[請益] 一題highlighted sentence題

看板TOEFL_iBT作者 (good!)時間13年前 (2011/01/24 15:08), 編輯推噓8(8013)
留言21則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
Large wind farms might also interfere with the flight patterns of migratory birds in certain areas, and they have killed large birds of prey (especially hawks, falcons, and eagles) that prefer to hunt along the same ridge lines that are ideal for wind turbines. ○Hawks, falcons, and eagles prefer to hunt along ridge lines, where wind turbines can kill large numbers of migratory birds. ○Wind turbines occasionally cause migratory birds to change their flight patterns and therefore may interfere with the areas where birds of prey prefer to hunt. ○Some of the best locations for large wind farms are places that may cause problems for migrating birds and birds of prey. ○Large wind farms in certain areas kill hawks, falcons, and eagles and thus might create a more ideal path for the flight of migratory birds. 答案是C 但我覺得B更好 請各位幫我解答 謝謝 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 125.227.121.79

01/24 15:11, , 1F
選C沒錯...哪有change flight patterns了@@?
01/24 15:11, 1F

01/24 15:28, , 2F
我也會選C 因為這2件事是獨立的 答案B的therefore不合適
01/24 15:28, 2F

01/24 15:58, , 3F
想請問change flight pattern是指改飛行路線嗎??
01/24 15:58, 3F

01/24 15:59, , 4F
因為我以為內容是說他改變了鳥的飛行路線,
01/24 15:59, 4F

01/24 15:59, , 5F
讓原本在那覓食的老鷹吃不到鳥
01/24 15:59, 5F

01/24 16:27, , 6F
change flight pattern是指改飛行路線沒有錯 可是文章沒
01/24 16:27, 6F

01/24 16:28, , 7F
有講到是"因為"這樣"而"造成老鷹受到影響
01/24 16:28, 7F

01/24 16:40, , 8F
但是老鷹的死亡,不是因為吃不到鳥嗎??
01/24 16:40, 8F

01/24 16:43, , 9F
因為風車,所以造成鳥改變航道,所以老鷹在原處吃不到鳥
01/24 16:43, 9F

01/24 16:44, , 10F
然後造成老鷹死亡, 文章的邏輯我是搞錯哪裡了呢??
01/24 16:44, 10F

01/24 16:52, , 11F
還有C有寫到best locations(文章最後一行) 但B沒有
01/24 16:52, 11F

01/24 22:04, , 12F
文章並沒有說老櫻死亡是因為吃不到鳥喔,是因為風車也會
01/24 22:04, 12F

01/24 22:04, , 13F
殺死大型掠食者(特別是老鷹之類的動物)
01/24 22:04, 13F

01/24 22:07, , 14F
意思就是說,掠食者和候鳥都是被風車所殺死的
01/24 22:07, 14F

01/24 22:07, , 15F
但是掠食者是否因為後鳥被風車給殺死而吃不到東西,沒有
01/24 22:07, 15F

01/24 22:08, , 16F
直接的因果關係
01/24 22:08, 16F

01/24 22:10, , 17F
而且文章也沒有提到風車有改變候鳥的飛行路線,故不選B
01/24 22:10, 17F

01/24 22:17, , 18F
B)的occasionally和therefore都是文章中沒有提到的
01/24 22:17, 18F

01/27 01:38, , 19F
這題,有個小小的背景常識是,大型風力電廠的旋轉扇葉會
01/27 01:38, 19F

01/27 01:40, , 20F
"直接"打死大型鳥類,因此被詬病為不算是全然的綠色能源
01/27 01:40, 20F

01/27 01:41, , 21F
而這段在說的main idea講的就是這部分
01/27 01:41, 21F
文章代碼(AID): #1DFIMBsD (TOEFL_iBT)
文章代碼(AID): #1DFIMBsD (TOEFL_iBT)