[討論] 包益民談新一代
我們班在爭論參不參加新一代 同學寫了一封信請教包先生
以下幾點中文的部份是認為不參加新一代的理由
英文的部份是包先生的回應
You will have tougher time and spend more money trying to do
the exhibition elsewhere.
I think 台創新一代設計展 is still your best chance.
The mission is to show the professionals as well as other
School what you can do. Here are my comments...
反對參加新一代的論點：
1.台創收費昂貴
yes, if they charge a lot. You have to find a way to make back the investment.
Money is never the issue if you can get good profit.
新一代設計展 draw a lot of people so potential is bigger to make bigger profit.
Spent time on how to make back the investment than complain about the cost.
2.真正去看學生作品的廠商老闆不多，大多數觀眾還是學生
then you need to invite more bosses and client to see your show,
to sponsor you, to attract them to come.
If you know this is a problem, the problem will not go away
if you move your exhibition elsewhere.
3.展場品質低落，如同菜市場
Shin Chien University make their exhibition really good. So you should also make yours equally impressive, if not better. It is no excuse to have ugly
venue and ugly show. You must be fully responsible
for the entire outcome.
4.質疑新一代評審的標準
the only standard here is to get your work out and
to show to as many people as possible.
5.設計的價值被扭曲( 拍賣專刊等行為 )
yes, I can see how Shin Chien has raise the bar and out sell the catalogs.
You must do something else different, attractive, able to show your work
and able to make a lot of money back
So everyone is happy. After all, this is perfect chance to use
Your creativity and market sense to entice your audience.
Good luck. I do not normally answer people mail. You
Are very lucky that I have few minutes today.
PAO
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
看完這封信 並沒有解除我對參不參加新一代的疑慮
新一代剝削學生的問題還是存在 由1.5點看來是造成展場變菜市場的可怕因果關係
費用方面我認我該花就花 不過在新一代我認為不過是燒錢的行為 花得頗沒價值
以上是我個人的觀點 希望可以得到大家的討論
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.131.30.243
推
05/25 05:20, , 1F
05/25 05:20, 1F
→
05/25 05:25, , 2F
05/25 05:25, 2F
→
05/25 05:26, , 3F
05/25 05:26, 3F
推
05/25 09:24, , 4F
05/25 09:24, 4F
推
05/25 09:46, , 5F
05/25 09:46, 5F
推
05/25 09:55, , 6F
05/25 09:55, 6F
→
05/25 09:55, , 7F
05/25 09:55, 7F
推
05/25 12:26, , 8F
05/25 12:26, 8F
→
05/25 12:27, , 9F
05/25 12:27, 9F
推
05/25 12:30, , 10F
05/25 12:30, 10F
→
05/25 12:40, , 11F
05/25 12:40, 11F
→
05/25 12:41, , 12F
05/25 12:41, 12F
推
05/25 12:43, , 13F
05/25 12:43, 13F
→
05/25 12:50, , 14F
05/25 12:50, 14F
→
05/25 12:51, , 15F
05/25 12:51, 15F
※ 編輯: fishb 來自: 140.131.30.243 (05/25 12:54)
推
05/25 13:12, , 16F
05/25 13:12, 16F
推
05/25 13:17, , 17F
05/25 13:17, 17F
推
05/25 13:21, , 18F
05/25 13:21, 18F
→
05/25 13:25, , 19F
05/25 13:25, 19F
→
05/25 13:26, , 20F
05/25 13:26, 20F
推
05/25 13:30, , 21F
05/25 13:30, 21F
→
05/25 13:28, , 22F
05/25 13:28, 22F
→
05/25 13:31, , 23F
05/25 13:31, 23F
推
05/25 13:34, , 24F
05/25 13:34, 24F
推
05/25 13:33, , 25F
05/25 13:33, 25F
→
05/25 13:36, , 26F
05/25 13:36, 26F
推
05/25 13:43, , 27F
05/25 13:43, 27F
推
05/25 14:15, , 28F
05/25 14:15, 28F
推
05/25 14:20, , 29F
05/25 14:20, 29F
→
05/25 14:20, , 30F
05/25 14:20, 30F
→
05/25 14:32, , 31F
05/25 14:32, 31F
推
05/25 14:34, , 32F
05/25 14:34, 32F
→
05/25 14:36, , 33F
05/25 14:36, 33F
推
05/25 14:36, , 34F
05/25 14:36, 34F
→
05/25 14:36, , 35F
05/25 14:36, 35F
→
05/25 14:37, , 36F
05/25 14:37, 36F
→
05/25 14:37, , 37F
05/25 14:37, 37F
推
05/25 14:39, , 38F
05/25 14:39, 38F
推
05/25 14:39, , 39F
05/25 14:39, 39F
→
05/25 14:40, , 40F
05/25 14:40, 40F
推
05/25 15:25, , 41F
05/25 15:25, 41F
推
05/25 17:25, , 42F
05/25 17:25, 42F
→
05/25 17:27, , 43F
05/25 17:27, 43F
推
05/25 18:17, , 44F
05/25 18:17, 44F
→
05/25 18:18, , 45F
05/25 18:18, 45F
推
05/25 18:21, , 46F
05/25 18:21, 46F
推
05/25 19:09, , 47F
05/25 19:09, 47F
→
05/25 19:10, , 48F
05/25 19:10, 48F
→
05/26 01:28, , 49F
05/26 01:28, 49F
→
05/26 01:28, , 50F
05/26 01:28, 50F
→
05/26 01:29, , 51F
05/26 01:29, 51F
→
05/26 01:30, , 52F
05/26 01:30, 52F
推
05/26 02:11, , 53F
05/26 02:11, 53F
推
05/26 15:51, , 54F
05/26 15:51, 54F
討論串 (同標題文章)