Re: [文法] first time & last time

看板Eng-Class作者coldeye (知其不可奈何而安之若命)時間12年前 (2013/09/07 00:16)推噓2(2推 0噓 5→)

留言7則, 2人參與討論串4/4 (看更多)

※ 引述《chrisjon (即將再當澳客)》之銘言： : ※ 引述《coldeye (知其不可奈何而安之若命)》之銘言： : : 請問下列哪些正確？ : : 我原本覺得是(a3)和(b2)，但發現眾說紛紜。 : : (a1)It is the first time they met. : 發生這件事時，你人在現場我覺得時態錯了應該改成It was : : (a2)It was the first time they met. : 敘述一件過去發生過的事澳籍老師&作家曾糾正這種用法英式英文好像也不能接受不過我知道美式可以接受就是了 : : (a3)It was the first time they had ever met. : 感覺…句子怪怪的，應該不會這樣用這我確定對出自Oxford Dictionary : : (b1)The last time I saw him was four years ago. : 一般敘述句意見一樣 : : (b2)The last time I had seen him was four years ago. : 沒有這樣用的(旁邊的澳洲人說的XD) 我查了一些資料後，發現相較於first，last的用法比較複雜。像是That was the first time I had run the Taipei Marathon. (那是我第一次參加台北馬拉松) That was the last time I ran the Taipei Marathon. (那是我最後一次參加台北馬拉松=>再也不參加了) The last time I had run the Taipei Marathon was in July. (我最後一次參加台北馬拉松是在七月的時候=>有可能還會參加) : : (b3)The last time I had seen him had been four years ago. : 個人也不會用這句，不過感覺ago是多餘的意見相同，這句應該不對。不過倒是看到一本書寫： The last time I had been to the Newark airport had been September 10, when Todd and I had returned from Rome. The day we departed I had dropped off Todd and.... 用法應該和b3不同就是了 : 以上是個人不負責語感回答:p 謝謝:) -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.133.190.210 ※ 編輯: coldeye 來自: 220.133.190.210 (09/07 00:17)

推

wohtp

09/07 15:47, , 1^F

09/07 15:47, 1^F

→

wohtp

09/07 15:49, , 2^F

09/07 15:49, 2^F

→

wohtp

09/07 15:49, , 3^F

09/07 15:49, 3^F