[文法] 關係代名詞的疑問

看板Eng-Class作者時間13年前 (2012/11/23 17:49), 編輯推噓1(1推 0噓 16→)
留言17則, 6人參與, 6年前最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
關係代名詞用什麼格，依子句而定。 但我不太會從子句判斷要用哪個 who whose whom The woman whose bag you took was angry about it. 為什麼這句不用who? 另外是否能用把whose這個位子改成that? 這部分一直搞不懂，謝謝^^ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 36.226.116.114
→
11/24 00:56, , 1F
"...不用who?"--> 那麼我們就用who來看看這個關係子句:
11/24 00:56, 1F
→
11/24 00:56, , 2F
... who(=the woman) bag you took was angry about it.
11/24 00:56, 2F
→
11/24 00:56, , 3F
(為了方便你理解作的變化)-->
11/24 00:56, 3F
→
11/24 00:56, , 4F
the woman bag you took was angry about it
11/24 00:56, 4F
→
11/24 00:57, , 5F
有沒有看出問題？如果你看不出來，那麼你的問題就不只是如
11/24 00:57, 5F
→
11/24 00:57, , 6F
何選關係代名詞而已...
11/24 00:57, 6F
→
11/24 10:08, , 7F
謝謝，感覺有怪怪的，但我還是不大懂..
11/24 10:08, 7F
→
11/24 10:09, , 8F
The woman who bag....(那個女人，被你拿走包包的那個，在生
11/24 10:09, 8F
→
11/24 10:09, , 9F
氣) 這樣翻起來好像也對 who whom whose要依哪邊判斷?
11/24 10:09, 9F
推
11/24 11:23, , 10F
在這句中 whose=the woman's 所有格後面才能接名詞
11/24 11:23, 10F
→
11/24 11:23, , 11F
You took the woman's bag.
11/24 11:23, 11F
→
11/24 11:24, , 12F
who只能代替名詞 例如the woman 後面就要接動詞
11/24 11:24, 12F
→
11/24 11:24, , 13F
不會接名詞(我指who當主詞的情況)
11/24 11:24, 13F
→
11/28 23:48, , 14F
還是那句老話，句型代換練習
11/28 23:48, 14F
→
09/07 00:10, , 15F
You took th https://daxiv.com
09/07 00:10, 15F
→
12/02 18:26, , 16F
You took th https://noxiv.com
12/02 18:26, 16F
→
04/13 22:44, 6年前 , 17F
who只能代替名詞 例 http://yaxiv.com
04/13 22:44, 17F
‣ 更多 virs 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1GhqR2yl (Eng-Class)
‣ 更多 virs 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1GhqR2yl (Eng-Class)