Re: [情報] 啟用即時重播 - 首兩月數據
※ 引述《asd831129 (SBP)》之銘言:
: MLB Owners approve expanded replay
: http://ppt.cc/0-Ey
: 在老闆會議上全票通過擴即時重播輔助判決
: 包括出局得分與否、好壞球數等
: 幾乎任何事都可重播
: 教練在前六局有一次的機會可以挑戰
: 挑戰成功就可以保留 類似網球鷹眼
: 七局後裁判自行選擇需要輔助與否
兩個月後:
According to data obtained from MLB's central office on Tuesday, there were
381 traditional replay reviews — 15 percent of which were umpire-initiated
rather than challenge-initiated — plus four more looks to check counts or
other record-keeping procedures in the first 759 games. Those challenges
totaled 830 minutes, meaning that the replays averaged 2 minutes, 9 seconds.
首兩個月的759場賽事裡,出現了381次重播輔助判決
其中有15%大約57次不是由教練挑戰,是裁判主動要求看Replay
另外有4次是主審忘記了好壞球數,要看影片確認
總合所有花在挑戰的時間是830分鐘,平均每次挑戰用了2分鐘09秒
大約每場比賽長了1分鐘6秒
重播的局數分佈在第一局最多,第三局最少
1st: 63
2nd: 34
3rd: 29
4th: 46
5th: 52
6th: 51
7th: 48
8th: 48
我先自首看不懂這圖片,所以不要問我為甚麼只有8局 囧
也不要問我為甚麼加起來只有371 囧
長條圖
http://goo.gl/q4cgOQ
各種挑戰總合成功率是47.2% 比起NFL往年平均的40%高
原判決 挑戰次數 上訴成功 原判 證據不足 翻盤率
Catch 7 7 0 0 100%
No Catch 5 4 0 1 80%
Safe 1st 69 41 7 21 59.4%
Safe other bases 83 42 18 23 50.6%
Out other bases 64 31 13 20 48.4%
Out 1st 82 36 20 26 43.9%
Other* 19 8 5 6 42.1%
Foul 12 4 2 6 33.3%
No home run 16 4 8 4 25.0%
Home run 9 2 6 1 22.2%
Plate block 15 1 13 1 6.7%
Total 381 180 92 109 47.2%
*Other includes things like HBPs and whether a ball hit the wall before
being caught.
大致上守備方抗議出局比較容易上訴成功
抗議safe或是沒被tag到比較容易失敗
全壘打判決的挑戰成功率也很低 不過因回報大所以會有教練嘗試
耗時方面 證據不足的時候耗時最多
證明裁判沒誤判用的時間則最少
Result Total plays Average time Std. Dev.
Confirmed 92 1:37 0:45
Overturned 180 2:03 0:53
Call stands 109 2:45 0:49
Source: FOX
Through nine weeks: What we've learned about instant replay
http://goo.gl/YG3cXo
--
本篇作者是BP的合約寫手,在BP上只能看到試閱版
然後BP原文要錢 Fox當天就丟到網上不用錢是怎樣 o.O
--
t a ◥███◣╮ ╭═╮ theanswer3 ╭◢█═ ███════╮
h n ║ █▌◥█╰══╯★╰════════════╯ █ █ ╴◤ ◣║
e s ║ █ ▄▄◤◢◢◣ ◣ ◢█◢ ◣█◣ ◢█◢ ◢█◣ █ ◥██◣ ̄◥/▄║
w ║ █ ▄▄◣█◤ █ █◢█ ███ █◢█ █◣ █ ▅ █ ﹀\ ║
e ║ █▌◢█ █ ◥ ◥◤█ ◥▌◤ ◥◤◥ ◥█◤◢█◣◥██◤╱ \ ║
r 3 ◢███◤══════ ▅◤═════════════════════╯
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 112.120.78.149
※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/MLB/M.1401948760.A.8E6.html
推
06/05 14:20, , 1F
06/05 14:20, 1F
推
06/05 14:27, , 2F
06/05 14:27, 2F
→
06/05 14:33, , 3F
06/05 14:33, 3F
推
06/05 14:36, , 4F
06/05 14:36, 4F
→
06/05 14:36, , 5F
06/05 14:36, 5F
推
06/05 14:39, , 6F
06/05 14:39, 6F
推
06/05 15:09, , 7F
06/05 15:09, 7F
推
06/05 16:05, , 8F
06/05 16:05, 8F
推
06/05 16:19, , 9F
06/05 16:19, 9F
→
06/05 16:27, , 10F
06/05 16:27, 10F
→
06/05 16:28, , 11F
06/05 16:28, 11F
推
06/05 16:30, , 12F
06/05 16:30, 12F
推
06/05 16:38, , 13F
06/05 16:38, 13F
推
06/05 16:56, , 14F
06/05 16:56, 14F
推
06/05 17:07, , 15F
06/05 17:07, 15F
→
06/05 17:08, , 16F
06/05 17:08, 16F
→
06/05 17:33, , 17F
06/05 17:33, 17F
→
06/05 17:33, , 18F
06/05 17:33, 18F
推
06/05 17:49, , 19F
06/05 17:49, 19F
→
06/05 17:51, , 20F
06/05 17:51, 20F
→
06/05 17:55, , 21F
06/05 17:55, 21F
推
06/05 18:00, , 22F
06/05 18:00, 22F
→
06/05 18:00, , 23F
06/05 18:00, 23F
→
06/05 18:01, , 24F
06/05 18:01, 24F
→
06/05 18:02, , 25F
06/05 18:02, 25F
→
06/05 18:03, , 26F
06/05 18:03, 26F
推
06/05 18:12, , 27F
06/05 18:12, 27F
→
06/05 18:13, , 28F
06/05 18:13, 28F
推
06/05 18:24, , 29F
06/05 18:24, 29F
→
06/05 18:25, , 30F
06/05 18:25, 30F
推
06/05 18:38, , 31F
06/05 18:38, 31F
→
06/05 18:38, , 32F
06/05 18:38, 32F
推
06/05 18:40, , 33F
06/05 18:40, 33F
推
06/05 19:45, , 34F
06/05 19:45, 34F
第9局不會不能用 延長賽第10局甚至12局都用過
我想是我看不懂那幅圖啦....
這個網站還不錯 紀錄了所有重播的局數跟資料
http://baseballsavant.com/apps/replays.php
推
06/05 20:04, , 35F
06/05 20:04, 35F
推
06/05 20:40, , 36F
06/05 20:40, 36F
→
06/05 20:41, , 37F
06/05 20:41, 37F
→
06/05 20:41, , 38F
06/05 20:41, 38F
→
06/05 20:42, , 39F
06/05 20:42, 39F
推
06/05 22:18, , 40F
06/05 22:18, 40F
→
06/05 22:19, , 41F
06/05 22:19, 41F
推
06/05 22:30, , 42F
06/05 22:30, 42F
→
06/05 22:31, , 43F
06/05 22:31, 43F
推
06/05 22:33, , 44F
06/05 22:33, 44F
→
06/05 23:24, , 45F
06/05 23:24, 45F
推
06/05 23:27, , 46F
06/05 23:27, 46F
→
06/05 23:28, , 47F
06/05 23:28, 47F
※ 編輯: catsondbs (113.254.104.72), 06/06/2014 01:16:22
推
06/08 16:31, , 48F
06/08 16:31, 48F