[問題] Pitfall Trap 墜穴陷阱的疑問

看板Magic作者oishi (.....)時間16年前 (2010/02/08 16:11)推噓1(1推 0噓 7→)

留言8則, 3人參與討論串1/2 (看更多)

Pitfall Trap Instant-Trap If exactly one creature is attacking, you may pay {W} rather than pay Pitfall Trap's mana cost. Destroy target attacking creature without flying. 問題:對手兩隻不會飛生物進行攻擊時，我殺了一隻，對手只剩一隻進攻生物，那麼我可以只支付替代費用將剩下的那隻進攻生物殺掉嗎？？答1: 類似規則506.5.(附下方) 殺了一隻，所以另一隻是"one creature is attacking" (特別強調attacking 不是 attacks) 可以只支付替代費用。答2: 對方宣告攻擊完，就是兩隻攻擊生物了，不可以只支付替代費用。 506.5. A creature attacks alone if it’s the only creature declared as an attacker during the declare attackers step. A creature is attacking alone if it’s attacking but no other creatures are. A creature blocks alone if it’s the only creature declared as a blocker during the declare blockers step. A creature is blocking alone if it’s blocking but no other creatures are. 剛開始我比較傾向於"答2"，但是看完506.5對於"attacks alone"及"is attacking alone" 的解釋，以及其兩者不同點，讓我開始傾向"答1"的答案!! 請問各位玩家們，解答應該是如何呢?? 謝謝大家 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.115.65.46

→

s123839

02/08 16:45, , 1^F

02/08 16:45, 1^F

→

plateauwolf

02/08 17:24, , 2^F

02/08 17:24, 2^F

→

oishi

02/08 17:41, , 3^F

02/08 17:41, 3^F