Re: [情報] 蕭邦鋼琴大賽公布各階段分數
※ 引述《fychang (MozartLover)》之銘言:
: 最後官網釋出final的rule, 評審們同意改變規則
: 變成評審排名再平均 @ @
: 最後結果
: Yulianna Avdeeva Russia 1,47
: Ingolf Wunder Austria 2,48
: Lukas Geniu?as Russia/Lithuania 2,50
: Daniil Trifonov Russia 3,48
: Evgeni Bozhanov Bulgaria 3,92
: Francois Dumont France 5,17
: Miroslav Kultyshev Russia 6,38
: Nikolay Khozyainov Russia 6,50
: Helene Tysman France 9,00
: http://konkurs.chopin.pl/en/edition/xvi/verdicts2/1986_final
: During the Jury meeting on the 20th of October 2010 at 7 p.m. the Jurors have
: decided to depart from the system of evaluation of the finalists described in
: the Rules of the Competition Jury (paragraphs XXI-XXII). The Jurors agreed on
: a different method of evaluation, regardless of the points awarded in the
: previous stages – the method which was based on the numerical system
: presenting the overall results after the competition performances. The Jurors
: used the integer numbers from the total scale 1-10 (where 1 – the highest
: value, 10 – the lowest value), with exception of the “students” (as
: descried in paragraphs XI) and with the correction (mentioned in paragraph
: XV) of 1 point range. It was decided, that the final verdict of the Jury
: concerning the main prizes will be made before disclosing the names of the
: participants, similarly to the decisions made during the classification
: between stages I-III.
焦元溥在自己的臉書爆了一個八卦:
http://www.facebook.com/notes/yuanpu-chiao/guan-yu-ben-jie-xiao-bang-da-sai-zheng-yi-de-ge-ren-yi-jian/287227094943?notif_t=subscription_updated
沒臉書帳號的我簡單懶人包一下,就是某個評審想護航自己學生,但根據規定他不能
為自己學生評分(要避嫌)。於是他就採取負面表列法,把可能威脅到自己學生的對手
打低分,沒威脅性的則給高分(orz台灣考研究所口試也常看到這種手段,沒想到
老外也在行...)。
然後Avdeeva因為眾望所歸,前面領先分數衝得很高所以影響不大。但Bozhanov就
中槍了,從緊咬Avdeeva掉到第四。這個第四和第三差別可是非常大,只有前三名
有獎牌(金銀銅),而且裁判席上那些前得主好像沒請過第4名以後的。所以怪不
得Bozhanov會氣的連獎金都不要了直接人間蒸發。
因為進入決賽的十個人有老師坐在裁判席的只有兩個,所以幕後黑手是誰應該很
清楚了(默...)
但我不同意焦對某W的批評,畢竟某W也拿到兩項單項獎,總不能說Avdeeva眾望所歸
就是裁判團大公無私,然後W的單項獎就是老師護航。我雖然鋼琴不是主修,也沒有
拿著波蘭國家版蕭邦樂譜逐句對照的能力,但某W協奏曲大爆發彈的比Avdeeva好
也是事實。如果說他奏鳴曲彈輸人這沒話講,但如果說他不瞭解蕭邦、只會彈那種
漂漂的優美,我想這指控也太過了。這只能說俄系德系學派詮釋不同,他們維也納
音樂學院的就是那個調調,你要他們彈的像莫斯科音樂學院那樣深沈快死掉本來就
不可能。Bozhanov彈的也很優美啊,他是德國Essen 和Duesseldorf音樂學院的...
決賽幾乎就是俄系德系學校爭霸,Wunder維也納、Bozhanov杜賽爾多夫、Tysman
漢堡和科隆音樂學院,只有Dumont才是巴黎音樂學院野田妹的學長...今年
朱莉亞..不,應該說美系學校在決賽前就全滅orz
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
※ 編輯: affen 來自: 91.3.175.205 (10/27 06:39)
→
10/27 07:11, , 1F
10/27 07:11, 1F
推
10/27 07:38, , 2F
10/27 07:38, 2F
→
10/27 07:39, , 3F
10/27 07:39, 3F
→
10/27 07:40, , 4F
10/27 07:40, 4F
→
10/27 09:56, , 5F
10/27 09:56, 5F
推
10/27 10:58, , 6F
10/27 10:58, 6F
→
10/27 10:59, , 7F
10/27 10:59, 7F
→
10/27 11:00, , 8F
10/27 11:00, 8F
→
10/27 11:00, , 9F
10/27 11:00, 9F
→
10/27 11:04, , 10F
10/27 11:04, 10F
推
10/27 12:39, , 11F
10/27 12:39, 11F
討論串 (同標題文章)