[討論] 蔡英文博士論文有標明出處！

看板HatePolitics作者kcbill (明日やろうは馬鹿野郎だ)時間3年前 (2020/08/12 21:18)推噓18(18推 0噓 12→)

留言30則, 20人參與討論串1/2 (看更多)

安安好像剛剛論文仔又高潮了一波根據林環牆教授臉書貼文發現說蔡英文博士論文抄襲兩段是抄襲貿易理論學者Harry G. Johnson 其實林環牆用紅框標起來的是第14頁兩句話 1. whether a country is absolutely strong or absolutely weak, it can maximize the power avialable to it by concentrating on those activities in which it is rel atively more powerful and hiring the services of specialists in those activiti es in which it is weaker. 2. Both the Ricardian and the Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson models carry the implicit assumption that involvement in international trade entails the enjoyment of e conomic benefits from efficient resource utilization with little or no cost in terms of serious disturbance to men’s livehood and economic and social lives . https://i.imgur.com/MKvM0j0.jpg

不過林環牆沒有貼出來的是下一頁第15頁 https://i.imgur.com/3QclpAI.jpg

很明顯的可以發現蔡英文在那邊有註記然後我們往註記頁那邊翻 https://i.imgur.com/t4iXZo1.jpg

就可以發現出處是Johnson在某本書的前言 H.G. Johnson, Forewords to the ‘Trade Effects of Public Subsidies to Private Enterprises’ by G. Denton, S. O’Cleireacan and S. Ash, pp. xxv （林環牆說的抄襲Johnson就是這邊這位）林環牆質疑抄襲的的第二句話在蔡英文有註記的這個出處的第xxv頁 https://i.imgur.com/XmfqW3o.jpg

而林環牆質疑的第一句話同樣在這個出處找得到在第xix頁 https://i.imgur.com/L1lNNge.jpg

論文仔最多也只能打林環牆質疑的第一句話蔡英文沒有緊接著明確標註而已（但其實那一段基本上就是簡述什麼叫做比較優勢理論而已）簡單google一下配合翻蔡英文論文的下一頁和註記頁就可以知道結果，論文仔可以高潮真的是www 有人要轉去八卦回原本爆卦那篇文嗎XD -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 60.251.182.61 (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/HatePolitics/M.1597238323.A.1F2.html

推

liam1984

08/12 21:19, 3年前 , 1^F

08/12 21:19, 1^F

推

meredith001

08/12 21:19, 3年前 , 2^F

08/12 21:19, 2^F

→

newby321

08/12 21:21, 3年前 , 3^F

08/12 21:21, 3^F