[公告] bluelamb y2468101216 水桶一案 判決更改
根據板規
8-6 非當事人對於板務之裁定與判決有異議者,可於檢舉區提出異議並附上完整說明。
於判決後七十二小時內達五人(含)以上提出異議,則需由三名板主共同審理該案。
重新審理#1Mm8GrWU一案
1.原推文
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 文章代碼(AID): #1Mm3Dj2B (PuzzleDragon) [ptt.cc] Re: [閒聊] 由GUNGHO營收 │
│ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PuzzleDragon/M.1455436653.A.08B.html │
│ 這一篇文章值 72 Ptt幣 │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
→
02/14 19:59,
02/14 19:59
2.更改理由
經板友上訴後重新審理該案,該推文如同原判決理由顯然是玩笑性質的話,
對照其他遭檢舉推文,攻擊性低下許多,而且bluelamb板友顯然是反諷該推文,
推
02/14 19:55,
02/14 19:55
板規 3-1 原意是為了禁止板友過度的挑釁引戰,
然而該次判決過度延伸到了只要是不合理論述皆判決3-1違規,
這樣明顯跟原定板規的意義有所衝突。
如果依照此標準水桶板友,那未來水桶標準將會提高許多,
實與板規想達到的目的有所差別。故決定取消該次判決。
3.處置內容
水桶取消
裁決板主:wl2340167
--
連帶
1.原文
作者 y2468101216 (芸) 看板 PuzzleDragon
標題 Re: [閒聊] 由GUNGHO營收下滑談起
時間 Sun Feb 14 20:34:24 2016
───────────────────────────────────────
原備份於z-14-6-1-15 改至z-14-5-70
2.更改理由
該文也被以引戰理由判決3-1,但文章內容顯然無引起爭吵或挑釁之意。
一樣取消該次判決。
3.處置內容
水桶取消
裁決板主:wl2340167
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
該次判決是本人過於魯莽的判斷,導致兩位板友數天無法發言,
水桶日期雖然可以取消,但被桶的時間已無法挽回。
近期會再公告我自己的懲處,深感抱歉。
未來還請大家配合板規,也歡迎提出不同的意見,感謝各位。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 106.1.29.116
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PuzzleDragon/M.1455710216.A.63C.html
推
02/17 19:57, , 1F
02/17 19:57, 1F
推
02/17 19:57, , 2F
02/17 19:57, 2F
→
02/17 19:57, , 3F
02/17 19:57, 3F
推
02/17 19:59, , 4F
02/17 19:59, 4F
應該沒有
推
02/17 19:59, , 5F
02/17 19:59, 5F
推
02/17 20:00, , 6F
02/17 20:00, 6F
沒有辦法補救,所以只能處罰判決人。
→
02/17 20:00, , 7F
02/17 20:00, 7F
推
02/17 20:00, , 8F
02/17 20:00, 8F
推
02/17 20:00, , 9F
02/17 20:00, 9F
→
02/17 20:00, , 10F
02/17 20:00, 10F
※ 編輯: wl2340167 (106.1.29.116), 02/17/2016 20:02:27
推
02/17 20:02, , 11F
02/17 20:02, 11F
→
02/17 20:02, , 12F
02/17 20:02, 12F
推
02/17 20:04, , 13F
02/17 20:04, 13F
推
02/17 20:04, , 14F
02/17 20:04, 14F
→
02/17 20:04, , 15F
02/17 20:04, 15F
推
02/17 20:04, , 16F
02/17 20:04, 16F
→
02/17 20:05, , 17F
02/17 20:05, 17F
推
02/17 20:05, , 18F
02/17 20:05, 18F
推
02/17 20:05, , 19F
02/17 20:05, 19F
推
02/17 20:06, , 20F
02/17 20:06, 20F
推
02/17 20:07, , 21F
02/17 20:07, 21F
推
02/17 20:10, , 22F
02/17 20:10, 22F
→
02/17 20:10, , 23F
02/17 20:10, 23F
推
02/17 20:12, , 24F
02/17 20:12, 24F
推
02/17 20:13, , 25F
02/17 20:13, 25F
推
02/17 20:14, , 26F
02/17 20:14, 26F
推
02/17 20:14, , 27F
02/17 20:14, 27F
推
02/17 20:15, , 28F
02/17 20:15, 28F
推
02/17 20:16, , 29F
02/17 20:16, 29F
推
02/17 20:16, , 30F
02/17 20:16, 30F
推
02/17 20:17, , 31F
02/17 20:17, 31F
推
02/17 20:17, , 32F
02/17 20:17, 32F
推
02/17 20:18, , 33F
02/17 20:18, 33F
推
02/17 20:19, , 34F
02/17 20:19, 34F
→
02/17 20:19, , 35F
02/17 20:19, 35F
推
02/17 20:19, , 36F
02/17 20:19, 36F
→
02/17 20:19, , 37F
02/17 20:19, 37F
推
02/17 20:20, , 38F
02/17 20:20, 38F
推
02/17 20:21, , 39F
02/17 20:21, 39F
推
02/17 20:22, , 40F
02/17 20:22, 40F
→
02/17 20:22, , 41F
02/17 20:22, 41F
→
02/17 20:24, , 42F
02/17 20:24, 42F
推
02/17 20:24, , 43F
02/17 20:24, 43F
推
02/17 20:24, , 44F
02/17 20:24, 44F
推
02/17 20:29, , 45F
02/17 20:29, 45F
→
02/17 20:36, , 46F
02/17 20:36, 46F
推
02/17 20:36, , 47F
02/17 20:36, 47F
推
02/17 20:39, , 48F
02/17 20:39, 48F
→
02/17 20:42, , 49F
02/17 20:42, 49F
→
02/17 20:45, , 50F
02/17 20:45, 50F
推
02/17 20:47, , 51F
02/17 20:47, 51F
推
02/17 20:48, , 52F
02/17 20:48, 52F
推
02/17 20:52, , 53F
02/17 20:52, 53F
推
02/17 20:57, , 54F
02/17 20:57, 54F
噓
02/17 21:01, , 55F
02/17 21:01, 55F
→
02/17 21:01, , 56F
02/17 21:01, 56F
推
02/17 21:03, , 57F
02/17 21:03, 57F
→
02/17 21:07, , 58F
02/17 21:07, 58F
推
02/17 21:10, , 59F
02/17 21:10, 59F
推
02/17 21:16, , 60F
02/17 21:16, 60F
→
02/17 21:17, , 61F
02/17 21:17, 61F
→
02/17 21:20, , 62F
02/17 21:20, 62F
→
02/17 21:35, , 63F
02/17 21:35, 63F
推
02/17 21:45, , 64F
02/17 21:45, 64F
推
02/17 21:46, , 65F
02/17 21:46, 65F
推
02/17 22:13, , 66F
02/17 22:13, 66F
推
02/17 22:21, , 67F
02/17 22:21, 67F
推
02/17 22:45, , 68F
02/17 22:45, 68F
推
02/17 22:54, , 69F
02/17 22:54, 69F
推
02/17 22:56, , 70F
02/17 22:56, 70F
推
02/17 23:04, , 71F
02/17 23:04, 71F
推
02/17 23:23, , 72F
02/17 23:23, 72F
推
02/17 23:26, , 73F
02/17 23:26, 73F
→
02/17 23:26, , 74F
02/17 23:26, 74F
推
02/17 23:29, , 75F
02/17 23:29, 75F
→
02/17 23:30, , 76F
02/17 23:30, 76F
推
02/17 23:30, , 77F
02/17 23:30, 77F
推
02/17 23:49, , 78F
02/17 23:49, 78F
推
02/18 00:04, , 79F
02/18 00:04, 79F
→
02/18 00:22, , 80F
02/18 00:22, 80F
推
02/18 00:34, , 81F
02/18 00:34, 81F
推
02/18 01:34, , 82F
02/18 01:34, 82F
推
02/18 07:32, , 83F
02/18 07:32, 83F
→
02/18 08:40, , 84F
02/18 08:40, 84F
推
02/18 08:58, , 85F
02/18 08:58, 85F
推
02/18 09:35, , 86F
02/18 09:35, 86F
推
02/18 11:11, , 87F
02/18 11:11, 87F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文:
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇):