Re: [文法] 疑問詞為主詞的辨別法?

看板Eng-Class作者beatrice1009 (Vita borghese)時間15年前 (2010/11/24 11:44)推噓1(1推 0噓 10→)

留言11則, 2人參與討論串2/2 (看更多)

這個問題經大家的回答後好像還是無解我特別去問了出過很多英文學習相關書籍的專家他的解釋為: 有be動詞的情況,通常疑問詞為主詞所以What do you think is the situation?這句是對的但有些情況是例外: 如Who is he? Who are you?等等,疑問詞就為受詞補語所以加入do you think則成 Who do you think he is? ----------------------------------------------- 經以上統整, 我的想法是因為英文通常不喜歡頭重腳輕關於What is the situation? 和 What is the tone of the speaker? 回答比較常用xxx is the situation. 和 xxx is the tone of the speaker. 故What在此為主詞但是像Who are you? 那種簡短問句,就無頭重腳輕的疑慮故Who為受詞 -------------------------------------------------- 大家覺得這樣的解釋是否較合理? ※ 引述《beatrice1009 (Vita borghese)》之銘言： : 如何分別疑問詞為主詞或受詞 : 坊間專書跟網路搜尋我都找過了 : 雖知道大概的分別法但是以下這幾句讓我百思不解 : What do you think is the situation? : What do you consider is the tone of the speaker? : 這兩句為原來的句子插入 do you think 來詢問對方意見 : 但是書上說他的原句 : What is the situation? 和 What is the tone of the speaker? : 的疑問詞What在句中為主詞 : 但是不管用中文或用英文想 : What is the situation? 的回答應該是 The situation is XXX. : 而不是 XXX is the situation.吧 what怎會是主詞 : What do you consider is the tone of the speaker? : 回答也應該是The tone of the speaker is XXX. : what應該是受詞補語不是主詞 : 所以這兩句加入do you think/consider應該是 : What do you think the situation is? : 和 What do you consider the tone of the speaker is? 才對吧 : 煩請文法高手解釋!! : 難道課本寫錯了@@"? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.130.251.250

→

hubertt

11/24 11:49, , 1^F

11/24 11:49, 1^F

→

hubertt

11/24 11:50, , 2^F

11/24 11:50, 2^F

→

hubertt

11/24 11:51, , 3^F

11/24 11:51, 3^F