Re: [疑問] 通靈少女 小真在廟裡那幕 (雷)
看板TaiwanDrama作者chueh134 (I think therefore I am)時間7年前 (2017/05/02 20:45)推噓21(21推 0噓 57→)留言78則, 18人參與討論串5/6 (看更多)
※ 引述《sr29 (owo)》之銘言:
: 嗚 怕標題暴雷
: 所以問在內文
: 第六集議員帶著老婆到宮廟裡發瘋
: 小真跌倒後起乩
: 一直在以為劇中起乩是她演的,其實神明根本就沒有降下來
: 這樣也正好呼應到季初她跟金老師說起乩很沒形象、
: 金老師說仙姑要明白人心的部分,表現出成長的樣子
: 在金老師騎車載小真的時候
: 我就在想小真什麼時候會跟金老師坦承(?)
: 結果一直沒有 讓我開始懷疑自己XDD
: 所以她在那段是真的起乩嗎?
: 如果是的話劇本好像有點刻意
: 還是真的跟我想得一樣是用演的呢?
先說我認為小真起乩這件事是假的
我們先看幾張圖
首先先看<通靈少女>的原型<神算
>
http://imgur.com/a/QUD6O
http://imgur.com/a/Xk0o9
http://imgur.com/a/RMup3
上面這三張是小雅起乩這橋段的畫面
如果大家有看過神算的話,應該都會覺得小雅的起乩是假的
因為這一連串的過程裡,小雅的情緒給人感覺是她既生氣又無力
信眾們講不聽,她又急著想去參加慶生會
所以最快的辦法就是透過神明信仰去制止信眾的無理取鬧
接著是<通靈少女>
http://imgur.com/6gicmst
http://imgur.com/a/6rgkE
http://imgur.com/a/ncj5w
http://imgur.com/a/G7D3V
雖然多了幾個鏡頭,但不難發現小真的情緒跟小雅的情緒流動過程是差不多的
從上面幾張圖可以看到小真從被推倒的錯愕到整個憤怒的眼神表情
大家可以再去回味一下這一個段落,可以看到小真有特別閉眼呼吸,試圖冷靜想辦法
接著就開始做起乩的演出
就如原PO說的,這一部份可說是呼應之前金老師講的:要理解人心並給予慰藉
至於為什麼沒跟金老師提這件事
我認為是因為沒有必要
以金老師的角度來看,小真是否真的起乩,在當時根本不是重點
就如金老師過去也一直不斷灌輸小真要懂得運用話術讓信徒安心的道理一樣
小真當時的起乩就是金老師過去灌輸給小真那些理論的最好詮釋
而小真因為這件事情,原本可以順利參與校慶表演的校園生活又再度被犧牲
我想,那低落的情緒不會是適合提這件事的時候
況且金老師又沒那麼粗神經,加上小真因為阿樂的離世堅持不再處理宮廟事務
本身對小真的愧疚讓他自己也沒什麼立場去提起乩的真假
以上是我的看法,歡迎大家討論 :)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 61.228.162.96
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/TaiwanDrama/M.1493729102.A.289.html
→
05/02 20:59, , 1F
05/02 20:59, 1F
推
05/02 21:13, , 2F
05/02 21:13, 2F
→
05/02 21:13, , 3F
05/02 21:13, 3F
→
05/02 21:14, , 4F
05/02 21:14, 4F
→
05/02 21:15, , 5F
05/02 21:15, 5F
→
05/02 21:16, , 6F
05/02 21:16, 6F
→
05/02 21:17, , 7F
05/02 21:17, 7F
推
05/02 22:07, , 8F
05/02 22:07, 8F
→
05/02 22:08, , 9F
05/02 22:08, 9F
→
05/02 22:08, , 10F
05/02 22:08, 10F
→
05/02 22:08, , 11F
05/02 22:08, 11F
→
05/02 22:08, , 12F
05/02 22:08, 12F
→
05/02 22:08, , 13F
05/02 22:08, 13F
→
05/02 22:10, , 14F
05/02 22:10, 14F
推
05/02 22:12, , 15F
05/02 22:12, 15F
推
05/02 22:30, , 16F
05/02 22:30, 16F
→
05/02 22:31, , 17F
05/02 22:31, 17F
推
05/02 22:35, , 18F
05/02 22:35, 18F
推
05/02 22:39, , 19F
05/02 22:39, 19F
→
05/02 22:40, , 20F
05/02 22:40, 20F
→
05/02 22:41, , 21F
05/02 22:41, 21F
→
05/02 22:42, , 22F
05/02 22:42, 22F
→
05/02 22:44, , 23F
05/02 22:44, 23F
推
05/02 22:45, , 24F
05/02 22:45, 24F
→
05/02 22:45, , 25F
05/02 22:45, 25F
→
05/02 22:46, , 26F
05/02 22:46, 26F
→
05/02 22:47, , 27F
05/02 22:47, 27F
→
05/02 22:49, , 28F
05/02 22:49, 28F
→
05/02 22:50, , 29F
05/02 22:50, 29F
推
05/02 22:51, , 30F
05/02 22:51, 30F
→
05/02 22:51, , 31F
05/02 22:51, 31F
→
05/02 22:52, , 32F
05/02 22:52, 32F
→
05/02 22:52, , 33F
05/02 22:52, 33F
→
05/02 22:54, , 34F
05/02 22:54, 34F
推
05/02 23:27, , 35F
05/02 23:27, 35F
→
05/02 23:27, , 36F
05/02 23:27, 36F
→
05/02 23:58, , 37F
05/02 23:58, 37F
→
05/03 00:02, , 38F
05/03 00:02, 38F
推
05/03 00:08, , 39F
05/03 00:08, 39F
→
05/03 00:09, , 40F
05/03 00:09, 40F
→
05/03 00:10, , 41F
05/03 00:10, 41F
→
05/03 00:10, , 42F
05/03 00:10, 42F
→
05/03 00:11, , 43F
05/03 00:11, 43F
推
05/03 00:14, , 44F
05/03 00:14, 44F
→
05/03 00:53, , 45F
05/03 00:53, 45F
→
05/03 00:55, , 46F
05/03 00:55, 46F
推
05/03 01:33, , 47F
05/03 01:33, 47F
推
05/03 10:40, , 48F
05/03 10:40, 48F
推
05/03 12:55, , 49F
05/03 12:55, 49F
→
05/03 12:55, , 50F
05/03 12:55, 50F
推
05/03 21:54, , 51F
05/03 21:54, 51F
→
05/03 21:54, , 52F
05/03 21:54, 52F
→
05/04 00:20, , 53F
05/04 00:20, 53F
→
05/04 00:22, , 54F
05/04 00:22, 54F
→
05/04 00:23, , 55F
05/04 00:23, 55F
推
05/04 02:17, , 56F
05/04 02:17, 56F
→
05/04 02:17, , 57F
05/04 02:17, 57F
→
05/04 02:17, , 58F
05/04 02:17, 58F
→
05/04 02:17, , 59F
05/04 02:17, 59F
→
05/04 02:17, , 60F
05/04 02:17, 60F
→
05/04 02:17, , 61F
05/04 02:17, 61F
推
05/04 09:44, , 62F
05/04 09:44, 62F
→
05/04 09:44, , 63F
05/04 09:44, 63F
→
05/04 09:44, , 64F
05/04 09:44, 64F
推
05/04 22:20, , 65F
05/04 22:20, 65F
→
05/04 22:21, , 66F
05/04 22:21, 66F
→
05/04 22:22, , 67F
05/04 22:22, 67F
推
05/04 22:33, , 68F
05/04 22:33, 68F
→
05/04 22:36, , 69F
05/04 22:36, 69F
→
05/04 22:37, , 70F
05/04 22:37, 70F
→
05/04 22:42, , 71F
05/04 22:42, 71F
→
05/04 22:42, , 72F
05/04 22:42, 72F
推
05/05 05:27, , 73F
05/05 05:27, 73F
→
05/05 05:27, , 74F
05/05 05:27, 74F
→
05/05 05:27, , 75F
05/05 05:27, 75F
推
05/06 10:40, , 76F
05/06 10:40, 76F
→
05/06 10:40, , 77F
05/06 10:40, 77F
→
05/06 14:04, , 78F
05/06 14:04, 78F
討論串 (同標題文章)