Re: [新聞] 金曲前哨戰開火 陳奕迅熱狗最贏
阿信唱腔沒加分 輸董事長
至於競爭最激烈的則是董事長樂團、五月天和黃立行搶奪最後席位之爭﹐袁永興表示﹐評審認為五月天主唱阿信的唱腔沒有幫專輯加分﹐但他創作的誠懇有被看到﹐因此十大專輯之爭﹐董事長樂團的「花光他的錢」險勝五月天的「後青春期的詩」﹐至於黃立行﹐雖然評審讚賞他的制作物成熟、概念新、編曲佳﹐可惜最後投票結果仍然敗北。
: ================================================================
: 可惡!竟然說阿信的唱腔沒有加分.....
: 老大說阿信的沙啞腔可是練了很久耶!!
: 可不是每個人都有的呢!!!
------------------------------------------------
看到這新聞~忽然想到曾經關於李宗盛談論五月天的一段話~
所以找出來~我想這應該是大家的心聲﹐XD
---------
"五月天是一個很奇妙的樂團,"不過是在小小的餐桌上﹐即使筷子上挾的不過是附近便當店的家常菜﹐大哥李宗盛依然談笑風生~吸引了所有人的目光焦點,"阿信的Vocal如果換成別人來唱~絕對不適合五月天﹐相對的阿信就算離團去唱別人寫的歌﹐相信也一定很難聽.今天台灣的聽眾比較起音樂的優劣﹐可能會說這個歌手的第一張專輯唱的怎樣怎樣﹐他的第二張專輯比起來又唱的如何﹔可是五月天不適用這樣的聆聽方式。你不是聽阿信的一個人的表現﹐而是去聽整個樂團的Style.""所以說真是妖孽呀﹐風格這麼Match的團不知道多少年才出現一個."
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 222.69.134.178
推
05/12 17:31, , 1F
05/12 17:31, 1F
推
05/12 17:40, , 2F
05/12 17:40, 2F
推
05/12 17:42, , 3F
05/12 17:42, 3F
推
05/12 17:49, , 4F
05/12 17:49, 4F
推
05/12 18:10, , 5F
05/12 18:10, 5F
推
05/12 18:12, , 6F
05/12 18:12, 6F
→
05/12 18:13, , 7F
05/12 18:13, 7F
推
05/12 18:15, , 8F
05/12 18:15, 8F
推
05/12 18:18, , 9F
05/12 18:18, 9F
→
05/12 18:18, , 10F
05/12 18:18, 10F
→
05/12 18:18, , 11F
05/12 18:18, 11F
→
05/12 18:19, , 12F
05/12 18:19, 12F
推
05/12 18:32, , 13F
05/12 18:32, 13F
推
05/12 19:06, , 14F
05/12 19:06, 14F
→
05/12 19:07, , 15F
05/12 19:07, 15F
→
05/12 19:08, , 16F
05/12 19:08, 16F
→
05/12 19:09, , 17F
05/12 19:09, 17F
→
05/12 19:10, , 18F
05/12 19:10, 18F
→
05/12 19:11, , 19F
05/12 19:11, 19F
推
05/12 20:02, , 20F
05/12 20:02, 20F
→
05/12 20:04, , 21F
05/12 20:04, 21F
→
05/12 20:15, , 22F
05/12 20:15, 22F
推
05/12 20:17, , 23F
05/12 20:17, 23F
推
05/12 20:35, , 24F
05/12 20:35, 24F
推
05/12 20:38, , 25F
05/12 20:38, 25F
推
05/12 21:02, , 26F
05/12 21:02, 26F
推
05/12 21:15, , 27F
05/12 21:15, 27F
推
05/12 21:25, , 28F
05/12 21:25, 28F
→
05/12 21:37, , 29F
05/12 21:37, 29F
推
05/12 22:09, , 30F
05/12 22:09, 30F
推
05/12 22:20, , 31F
05/12 22:20, 31F
推
05/12 22:37, , 32F
05/12 22:37, 32F
推
05/12 23:02, , 33F
05/12 23:02, 33F
推
05/12 23:09, , 34F
05/12 23:09, 34F
推
05/12 23:13, , 35F
05/12 23:13, 35F
→
05/12 23:14, , 36F
05/12 23:14, 36F
推
05/12 23:15, , 37F
05/12 23:15, 37F
推
05/12 23:17, , 38F
05/12 23:17, 38F
推
05/12 23:18, , 39F
05/12 23:18, 39F
推
05/12 23:18, , 40F
05/12 23:18, 40F
推
05/12 23:29, , 41F
05/12 23:29, 41F
→
05/12 23:30, , 42F
05/12 23:30, 42F
→
05/12 23:30, , 43F
05/12 23:30, 43F
→
05/12 23:31, , 44F
05/12 23:31, 44F
推
05/12 23:36, , 45F
05/12 23:36, 45F
推
05/12 23:42, , 46F
05/12 23:42, 46F
推
05/13 00:23, , 47F
05/13 00:23, 47F
推
05/13 00:26, , 48F
05/13 00:26, 48F
→
05/13 00:51, , 49F
05/13 00:51, 49F
推
05/13 00:53, , 50F
05/13 00:53, 50F
推
05/13 01:00, , 51F
05/13 01:00, 51F
推
05/13 01:59, , 52F
05/13 01:59, 52F
推
05/13 03:19, , 53F
05/13 03:19, 53F
推
05/13 08:12, , 54F
05/13 08:12, 54F
推
05/13 09:52, , 55F
05/13 09:52, 55F
推
05/13 11:07, , 56F
05/13 11:07, 56F
推
05/13 13:16, , 57F
05/13 13:16, 57F
推
05/13 19:05, , 58F
05/13 19:05, 58F
推
05/13 21:38, , 59F
05/13 21:38, 59F
推
05/13 23:30, , 60F
05/13 23:30, 60F
推
05/14 12:34, , 61F
05/14 12:34, 61F
討論串 (同標題文章)