[情報] TIMES雜誌2018十大爛歌消失

看板WesternMusic作者時間5年前 (2018/12/23 12:09), 5年前編輯推噓42(48619)
留言73則, 57人參與, 最新討論串1/1
https://goo.gl/p2Vn84 10. Eminem, “Fall” 9. Greta Van Fleet, “Lover, Leaver” 8. Kanye West and Lil Pump, “I Love It” 7. DJ Snake, “Taki Taki (with Selena Gomez, Ozuna & Cardi B)” 6. Zayn, “Let Me” 5. Maroon 5, “Girls Like You (feat. Cardi B)” 4. Justin Timberlake, “The Hard Stuff” 3. Bella Thorne, “B*TCH I’M BELLA THORNE” 2. 6ix9ine, “FEFE (feat. Nicki Minaj & Murda Beatz)” 1. Post Malone, “Psycho (feat. Ty Dolla $ign)” 同場加映十大好歌 https://goo.gl/1v17TS -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 218.164.42.244 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/WesternMusic/M.1545538168.A.C39.html

12/23 12:18, , 1F
Let me有那麼爛嗎......我覺得比Entertainer好啊....
12/23 12:18, 1F

12/23 12:32, , 2F
Let Me很好聽阿...
12/23 12:32, 2F

12/23 12:38, , 3F
???????????
12/23 12:38, 3F

12/23 12:40, , 4F
最喜歡Let me的說...
12/23 12:40, 4F

12/23 12:41, , 5F
Bella那首爛到笑XDD M5則是很失望
12/23 12:41, 5F

12/23 12:49, , 6F
Let me在榜上的話有些歌根本連講爛都嫌太好吧
12/23 12:49, 6F
If you’re opening a song with the line “Sweet baby, our sex has meaning,” it’s going to need a redeeming musical quality. Unfortunately, “Let Me”— a defanged, vapid R&B love song—fails to overcome its lyrical limitations. Zayn is an adept vocalist, but the forgettable melody and cringe-worthy verses hold him back. 以上為TIMES的解釋 ※ 編輯: clonsey1314 (218.164.42.244), 12/23/2018 12:51:36

12/23 12:53, , 7F
第一名 不太認同
12/23 12:53, 7F
The sensitive thug archetype has been a cliché for at least a generation, but the 23-year-old Texan who had the words “always tired” tattooed on his face this year may have exhausted it for good with this nonsensical, self-aggrandizing whine-fest. Neither sung nor rapped so much as rhythmically brayed, and featuring an only marginally superior verse by Ty Dolla $ign, “ Psycho” was the year’s most embarrassing No. 1. From his straight-faced mention of the “friend zone” to the crack, “Had so many bottles, gave ugly girl a sip,” Post Malone proved that all a song needs to achieve massive popularity is some retrograde gender politics translated into third-rate slang.

12/23 12:53, , 8F
簡單來說 就是不該紅但紅了的歌
12/23 12:53, 8F

12/23 12:56, , 9F
名單很好 確實都是爛歌
12/23 12:56, 9F

12/23 13:03, , 10F
Bella Thorne哈哈哈哈 從Shake it up開始就一直靠auto
12/23 13:03, 10F

12/23 13:03, , 11F
tune撐場
12/23 13:03, 11F

12/23 13:14, , 12F
Fall會上榜只是不符合政治正確吧
12/23 13:14, 12F
“Everybody’s been tellin’ me what they think about me for the last few months,” Eminem intoned on the lead single from his album Kamikaze. “Maybe it’s time I tell ’em what I think about them.” It may look like a self-aware joke, on paper, from a rapper who built his career on insult comedy, but his delivery suggested that he was dead serious. Perhaps Slim Shady really was delusional enough to believe that a diss track making light of Gabrielle Giffords’ shooting and hurling homophobic slurs at Tyler, the Creator constituted new territory for him. To be fair, “Fall” did turn out to be a milestone in one respect: Its tastelessness even alienated his unwitting collaborator on the song, Justin Vernon of Bon Iver, who tweeted that he was “not a fan of [its] message.”

12/23 13:25, , 13F
Psycho好聽
12/23 13:25, 13F

12/23 14:02, , 14F
Taki Taki竟然是爛歌QQ
12/23 14:02, 14F

12/23 14:03, , 15F
Taki洗腦.但歌詞真的滿爛的xd
12/23 14:03, 15F
Too much of a good thing does exist. Separately, DJ Snake, Selena Gomez, Ozuna and Cardi B are all artists at the top of their respective games. But compiled unnecessarily on this overstuffed yet under-produced Latin-inspired club track, their voices are lost in the mix. It feels like the song is pandering to four different fan bases—and, in the process, puts out the spark that gives each artist his or her own appeal. 個人也覺得爛

12/23 14:07, , 16F
我蠻喜歡let me跟phycho欸哈哈哈
12/23 14:07, 16F

12/23 14:12, , 17F
1、5不認同,其他OK
12/23 14:12, 17F

12/23 14:14, , 18F
滿喜歡girls like you 的耶
12/23 14:14, 18F
Cardi B’s verse is the only saving grace of this inexplicable chart-topper, which sounds engineered to soundtrack department-store commercials. With lyrics that could have been pulled straight from the dating profile of any man searching for that oh-so-elusive significant other who, get this, loves fun, “Girls Like You” is more headache than hit. 滿爛的啊Girls like you ※ 編輯: clonsey1314 (218.164.42.244), 12/23/2018 14:45:47

12/23 14:43, , 19F
taki完全失望啊 這陣容做這種歌
12/23 14:43, 19F

12/23 14:50, , 20F
FEFE真的是爛歌 但是我還是聽得好喜歡哈哈
12/23 14:50, 20F

12/23 15:18, , 21F
Paycho超棒好嗎,其他我覺得正常XD
12/23 15:18, 21F

12/23 15:25, , 22F
#1#2都很洗腦啊,聽了很多遍
12/23 15:25, 22F

12/23 16:07, , 23F
FEFE對我來說的意義只有Nicki而已
12/23 16:07, 23F

12/23 16:29, , 24F
認同
12/23 16:29, 24F

12/23 16:34, , 25F
Girls like you蠻無聊...
12/23 16:34, 25F

12/23 16:40, , 26F
Bella那首應該要第1名才對啊
12/23 16:40, 26F

12/23 17:14, , 27F
FEFE 只有 Nicki 能聽,當出69訪談也說這首歌詞根本是X
12/23 17:14, 27F

12/23 17:14, , 28F
哈哈哈哈哈
12/23 17:14, 28F

12/23 17:14, , 29F
很討厭Psycho 因為這首歌不想聽Post Malone那張專 後來是
12/23 17:14, 29F

12/23 17:14, , 30F
因為評價還不錯才開始聽 其他歌都比Psycho好太多
12/23 17:14, 30F

12/23 17:22, , 31F
跟好不好聽沒有太大關係呀
12/23 17:22, 31F

12/23 17:22, , 32F
主要是從歌詞面去評論
12/23 17:22, 32F

12/23 17:30, , 33F
Oh oh oh用太多會很膩
12/23 17:30, 33F

12/23 17:39, , 34F
Psycho很好聽好不
12/23 17:39, 34F

12/23 17:48, , 35F
taki taki 不管歌詞,音樂都不好 這陣容結果歌長這樣
12/23 17:48, 35F

12/23 18:08, , 36F
我也很喜歡psycho耶
12/23 18:08, 36F

12/23 18:56, , 37F
時代雜誌Time沒有加s喔
12/23 18:56, 37F
已更正 謝謝提醒!

12/23 19:05, , 38F
喜歡psycho +1
12/23 19:05, 38F

12/23 20:06, , 39F
怎麼沒有the light is coming(逃
12/23 20:06, 39F

12/23 21:14, , 40F
是說我之前看到The light is coming被slant magazine選成
12/23 21:14, 40F

12/23 21:14, , 41F
年度第三好歌XDDD
12/23 21:14, 41F
※ 編輯: clonsey1314 (218.164.42.244), 12/23/2018 21:40:33

12/23 22:24, , 42F
本來國外的樂評就不是只評旋律和編曲 歌詞也是重點之一
12/23 22:24, 42F

12/23 22:25, , 43F
至於Ariana這張應該是他四張中樂評最好的一張 樂評的年
12/23 22:25, 43F

12/23 22:25, , 44F
末榜單都是高位
12/23 22:25, 44F

12/23 22:40, , 45F
Taki Taki真的爛透
12/23 22:40, 45F

12/23 22:45, , 46F
takitaki真的整首連結點很怪
12/23 22:45, 46F

12/23 23:29, , 47F
喜歡Psycho+1 Post Malone根本超讚
12/23 23:29, 47F

12/24 00:07, , 48F
psycho蠻好聽的
12/24 00:07, 48F

12/24 01:04, , 49F
大概又準備再被阿姆寫一首罵了
12/24 01:04, 49F

12/24 01:35, , 50F
我覺得psycho 不錯啊...雖然我後來都聽翻唱的版本
12/24 01:35, 50F

12/24 01:51, , 51F
takitaki真的
12/24 01:51, 51F

12/24 02:20, , 52F
爛歌都滿實至名歸的啊XD
12/24 02:20, 52F

12/24 04:51, , 53F
推psycho
12/24 04:51, 53F

12/24 08:12, , 54F
taki taki真的蠻失望的 但還是喜歡蛇爺
12/24 08:12, 54F

12/24 09:15, , 55F
不只國外,台灣評中文歌的樂評也會評歌詞,只是本板大部
12/24 09:15, 55F

12/24 09:15, , 56F
分的人不聽也不管歌詞唱什麼和意涵(國外其實也很多聽眾
12/24 09:15, 56F

12/24 09:15, , 57F
不管歌詞)。
12/24 09:15, 57F

12/24 09:18, , 58F
Taki taki很爛?不解欸這什麼根據評的啊?如果歌不紅
12/24 09:18, 58F

12/24 09:18, , 59F
應該就不會出現在榜上了...
12/24 09:18, 59F

12/24 10:39, , 60F
中文歌也只能評歌詞而已.音樂水準那麼差.每首都一樣
12/24 10:39, 60F

12/24 10:40, , 61F
老外根本不會想聽中文歌.太平.太無聊了
12/24 10:40, 61F

12/24 11:12, , 62F
侮辱中文歌並不會讓你的品味顯得特別高尚。
12/24 11:12, 62F

12/24 12:37, , 63F
psycho?
12/24 12:37, 63F

12/24 12:45, , 64F
Girls Like You爛歌無誤
12/24 12:45, 64F

12/24 12:54, , 65F
十大好歌 推Mac miiler
12/24 12:54, 65F

12/24 13:03, , 66F
樓上聽英文歌是有比較高端???
12/24 13:03, 66F

12/24 15:02, , 67F
Psycho超級好聽 有病
12/24 15:02, 67F

12/24 16:28, , 68F
Psycho我也覺得好聽耶
12/24 16:28, 68F

12/24 20:08, , 69F
怎麼沒有Drake的作品們
12/24 20:08, 69F

12/24 21:18, , 70F
我覺得FEFE應該第一XD
12/24 21:18, 70F

12/24 22:09, , 71F
甭擔心Drake啦,他的那幾首單曲評價都很好的
12/24 22:09, 71F

12/24 22:28, , 72F
Psycho編曲好聽但那個歌詞實在是
12/24 22:28, 72F

12/24 22:33, , 73F
drake今年沒有爛啊
12/24 22:33, 73F
文章代碼(AID): #1S7mfumv (WesternMusic)