Re: [問題] 對哈利波特的一點小疑問(算是有雷吧...)

看板HarryPotter作者 (哈利波特完結了...)時間16年前 (2007/10/03 22:19), 編輯推噓1(108)
留言9則, 3人參與, 最新討論串4/4 (看更多)
※ 引述《linmin (peace)》之銘言: : : 推 nanpyn:哈利的鳳凰羽魔杖跟Elder Wand的忠誠是兩回事呀 10/02 00:10 : : → nanpyn:只能說Elder Wand的強大魔力是個特例才會有移轉主人的狀況 10/02 00:13 : : → nanpyn:不然一般的魔杖若被擊敗 只要取回 它還是會聽原來主人的話 10/02 00:13 : 關於這一點,以下這段還蠻耐人尋味的: : “Can you identify these?” Harry asked. : The wandmaker took the first of the wands and held it close to his faded eyes, : rolling it between his knobble-knuckled fingers, flexing it slightly. : “Walnut and dragon heartstring,” he said. “Twelve-and-three-quarter inches. : Unyielding. This wand belonged to Bellatrix Lestrange.” : “And this one?” : Ollivander performed the same examination. : “Hawthorn and unicorn hair. Ten inches precisely. Reasonably springy. This : was the wand of Draco Malfoy.” : “Was?” repeated Harry. “Isn't it still his?” : “Perhaps not. If you took it –” : “—I did – ” : “—then it may be yours. Of course, the manner of taking matters. Much also : depends upon the wand itself. In general, however, where a wand has been won, : its allegiance will change.” : 抱歉貼了一大段原文,不過我想換主人的情況不只是適用Elder Wand而已? 這讓我突然想到第一集電影的某畫面... 奧利凡德說過 是魔杖選擇它的主人 (應該沒記錯吧?XD) -- 幻變的夕色 有無盡的形容 短促的美麗 也深烙印生命 我殷熱的激情陣陣抽蓄著曾經 曾經我跋扈的呼吸 在朔風下甦醒 讓未知孵化我不渝的信仰 堅持在浩瀚人生巨流裡前航 回首的剎那 請容許我猖狂 飛揚的神思是種難解的訊息 ---張雨生 未知 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 59.121.122.184

10/04 22:05, , 1F
沒錯 第七集也不斷強調這點
10/04 22:05, 1F

10/04 22:08, , 2F
I know. 但已修正為原主人「贏回」
10/04 22:08, 2F

10/04 22:08, , 3F
原本的推文是回應aclock而說
10/04 22:08, 3F

10/04 22:09, , 4F
哈利的魔杖如同每位巫師一樣都曾被繳械
10/04 22:09, 4F

10/04 22:09, , 5F
但只要原本的主人取回(掉了撿起來)或贏回(戰勝)原魔杖
10/04 22:09, 5F

10/04 22:10, , 6F
當然還是繼續有效的
10/04 22:10, 6F

10/04 22:12, , 7F
即使路平在第三集第十七章贏過哈利 他並未持有哈利的魔杖
10/04 22:12, 7F

10/04 22:14, , 8F
That's the major difference.
10/04 22:14, 8F

10/05 19:15, , 9F
其實我只是好奇同時用好幾根魔杖會不會威力加倍....
10/05 19:15, 9F
文章代碼(AID): #170wJmJZ (HarryPotter)
討論串 (同標題文章)
文章代碼(AID): #170wJmJZ (HarryPotter)