Re: [討論] 非華人產後是不是都不做月子呢
科學時代
大家也不用廢話了
相信板上很多都念過研究所了
麻煩上一下學術網路
搜尋一下論文應該不難
中英文皆可
為了怕大家專業術語不熟
英文關鍵字給大家
"postpartum care"
"postpartum recovery"
若可以證實產後"台式坐月子"有顯著差異
相信拿個研究論文首獎也不為過
休養是必要的
畢竟內分泌體型變化那麼多
不過
到底該做哪些的休息跟保養
相信各國人民方法不同
產後休養不等於就是台式坐月子
台灣月子產業已經洗腦大家
一定要吃很油的補品
(廚房用一堆殺蟑劑、用大統的假油你也不知道)
住在密不透風全空調的商業大樓套房內
(消防安檢有沒有造假妳也不知道)
蓬頭垢面也不能洗澡洗頭
為了什麼妳也不知道
不過神話般的做月子的功效
恐嚇妳不做月子下半生身體就是如何如何的糟
大概是都月子產業的宣傳手法
中醫沒那麼神奇啦
說個客觀的數據
在中醫盛行、西醫發達前
人的平均壽命約30-50吧
在古代
有頂尖御醫照顧吃補品的皇帝
也就差不多是這個歲數就翹辮子了
更別說一大堆二十歲前就早夭的
這些人看的中醫師醫術估計不會比妳現在看的中醫師差
死的卻比你早
中醫真的那麼會調養
怎麼會好好人青壯年不到就掛了?
至於說華人體質異於西方人
請問妳論述的證據在哪?
長得不一樣就是體質不一樣?
那混血兒怎麼辦?
要中式還是西式的?
說西方人易老化
那美式飲食的高熱量造成的
況且也不是每個西方國家的女人產後都又老又皺好嗎?
不要以為美國人就代表西方人
坐月子是中醫文化的產物
不是人種差異的產物
不要以訛傳訛了
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.168.26.26
→
12/10 16:32, , 1F
12/10 16:32, 1F
→
12/10 16:33, , 2F
12/10 16:33, 2F
→
12/10 16:33, , 3F
12/10 16:33, 3F
→
12/10 16:33, , 4F
12/10 16:33, 4F
→
12/10 16:33, , 5F
12/10 16:33, 5F
推
12/10 16:34, , 6F
12/10 16:34, 6F
→
12/10 16:34, , 7F
12/10 16:34, 7F
→
12/10 16:34, , 8F
12/10 16:34, 8F
→
12/10 16:34, , 9F
12/10 16:34, 9F
→
12/10 16:34, , 10F
12/10 16:34, 10F
→
12/10 16:34, , 11F
12/10 16:34, 11F
→
12/10 16:34, , 12F
12/10 16:34, 12F
→
12/10 16:34, , 13F
12/10 16:34, 13F
→
12/10 16:34, , 14F
12/10 16:34, 14F
→
12/10 16:35, , 15F
12/10 16:35, 15F
→
12/10 16:35, , 16F
12/10 16:35, 16F
→
12/10 16:35, , 17F
12/10 16:35, 17F
→
12/10 16:35, , 18F
12/10 16:35, 18F
→
12/10 16:36, , 19F
12/10 16:36, 19F
→
12/10 16:36, , 20F
12/10 16:36, 20F
→
12/10 16:37, , 21F
12/10 16:37, 21F
推
12/10 16:37, , 22F
12/10 16:37, 22F
→
12/10 16:37, , 23F
12/10 16:37, 23F
→
12/10 16:37, , 24F
12/10 16:37, 24F
→
12/10 16:37, , 25F
12/10 16:37, 25F
→
12/10 16:37, , 26F
12/10 16:37, 26F
→
12/10 16:37, , 27F
12/10 16:37, 27F
→
12/10 16:38, , 28F
12/10 16:38, 28F
推
12/10 16:38, , 29F
12/10 16:38, 29F
→
12/10 16:39, , 30F
12/10 16:39, 30F
→
12/10 16:39, , 31F
12/10 16:39, 31F
→
12/10 16:39, , 32F
12/10 16:39, 32F
→
12/10 16:39, , 33F
12/10 16:39, 33F
→
12/10 16:39, , 34F
12/10 16:39, 34F
→
12/10 16:40, , 35F
12/10 16:40, 35F
→
12/10 16:40, , 36F
12/10 16:40, 36F
噓
12/10 16:41, , 37F
12/10 16:41, 37F
→
12/10 16:41, , 38F
12/10 16:41, 38F
→
12/10 16:41, , 39F
12/10 16:41, 39F
噓
12/10 16:42, , 40F
12/10 16:42, 40F
→
12/10 16:42, , 41F
12/10 16:42, 41F
→
12/10 16:42, , 42F
12/10 16:42, 42F
→
12/10 16:42, , 43F
12/10 16:42, 43F
→
12/10 16:47, , 44F
12/10 16:47, 44F
噓
12/10 16:48, , 45F
12/10 16:48, 45F
→
12/10 16:49, , 46F
12/10 16:49, 46F
→
12/10 16:55, , 47F
12/10 16:55, 47F
→
12/10 16:55, , 48F
12/10 16:55, 48F
噓
12/10 16:58, , 49F
12/10 16:58, 49F
→
12/10 16:58, , 50F
12/10 16:58, 50F
→
12/10 16:59, , 51F
12/10 16:59, 51F
→
12/10 16:59, , 52F
12/10 16:59, 52F
→
12/10 16:59, , 53F
12/10 16:59, 53F
噓
12/10 17:01, , 54F
12/10 17:01, 54F
→
12/10 17:02, , 55F
12/10 17:02, 55F
→
12/10 17:02, , 56F
12/10 17:02, 56F
噓
12/10 17:03, , 57F
12/10 17:03, 57F
噓
12/10 17:03, , 58F
12/10 17:03, 58F
→
12/10 17:03, , 59F
12/10 17:03, 59F
→
12/10 17:04, , 60F
12/10 17:04, 60F
→
12/10 17:05, , 61F
12/10 17:05, 61F
→
12/10 17:07, , 62F
12/10 17:07, 62F
→
12/10 17:08, , 63F
12/10 17:08, 63F
→
12/10 17:09, , 64F
12/10 17:09, 64F
→
12/10 17:10, , 65F
12/10 17:10, 65F
→
12/10 17:19, , 66F
12/10 17:19, 66F
→
12/10 17:19, , 67F
12/10 17:19, 67F
推
12/10 17:23, , 68F
12/10 17:23, 68F
→
12/10 17:24, , 69F
12/10 17:24, 69F
推
12/10 17:25, , 70F
12/10 17:25, 70F
推
12/10 17:27, , 71F
12/10 17:27, 71F
→
12/10 17:27, , 72F
12/10 17:27, 72F
推
12/10 17:28, , 73F
12/10 17:28, 73F
→
12/10 17:29, , 74F
12/10 17:29, 74F
→
12/10 17:29, , 75F
12/10 17:29, 75F
→
12/10 17:29, , 76F
12/10 17:29, 76F
→
12/10 17:30, , 77F
12/10 17:30, 77F
→
12/10 17:30, , 78F
12/10 17:30, 78F
→
12/10 17:31, , 79F
12/10 17:31, 79F
→
12/10 17:32, , 80F
12/10 17:32, 80F
推
12/10 17:33, , 81F
12/10 17:33, 81F
噓
12/10 18:08, , 82F
12/10 18:08, 82F
推
12/10 19:05, , 83F
12/10 19:05, 83F
→
12/10 19:06, , 84F
12/10 19:06, 84F
→
12/10 19:08, , 85F
12/10 19:08, 85F
→
12/10 19:08, , 86F
12/10 19:08, 86F
噓
12/10 19:51, , 87F
12/10 19:51, 87F
→
12/11 01:12, , 88F
12/11 01:12, 88F
→
12/11 01:12, , 89F
12/11 01:12, 89F
推
12/11 02:47, , 90F
12/11 02:47, 90F
→
12/11 02:48, , 91F
12/11 02:48, 91F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 3 之 5 篇):
討論
29
108