Re: 一條雜魚

看板MIN-Twins作者IronChef (Schadenfreude)時間16年前 (2007/12/05 19:17)推噓6(7推 1噓 3→)

留言11則, 8人參與討論串4/6 (看更多)

我剛才在一個很受歡迎的老外鄉民Blog看到評論. 我覺得有點參考價值 == Mr Steinbrenners son has stated that their offer is far and away the best. I think that's patently false == == There is a recurring theme out there that Melky Cabrera is a far superior piece of the pie here than Coco Crisp. A claim I would argue adamantly against. First off Melky is a career .275 hitter to Coco being a career .280 hitter ... From a purely talent standpoint there are many paths to go down. The first and hardest to define talent is defense. I have no idea how good/bad of an OF Melky is. From what I saw he is a good OF. Decent arm and covers ground. Coco on the other hand I would argue should have won the Gold Glove this year, hands down. He doesn’t have a cannon for an arm but I have never seen an OF impact games and save runs to the degree he did this year. Next to Andruw Jones, Tori Hunter and maybe 1-2 others Coco is as good at playing CF as anyone I’ve ever seen ... So if you look at the next 3-4 years I would think you might project Melky to possibly get better? Coco is in those ’prime’ years according to BP and Bill James. He’ll get older but the years he’s under contract are years that position players usually peak at. He adds a speed dimension as well. That matters more to a team playing on turf than it might mean to a team on grass. People would claim that the Coco didn’t live up to the potential he was supposed to coming from Cleveland. Coming out of Cleveland he was a 300 30 double 15 hr 15-20 steal guy who played ridiculous CF. In my opinion he’s more apt to be closer to that guy over the next few years than the guy who was hurt in 06 and just never got on track this year. That being said he was still an impact player for us. His CF defense won games this year. ... == == 當然這位鄉民很明顯的有Bias, 因為這位鄉民跟Melky Cabrera生涯的對戰成績是 22AB 5H 2BB 1K 1HR .310/.468 == -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.112.212.196

推

RandyME

12/05 19:17, , 1^F

12/05 19:17, 1^F

推

CGary

12/05 19:26, , 2^F

12/05 19:26, 2^F

→

shancko

12/05 19:29, , 3^F

12/05 19:29, 3^F