[情報] Joe Torre submits replay proposal

看板MLB作者 (距離太遠 思念太近)時間12年前 (2013/08/16 01:02), 編輯推噓29(29014)
留言43則, 32人參與, 最新討論串1/1
簡單翻譯 就是 MLB 明年要增加 video replay 的使用度 MLB EVP Joe Torre 已經把提案弄出來了 剛剛聽 ESPN 的說法是, 教練在前六局有一次 "挑戰" 判決的機會 第七局以後有兩次. 至於能不能將前面沒有用的次數留到後面還要討論 而所有判決將會由 MLB 在紐約的總部進行審議, 而不是現在的 由裁判組進去 video room 決定. 基本上除了好壞球以外都可挑戰. 如果有在看 NFL 的, 基本上就是 NFL 的 coach challenge 紅旗的意思 這個 replay 使用的投票將會在球季末的時候投票, 若有 > 75% 的 owner 同意 新的 video replay 制度就會上路. http://tinyurl.com/pwun6e6 COOPERSTOWN, N.Y. -- Major League Baseball Executive Vice President Joe Torre has given his instant replay proposal to the executive committee to consider as baseball's brass huddled for two days of meetings. Commissioner Bud Selig was to address the media on Thursday morning to discuss what is on the table. "I thought it was very thoughtful and well done," Selig said Wednesday evening. "We'll discuss it in more detail tomorrow. We haven't even discussed it." MLB is looking at a vast expansion of video review for the 2014 season and is examining whether all calls other than balls and strikes should be subject to instant replay. Torre said at the All-Star Game in New York last month that he was fairly confident a new system would be in place for next season. Video review has been in place for umpires on home run calls since August 2008. "You know me, I'm always encouraged," Torre said Wednesday. Selig initially wanted to add trap plays and fair-or-foul calls down the lines for 2013, then decided to proceed cautiously, and the change was put off while more radical options were studied. Torre has said all options were being considered, including an NFL-type system that would give managers the ability to challenge calls. The replay subcommittee also includes former St. Louis Cardinals manager Tony La Russa and Atlanta Braves president John Schuerholz. -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 76.117.52.242

08/16 01:27, , 1F
很棒阿 至少能遏止類似嘎拉瑞嘎的事件發生XD
08/16 01:27, 1F

08/16 01:38, , 2F
說好壞球還是不能challenge 但是其他的play都可以
08/16 01:38, 2F

08/16 01:39, , 3F
看來以後要看到教練跟裁判爭論的鏡頭很難了...
08/16 01:39, 3F

08/16 01:41, , 4F
好壞球就留給HP吧,不然乾脆不需要裁判好了
08/16 01:41, 4F

08/16 01:51, , 5F
一樓不一定喔 如果提出次數已經用完也是不能
08/16 01:51, 5F

08/16 02:11, , 6F
至少有機會可以逆轉誤判...
08/16 02:11, 6F

08/16 02:55, , 7F
要不是有裁判公會 很多用電子都能取代了..
08/16 02:55, 7F
※ 編輯: mrkey 來自: 76.117.52.242 (08/16 03:14)

08/16 03:25, , 8F
所以是直接連線到紐約總部來判決?
08/16 03:25, 8F

08/16 06:29, , 9F
如果這樣真的是時代的進步.. football的challenge好看
08/16 06:29, 9F

08/16 06:49, , 10F
HP能不能判好壞球跟有沒有HP可以分開談
08/16 06:49, 10F

08/16 08:42, , 11F
教練可出來和裁判吵架,吵半天才說:我不要挑戰,留著用!XD
08/16 08:42, 11F

08/16 08:47, , 12F
早就該做了....
08/16 08:47, 12F

08/16 08:48, , 13F
如果把單是今年的誤判影片剪出來可能都能播上一小時了
08/16 08:48, 13F

08/16 08:51, , 14F
不只吧.... 光Angel Hernandez 已經超過一小時了
08/16 08:51, 14F

08/16 09:17, , 15F
布朗爺:寂寞
08/16 09:17, 15F

08/16 09:18, , 16F
NFL挑戰失敗會有懲罰啊,棒球挑戰失敗要懲罰啥?直接出局?
08/16 09:18, 16F

08/16 09:26, , 17F
扣一分嗎XD 畢竟NFL的扣除暫停在NFL的世界裡是很重大的
08/16 09:26, 17F

08/16 09:43, , 18F
Angel Hernandez可以選一支年度Top10
08/16 09:43, 18F

08/16 09:45, , 19F
可以考慮扣一次投手暫停,教練上來就得直接換投
08/16 09:45, 19F

08/16 09:49, , 20F
這樣後半戰比較有問題 RP海上陣時常常是一次直接換掉
08/16 09:49, 20F

08/16 09:49, , 21F
到時候總仔耍賴說我原本要上兩次的 這就很難界定 XD
08/16 09:49, 21F

08/16 09:51, , 22F
good
08/16 09:51, 22F

08/16 10:32, , 23F
進攻方挑戰的時候有啥暫停給你扣..
08/16 10:32, 23F

08/16 10:45, , 24F
一個出局數?沒有就扣下一場的
08/16 10:45, 24F

08/16 10:49, , 25F
網球挑戰失敗也沒事阿XD 為什麼一定要懲罰
08/16 10:49, 25F

08/16 10:58, , 26F
目前聽說就和NFL,網球一樣,挑戰成功就保留那個挑戰
08/16 10:58, 26F

08/16 10:58, , 27F
如果挑戰失敗的話就沒有了
08/16 10:58, 27F

08/16 11:09, , 28F
不用Angel Hernandez, 今天已經total 4個誤判
08/16 11:09, 28F

08/16 11:09, , 29F
NYM/SD半分鐘前才一個錯誤判決
08/16 11:09, 29F

08/16 11:14, , 30F
類似網球 鷹眼的道裡嗎?
08/16 11:14, 30F

08/16 11:32, , 31F
好難過,這樣被趕出場的畫面會少很多
08/16 11:32, 31F

08/16 11:40, , 32F
Angel Hernandez:老子就是愛趕下班....有看沒看都一樣
08/16 11:40, 32F

08/16 11:56, , 33F
阿是有用逆 Rosales的全壘打看重播後還是被黑掉啊
08/16 11:56, 33F

08/16 12:44, , 34F
看過之前有裁判爆料總教練們上來吵架的內容 不覺得會少
08/16 12:44, 34F

08/16 13:56, , 35F
樓上說的我有印象XD 不曉得還找不找的到...
08/16 13:56, 35F

08/16 14:03, , 36F
請洽catsondbs的文章 http://ppt.cc/2BhI
08/16 14:03, 36F

08/16 14:19, , 37F
謝謝樓上XD
08/16 14:19, 37F

08/16 14:50, , 38F
客氣了
08/16 14:50, 38F

08/16 18:52, , 39F
(  ̄□ ̄)ー 異議あり
08/16 18:52, 39F

08/16 19:20, , 40F
早就有這樣的提議了,不過亡羊補牢時未晚
08/16 19:20, 40F

08/16 23:59, , 41F
突然想到 如果影帶無法判定是不是誤判(被擋住之類)那怎麼算?
08/16 23:59, 41F

08/17 01:14, , 42F
現在都能追蹤投球的軌跡了 不知道將來能不能追蹤外野的飛球
08/17 01:14, 42F

08/19 00:13, , 43F
的確像是網球的鷹眼
08/19 00:13, 43F
文章代碼(AID): #1I3Gck6f (MLB)