[請益] Now可以用現在完成式嗎?

看板Teacher作者 (wang fan)時間11年前 (2012/10/06 23:17), 編輯推噓3(3011)
留言14則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
出處:翰林書商的國三的一段複習卷 David is popular with his students in Joy Junior High School. In fact, he __1____ an English teacher for thirteen years. He ___2___ to choose the job at the age of thirteen because of his English teacher Tracy Chang. She always __3__ English in an interesting way .She __4___her students play games, sing songs, and write English letter every day. Besides, she seldom spoke Chinese in class. David really loved English class. Now In David's English class, English __5__ the only "spoken" language! He thinks that one day his students __6__ English as well as he. And they will miss the days to learn Engish with him. 答案: 1.has been 2.decided 3.taught 4.made 5.(A) is (B)was(C)has been (D) will be 答案c 我的看法: 一、倒數第五行: 現在David的英文課 英文已經是唯一被說的語言 我覺得中文這樣很順,ok。 但是有now不是指現在簡單式或進行式嗎? 二、如果這一句要用現在完成式 那第一句不就應把 David is popular with… 不就寫成David has been popular…? 三、第五題寫is的同學真的要算他錯嗎? 謝謝! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.227.95.170

10/06 23:33, , 1F
整篇文章在探討老師從以前到現在語言使用的演變,用
10/06 23:33, 1F

10/06 23:34, , 2F
完成式現在式都是可以的
10/06 23:34, 2F

10/06 23:36, , 3F
我覺得,這位老師,你在解讀文法時,請注意上下文或整篇
10/06 23:36, 3F

10/06 23:36, , 4F
文章所要交代的關係.我覺得你一直在執著,因為某個字
10/06 23:36, 4F

10/06 23:38, , 5F
所以文法就要怎樣, 而不是去考慮整篇閱讀前後關係.
10/06 23:38, 5F

10/06 23:40, , 6F
小聲說,(但我誠心建議)-有些教學上的問題要加強,
10/06 23:40, 6F

10/07 02:01, , 7F
覺得第五題用A或C都可以 不曉得有沒有其他高見?
10/07 02:01, 7F

10/07 11:04, , 8F
AC皆可
10/07 11:04, 8F

10/07 12:53, , 9F
謝謝!翻了一下文法書,只看到by now要用完成式。
10/07 12:53, 9F

10/07 12:54, , 10F
比如:I has read three books by now.但這是now
10/07 12:54, 10F

10/07 12:55, , 11F
難道by now中by可以省略?謝謝!
10/07 12:55, 11F

10/07 13:45, , 12F
推一樓, by now= till now
10/07 13:45, 12F

10/07 17:42, , 13F
不是by now不by now的問題,是整篇文義問題.
10/07 17:42, 13F

10/07 17:43, , 14F
但如果解讀成by now,當然更明確.
10/07 17:43, 14F
※ 編輯: wang7878 來自: 61.227.88.58 (10/07 21:24)
文章代碼(AID): #1GS4jvBt (Teacher)