Re: [文法] 文法問題
※ 引述《AlexanderW (Alexander Wang )》之銘言：
: ※ 引述《hopeliu (阿翔)》之銘言：
: : I ____________ her when she was ill.
: : (A) often helped
: : (B) have often helped
: : (C) has often helped
: : 請問這題，
: : 答案A，
: : B為什麼不可以？
: : 感謝各位大大。
: : → zofloya:B是現在式 02/21 22:18
: : 推 tijj:Eng-Class 02/22 09:56
: : → tijj:因為出題者不知道B可以 02/22 10:00
: 如果想像時態 在一個時間線上 完成式B points to a period of time.
: 跟後面 she was ill (at one point in time) 是不對稱的 hence (A)
大部分人都知道A對, 但不表B錯. 出題者真的功力不夠.
When-Clauses and Temporal Structure Renaat Declerck p 166
(37 b) I have often helped him when he was ill.
Sentence (37b) can be paraphrased as (37 b'):
(37 b') It has often happened that I helped him when he was ill.
※ 編輯: tijj 來自: 210.69.13.1 (02/22 16:57)
推
02/23 08:07, , 1F
02/23 08:07, 1F
討論串 (同標題文章)