim. He talked a good game, but he'd
: yet to experience the cold truth of leadership in his bones, as Michael had."
: 從我的觀點看來Michael跟Kobe最大的差別是,Michael是超級的領導者,雖然有時他對隊友
: 非常嚴厲,但大致上他都可以用他的專制來控制隊友的情緒,而Kobe花了很多時間才成為真
: 正的領導者,他是很會在大家面前發言,但他還沒體會到一個冰冷的事實是---他跟Michael
: 天生就有所不同
:
:
: 看有誰要繼續接力
:
: ※ 引述《sx4152 (呵呵)》之銘言:
: : Phil Jackson Compares Kobe Bryant And Michael Jordan In New Book
: : By Ramneet Singh| May 16, 2013|
: : Michael Jordan will go down in many peoples’ eyes as the greatest player to
: : ever play the game of basketball. Jordan amassed countless accolades over his
: : illustrious career and he forever changed the NBA with his on-court heroics
: : and off the court projects. However, over the years Kobe Bryant has given
: : Jordan a run for his money and has sparked a debate as to who is the better
: : player.
: : Micheal Jordan在許多球迷的心目中是最好的球員,Jordan在他卓越的籃球生涯中
: : 獲得了無數的榮耀與稱讚,而且他場上場外的球星風采徹底顛覆了整個聯盟,然而,幾些
: : 年後,Kobe Bryant逐漸追上了Jordan所賺的錢與表現,這使得我們要來討論誰是最好的
: : 球員
: : Perhaps no one knows the two players better than the man who led them to all
: : of their championship rings, Phil Jackson. Jackson coached the two superstars
: : in their primes and he offered a comparison in his new book. Jackson will be
: : releasing ”Eleven Rings: The Soul of Success” very soon and Mike Bresnahan
: : had a chance to get a glimpse at the book.
: : 或許沒人比Phil Jackson還瞭解這兩個男人,他曾帶領他們拿下冠軍,Jackson在這兩個
: : 超級球星的巔峰時期執教過他們,而他將在他的新書來比較他們兩位
: : Phil Jackson的新書:"11個戒指:勝利之魂"
: : 以下是書摘:
: : “Michael was more charismatic and gregarious than Kobe. He loved hanging out
: : with his teammates and security guards, playing cards, smoking cigars, and
: : joking around,”
: : 喬丹比起Kobe更具有魅力及合群性,他喜歡跟他的隊友/保鑣一起廝混,一起打牌,
: : 抽雪茄,還有一起開玩笑
: : “Kobe is different. He was reserved as a teenager, in part because he was
: : younger than the other players and hadn’t developed strong social skills in
: : college. When Kobe first joined the Lakers, he avoided fraternizing with his
: : teammates. But his inclination to keep to himself shifted as he grew older.
: : Increasingly, Kobe put more energy into getting to know the other players,
: : especially when the team was on the road.”
: : 反觀Kobe,他是個冷淡的少年,這多少是因為他在隊伍中是最年輕的,以及他沒有在
: : 大學中學到如何社交,當Kobe初入湖人隊,他避免與其他人友善,他傾向讓自己變得成熟,
: : 漸漸的,在球隊正在起步時,Kobe放了更多精力去認識其他球員
: : “Jordan was also more naturally inclined to let the game come to him and not
: : overplay his hand, whereas Kobe tends to force the action, especially when
: : the game isn’t going his way. When his shot is off, Kobe will pound away
: : relentlessly until his luck turns. Michael, on the other hand, would shift
: : his attention to defense or passing or setting screens to help the team win
: : the game.”
: : Jordan比較會主宰比賽但不會過度自幹,反觀Kobe,他會選擇獨攬一切,尤其是比賽
: : 不如他的意時
: : 當Kobe開始投不進籃時,他會拼命投籃直到手感回來,Jordan在他狀況不好時,他會
: : 把注意力放在防守或傳球或幫隊友掩護來贏得勝利
: : Jackson also said Jordan “was stronger, with bigger shoulders and a sturdier
: : frame,” which helped him pass defenses. As for Bryant, the Zen Master said
: : his finesse and flexibility allowed him to get through defenders.
: : Jackson說Jordan比Kobe還強壯,更具肩膀,更具有堅毅的精神,這讓他無懈可擊
: : 反觀Kobe,禪師說Kobe是靠他的技巧&靈活性來擊敗防守者
: : From the excerpts released, it seems as though Jackson favors Jordan over
: : Bryant when choosing the better player. Although Bryant can very well be
: : considered the second greatest shooting guard of all-time, Jordan is truly in
: : a class of his own. Jackson may choose to pick Jordan over Bryant, but there
: : is no doubt Kobe’s success is something not many people will ever match.
: : 我們可以知道,Jackson比較喜歡Jordan,雖說Kobe被認為是史上第二的SG,但喬丹
: : 是在另外一個境界,Jackson也許會選擇Jordan為最好的球員,但不可否認的是,Kobe的成功
: : 也達到了大部分人所無法到達的境界
: : In terms of number of championships and individual awards, Jordan has the
: : upper hand against Bryant; however, the Black Mamba has a chance to tie Jordan
: : ’s six rings and surpass him on the all-time scoring list in the near
: : future.
: : 就冠軍數與個人獎項,喬丹是比Kobe強多了,但黑曼巴還是有機會追齊Jordan的六座
: : 冠軍,與超越喬丹的成就
: : source: http://ppt.cc/qiad
:
: --
: "Stats are for losers, so you keep looking at stats,
: we'll keep looking at wins" Tampa Bay's Raheem Morris
:
: "數據是給輸家看的,你們繼續專研數據,我們繼續想法子贏球"
: 坦帕灣 羅辛‧莫里斯
:
: --
: ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
: ◆ From: 114.137.44.122
: → kaede0711 :這本書根本就是在裱Kobe,明知道比不上還狂比XD 05/17 09:47
: 推 ILLwill :怎麼說呢?有些比較晚看球的人都會聽說MJ是KB模板 05/17 09:50
: → ILLwill :但其實是完全不同層次球員 05/17 09:50
: → Alipapa :PHIL幹麻一直說大家原本就知道的事呢?? 05/17 09:50
: → anikishawn : 板模 05/17 09:51
: → redplum :真正看過兩人打球的人才會知道他們之間的差異性 05/17 09:51
: 另外
:
: 這裡並沒有對Kobe不敬
:
: 我們都知道Kobe比不上Michael
:
: 但有件事情Michael絕對比不上Kobe
:
: 就是Kobe未達目的不擇手段的精神比Michael更適合一般人學習
:
: Michael就有點像天生條件就超級好的好勝者 當然他的成就幾乎跟神話一樣難以處碰
: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
: Kobe相較Michael而言先天條件就有限制 但是靠著後天努力來補足
: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
: 這不是更適合我們一般人模仿嗎?
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
首先感謝R大的翻譯
但以初期的身體素質與成就來看(wiki):
Kobe:在費城郊區的勞爾梅里恩高中(Lower Merion HS)度過高中籃球生涯
在高中最後一年每場平均30.8分、12個籃板、6.5個助攻、4個抄截和3.8個阻攻[4],
率領球隊獲得53年以來的第一個州冠軍,
在高中球季累積的2883分更打破了名人堂球星威爾特·張伯倫保持的賓州東南區記錄。
Jordan:在10年級時由於身高不夠(1.80米),未能入選當地中學的高中籃球校隊。
為了證明自己的能力,他在初中校隊的比賽中多次獲得單場超過40分的成績。
在第二年,他的身高長了10公分,外加努力的訓練,終於入選了高中校隊。
在高中最後兩年他的每場平均得分達到了20分,並入選了全美高中最佳陣容
Kobe才是天生條件超級好的好勝者(打破張伯倫的高中記錄)
Jordan反而是先天條件有限制,靠努力訓練才擠進籃球隊
感覺Jordan更適合我們模仿
恕刪
:
: 能跟最偉大的比較已經非常光榮了
: → kaede0711 :Kobe哪裡適合一般人= =,他是標準天才又偏執的典型 05/17 10:03
: → neos042 :KOBE和JORDAN都是我最愛的球員,希望KOBE奪第六冠! 05/17 10:03
: 推 turbo66 :我只能說摳比很多地方要跟喬丹學習 05/17 10:03
: → IBIZA :MJ作人也不算成功 只是他能讓人服氣 05/17 10:03
:
: 上一篇說的Michael喜歡跟朋友 保鑣在一起 這個朋友跟保鑣應該就是Charles Oakley吧
:
: Michael會跟朋友一起出門是因為他沒辦法自己出門 這是巨星的悲哀
:
: Kobe上次接受訪問時他說他可以自己去逛Macy's百貨公司 而且沒人理他
:
: 他們兩個生活型態也有點不同 Jordan有些不良嗜好 賭博 抽雪茄 熬夜泡吧
: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
: 這些都是Michael當球員時就有的娛樂
: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
: 而Kobe比較喜歡歐洲式的生活方式
再次感謝R大的翻譯,可是比起當球員時的生活形態(習慣?)與嗜好,
不知道105, 某事被告進法院,東西不自己收,被拍賣又告母親進法院
這種歐洲式生活方式好像更不像是NBA球員的生活方式?
: ※ 編輯: redplum 來自: 114.137.44.122 (05/17 10:17)
: → kaede0711 :如果比不上MJ就不是天才,那全NBA沒天才了 05/17 10:04
: 推 jinabs98 :比對超級勝利者1~2名的書 人生失敗者買最多 05/17 10:04
: 推 ckshchen :未達目的不擇手段的精神....服務生 05/17 10:04
: 推 allen12126 :Kobe有人氣,但人緣並不好,跟他相處過的人都不喜歡他 05/17 10:07
: 推 ILLwill :要我說,Kobe就是冰人格文被當成魔術一樣的敬重 05/17 10:07
: → ILLwill :是很偉大,但又過譽 05/17 10:08
: 推 Linethan :對比較年輕的球迷來說 可能沒看過MJ打球 但是看Kobe 05/17 10:08
: 推 bradad :禪師又在靠消費他人賣書 這梗還真是寫不膩 05/17 10:08
: → Linethan :看了十幾年 自然會想知道Kobe跟MJ比到底如何 05/17 10:08
: 推 lejnsaryai :最適合一般人的不是林嗎 突破黃種人體能障礙跟歧視 05/17 10:09
: → Linethan :寫什麼書只不過是依照讀者想看什麼罷了 05/17 10:09
: → kaede0711 :我也覺得姑且喜不喜歡,亞洲人要類比還不如找林 05/17 10:09
: → kaede0711 :去找兩個人生勝利組,然後再來說較差的值得我學習 05/17 10:10
: → kaede0711 :這真的是= = 05/17 10:11
: → satheni :是不知道他哪裡不擇手段,連傳球都不太願意了.... 05/17 10:11
: → pounil :Mike Brown: 關於LAODA和LBJ 我也可以出書囉 05/17 10:11
: 推 newtypeL9 :JORDAN對勝利的偏執也是不輸給KOBE的,他好勝心之強. 05/17 10:12
: 推 neos042 :人家是說"做事的精神",竟扯到亞洲人打籃球和LIN..... 05/17 10:12
: → pounil : 請各位讀者到時多多捧場 05/17 10:12
: 推 ILLwill :要看什麼事,我會希望學習MJ擋人防守確實,但不用學 05/17 10:13
: → ILLwill :他愛賭錢 05/17 10:13
: 推 micbrimac :說Jordan做人成功,應該也還好...他的醜聞也挺多... 05/17 10:16
: → kaede0711 :說句實在的,你去比較MJ跟Kobe的出生跟籃球成長背景 05/17 10:16
: 推 KenRock :push 05/17 10:16
: → kaede0711 :你就知道去說MJ超人素質都是事後論,基本上能打NBA更 05/17 10:17
: → kaede0711 :甚而取得他們這種成就的,哪個不是在身體及精神面超群 05/17 10:17
: 推 ILLwill :老喬根本是信長個性做人哪裡好,老大大概是石田三成 05/17 10:18
: 推 micbrimac :就算放到現在,MJ的體能還是優於許多現今球員 05/17 10:18
: → micbrimac :能跟MJ比體能的大概只有LBJ而已 05/17 10:18
: 推 lejnsaryai :為什麼不能扯?籃球運動黃種人本來就比較吃虧 要站上 05/17 10:18
: → lejnsaryai :nba 論後天努力一個是黃種人一個本來就是黑人 05/17 10:19
: → micbrimac :現今能罰球線起跳灌籃的也沒有幾人,有他那種協調性 05/17 10:19
: → micbrimac :的人又更少了‧ 05/17 10:19
: → vic1201 :在做兩個人的比較 為什麼硬要扯到第三人 05/17 10:20
: → lejnsaryai :純粹是對原PO說的 適合一般人模仿有感而發而已 05/17 10:21
: → micbrimac :MJ的體能就算放在歷史上,也是數一數二好的 05/17 10:21
: → lejnsaryai :也沒有特地在酸誰 05/17 10:21
: → IBIZA :好勝心強是一回事, 偏執是另一回事 05/17 10:22
: → IBIZA :就像Phil書裡講的, 同樣狀況不好被守住, MJ會想辦法 05/17 10:22
: → vic1201 :他只是在比較:兩人中"誰比較適合一般人模仿 05/17 10:22
恕刪
最後再感謝R大的翻譯
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 123.192.39.186
→
05/17 11:05, , 1F
05/17 11:05, 1F
→
05/17 11:05, , 2F
05/17 11:05, 2F
→
05/17 11:06, , 3F
05/17 11:06, 3F
推
05/17 11:07, , 4F
05/17 11:07, 4F
推
05/17 11:07, , 5F
05/17 11:07, 5F
→
05/17 11:07, , 6F
05/17 11:07, 6F
推
05/17 11:08, , 7F
05/17 11:08, 7F
→
05/17 11:08, , 8F
05/17 11:08, 8F
→
05/17 11:08, , 9F
05/17 11:08, 9F
→
05/17 11:09, , 10F
05/17 11:09, 10F
→
05/17 11:09, , 11F
05/17 11:09, 11F
推
05/17 11:09, , 12F
05/17 11:09, 12F
→
05/17 11:10, , 13F
05/17 11:10, 13F
推
05/17 11:10, , 14F
05/17 11:10, 14F
→
05/17 11:10, , 15F
05/17 11:10, 15F
→
05/17 11:10, , 16F
05/17 11:10, 16F
→
05/17 11:10, , 17F
05/17 11:10, 17F
→
05/17 11:10, , 18F
05/17 11:10, 18F
推
05/17 11:11, , 19F
05/17 11:11, 19F
→
05/17 11:11, , 20F
05/17 11:11, 20F
→
05/17 11:11, , 21F
05/17 11:11, 21F
→
05/17 11:11, , 22F
05/17 11:11, 22F
→
05/17 11:12, , 23F
05/17 11:12, 23F
推
05/17 11:12, , 24F
05/17 11:12, 24F
→
05/17 11:12, , 25F
05/17 11:12, 25F
→
05/17 11:13, , 26F
05/17 11:13, 26F
推
05/17 11:13, , 27F
05/17 11:13, 27F
噓
05/17 11:13, , 28F
05/17 11:13, 28F
推
05/17 11:13, , 29F
05/17 11:13, 29F
→
05/17 11:14, , 30F
05/17 11:14, 30F
推
05/17 11:14, , 31F
05/17 11:14, 31F
→
05/17 11:14, , 32F
05/17 11:14, 32F
推
05/17 11:14, , 33F
05/17 11:14, 33F
推
05/17 11:14, , 34F
05/17 11:14, 34F
推
05/17 11:14, , 35F
05/17 11:14, 35F
→
05/17 11:14, , 36F
05/17 11:14, 36F
推
05/17 11:15, , 37F
05/17 11:15, 37F
→
05/17 11:15, , 38F
05/17 11:15, 38F
→
05/17 11:15, , 39F
05/17 11:15, 39F
還有 65 則推文
→
05/17 12:50, , 105F
05/17 12:50, 105F
噓
05/17 12:53, , 106F
05/17 12:53, 106F
→
05/17 12:54, , 107F
05/17 12:54, 107F
→
05/17 12:54, , 108F
05/17 12:54, 108F
推
05/17 13:10, , 109F
05/17 13:10, 109F
→
05/17 13:13, , 110F
05/17 13:13, 110F
噓
05/17 13:32, , 111F
05/17 13:32, 111F
噓
05/17 13:34, , 112F
05/17 13:34, 112F
噓
05/17 13:34, , 113F
05/17 13:34, 113F
噓
05/17 13:37, , 114F
05/17 13:37, 114F
噓
05/17 13:40, , 115F
05/17 13:40, 115F
推
05/17 13:52, , 116F
05/17 13:52, 116F
→
05/17 13:53, , 117F
05/17 13:53, 117F
→
05/17 13:53, , 118F
05/17 13:53, 118F
→
05/17 13:54, , 119F
05/17 13:54, 119F
→
05/17 14:00, , 120F
05/17 14:00, 120F
→
05/17 14:00, , 121F
05/17 14:00, 121F
→
05/17 14:00, , 122F
05/17 14:00, 122F
→
05/17 14:09, , 123F
05/17 14:09, 123F
推
05/17 14:19, , 124F
05/17 14:19, 124F
→
05/17 14:19, , 125F
05/17 14:19, 125F
推
05/17 14:20, , 126F
05/17 14:20, 126F
→
05/17 14:29, , 127F
05/17 14:29, 127F
→
05/17 14:29, , 128F
05/17 14:29, 128F
→
05/17 14:29, , 129F
05/17 14:29, 129F
推
05/17 14:36, , 130F
05/17 14:36, 130F
→
05/17 14:37, , 131F
05/17 14:37, 131F
噓
05/17 14:55, , 132F
05/17 14:55, 132F
噓
05/17 15:36, , 133F
05/17 15:36, 133F
→
05/17 16:03, , 134F
05/17 16:03, 134F
噓
05/17 16:14, , 135F
05/17 16:14, 135F
推
05/17 16:33, , 136F
05/17 16:33, 136F
推
05/17 16:55, , 137F
05/17 16:55, 137F
→
05/17 18:16, , 138F
05/17 18:16, 138F
推
05/17 20:01, , 139F
05/17 20:01, 139F
→
05/17 20:02, , 140F
05/17 20:02, 140F
→
05/17 20:03, , 141F
05/17 20:03, 141F
推
05/18 07:34, , 142F
05/18 07:34, 142F
→
05/18 07:36, , 143F
05/18 07:36, 143F
噓
04/04 02:36, , 144F
04/04 02:36, 144F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 3 之 5 篇):