[討論] 霸王別姬裡面對於段小樓描寫是不是有問題
最近看了被很多人推薦的霸王別姬
電影是拍的不錯
但對人性的描寫,尤其是段小樓是不是很有問題。
段小樓前半部很有正義感熱情,在面對日本鬼子時連死都不怕了。
怎麼會被紅衛兵這群小人批鬥,就畏畏縮縮的投降低頭,被招安。
根本跟現實人性不合吧!
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.137.17.191 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/movie/M.1713324327.A.016.html
→
04/17 11:26,
2周前
, 1F
04/17 11:26, 1F
→
04/17 11:26,
2周前
, 2F
04/17 11:26, 2F
推
04/17 11:28,
2周前
, 3F
04/17 11:28, 3F
推
04/17 11:29,
2周前
, 4F
04/17 11:29, 4F
推
04/17 11:36,
2周前
, 5F
04/17 11:36, 5F
→
04/17 11:37,
2周前
, 6F
04/17 11:37, 6F
推
04/17 11:40,
2周前
, 7F
04/17 11:40, 7F
→
04/17 11:50,
2周前
, 8F
04/17 11:50, 8F
推
04/17 11:54,
2周前
, 9F
04/17 11:54, 9F
→
04/17 12:06,
2周前
, 10F
04/17 12:06, 10F
→
04/17 12:07,
2周前
, 11F
04/17 12:07, 11F
→
04/17 12:07,
2周前
, 12F
04/17 12:07, 12F
→
04/17 12:07,
2周前
, 13F
04/17 12:07, 13F
→
04/17 12:08,
2周前
, 14F
04/17 12:08, 14F
→
04/17 12:09,
2周前
, 15F
04/17 12:09, 15F
推
04/17 12:11,
2周前
, 16F
04/17 12:11, 16F
→
04/17 12:13,
2周前
, 17F
04/17 12:13, 17F
→
04/17 12:15,
2周前
, 18F
04/17 12:15, 18F
→
04/17 12:33,
2周前
, 19F
04/17 12:33, 19F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 20F
04/17 12:38, 20F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 21F
04/17 12:38, 21F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 22F
04/17 12:38, 22F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 23F
04/17 12:38, 23F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 24F
04/17 12:38, 24F
→
04/17 12:38,
2周前
, 25F
04/17 12:38, 25F
→
04/17 13:19,
2周前
, 26F
04/17 13:19, 26F
推
04/17 13:26,
2周前
, 27F
04/17 13:26, 27F
→
04/17 13:27,
2周前
, 28F
04/17 13:27, 28F
→
04/17 13:33,
2周前
, 29F
04/17 13:33, 29F
→
04/17 13:41,
2周前
, 30F
04/17 13:41, 30F
→
04/17 14:10,
2周前
, 31F
04/17 14:10, 31F
→
04/17 14:10,
2周前
, 32F
04/17 14:10, 32F
→
04/17 14:10,
2周前
, 33F
04/17 14:10, 33F
→
04/17 14:10,
2周前
, 34F
04/17 14:10, 34F
→
04/17 14:11,
2周前
, 35F
04/17 14:11, 35F
→
04/17 14:11,
2周前
, 36F
04/17 14:11, 36F
噓
04/17 14:26,
2周前
, 37F
04/17 14:26, 37F
推
04/17 14:33,
2周前
, 38F
04/17 14:33, 38F
推
04/17 14:39,
2周前
, 39F
04/17 14:39, 39F
還有 44 則推文
→
04/17 16:55,
2周前
, 84F
04/17 16:55, 84F
→
04/17 16:55,
2周前
, 85F
04/17 16:55, 85F
→
04/17 16:56,
2周前
, 86F
04/17 16:56, 86F
推
04/17 17:24,
2周前
, 87F
04/17 17:24, 87F
推
04/17 17:29,
2周前
, 88F
04/17 17:29, 88F
推
04/17 17:32,
2周前
, 89F
04/17 17:32, 89F
→
04/17 17:32,
2周前
, 90F
04/17 17:32, 90F
推
04/17 18:11,
2周前
, 91F
04/17 18:11, 91F
→
04/17 18:11,
2周前
, 92F
04/17 18:11, 92F
→
04/17 18:11,
2周前
, 93F
04/17 18:11, 93F
→
04/17 18:11,
2周前
, 94F
04/17 18:11, 94F
→
04/17 18:11,
2周前
, 95F
04/17 18:11, 95F
→
04/17 18:12,
2周前
, 96F
04/17 18:12, 96F
→
04/17 18:18,
2周前
, 97F
04/17 18:18, 97F
→
04/17 18:18,
2周前
, 98F
04/17 18:18, 98F
推
04/17 19:04,
2周前
, 99F
04/17 19:04, 99F
→
04/17 19:54,
2周前
, 100F
04/17 19:54, 100F
→
04/17 20:07,
2周前
, 101F
04/17 20:07, 101F
推
04/17 22:03,
2周前
, 102F
04/17 22:03, 102F
推
04/18 00:11,
2周前
, 103F
04/18 00:11, 103F
→
04/18 00:11,
2周前
, 104F
04/18 00:11, 104F
推
04/18 00:14,
2周前
, 105F
04/18 00:14, 105F
→
04/18 00:14,
2周前
, 106F
04/18 00:14, 106F
推
04/18 00:16,
2周前
, 107F
04/18 00:16, 107F
推
04/18 01:01,
2周前
, 108F
04/18 01:01, 108F
→
04/18 01:01,
2周前
, 109F
04/18 01:01, 109F
推
04/18 02:53,
2周前
, 110F
04/18 02:53, 110F
推
04/18 02:59,
2周前
, 111F
04/18 02:59, 111F
→
04/18 02:59,
2周前
, 112F
04/18 02:59, 112F
推
04/18 03:03,
2周前
, 113F
04/18 03:03, 113F
推
04/18 04:37,
2周前
, 114F
04/18 04:37, 114F
推
04/18 06:01,
2周前
, 115F
04/18 06:01, 115F
推
04/18 12:27,
2周前
, 116F
04/18 12:27, 116F
→
04/18 15:42,
2周前
, 117F
04/18 15:42, 117F
推
04/18 17:32,
2周前
, 118F
04/18 17:32, 118F
→
04/18 17:32,
2周前
, 119F
04/18 17:32, 119F
推
04/18 17:34,
2周前
, 120F
04/18 17:34, 120F
→
04/19 07:24,
1周前
, 121F
04/19 07:24, 121F
→
04/19 13:17,
1周前
, 122F
04/19 13:17, 122F
→
04/19 13:17,
1周前
, 123F
04/19 13:17, 123F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文:
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇):