[情報] 2006 年後十大搶交易案

看板MLB作者 (Westy)時間13年前 (2011/01/27 22:32), 編輯推噓33(33012)
留言45則, 34人參與, 最新討論串1/1
只考慮得到球員和送走球員的 WAR 差距 (BR版本) 球員年紀、球隊陣容、薪資、合約期限都不考慮 Sent WAR: 該球員離隊後累積的 WAR 總和,再次轉隊仍計算在內 Received WAR: 所得到球員在隊中累積的 WAR,換隊後不計算在內 http://tinyurl.com/46r56q6 資料出自這篇文章 1. 教士-遊騎兵 A-Gon 交易案 Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR Net Gain ────────────── ─────────────── Adam Eaton -2.9 Adrian Gonzalez 22.9 Akinori Otsuka 3.7 Terrmel Sledge -0.5 Billy Killian 0 Chris Young 6.6 ────────────── ─────────────── 0.8 29 28.2 2. 印地安人-水兵 秋信守 Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Ben Broussard -2 Shin-Soo Choo 18.2 Shawn Nottingham 0 ────────────── ─────────────── -2 18.2 20.2 3. 老虎-馬林魚 小卡布 Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Cameron Maybin 1.7 Dontrelle Willis -1.4 Mike Rabelo -0.6 Miguel Cabrera 14.4 Andrew Miller -3.5 Burke Badenhop 0.4 Eulogio De La Cruz -1.3 Dallas Trahern 0 ────────────── ─────────────── -3.3 13 16.3 4. 光芒-雙城 狀元... Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Delmon Young 0.3 Jason Bartlett 6.8 Jason Pridie -0.3 Matt Garza 7 Brendan Harris -0.2 Eduardo Morlan 0 ────────────── ─────────────── -0.2 13.8 14 5. 白襪-條子 Danks Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Brandon McCarthy 1.2 John Danks 12.3 David Paisano 0 Nick Massett 1.7 Jacob Rasner 0 ────────────── ─────────────── 1.2 14 12.8 6. 梅子-雙城 山大王 Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Carlos Gomez 3 Johan Santana 14.4 Phillip Humber 0.1 Kevin Mulvey -0.5 Deolis Guerra 0 ────────────── ─────────────── 2.6 14.4 11.8 7. 紅人-紅襪 阿漏油 Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Wily Mo Pena 1.7 Bronson Arroyo 13.1 11.4 8. 三方交易水兵送走 Putz Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── J.J. Putz 1.1 Aaron Heilman 0 Sean Green -0.2 Jason Vargas 1.8 Jeremy Reed -0.7 Maikel Cleto 0 Endy Chavez 0.1 Ezequiel Carrera 0 Mike Carp 0.3 Franklin Gutierrez 8.8 ────────────── ─────────────── 0.2 11 10.8 9. 紅雀-運動家 Holliday Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Brett Wallace -0.1 Matt Holliday 8.3 Clay Mortensen -1 Shane Peterson 0 ────────────── ─────────────── -1.1 8.3 9.4 10. 笑臉人-水兵 Cabrera Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR ────────────── ─────────────── Eduardo Perez -0.7 Asdrubal Cabrera 8.5 9.2 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.160.65.224

01/27 22:34, , 1F
Bavasi 當年跟 Indians 那兩筆交易真的很經典。
01/27 22:34, 1F

01/27 22:35, , 2F
而且換過去那兩個人都先後離開球場了。
01/27 22:35, 2F

01/27 22:37, , 3F
應該還要再加進薪資考量會比較好
01/27 22:37, 3F

01/27 22:38, , 4F
水兵:說好不提的.....
01/27 22:38, 4F

01/27 22:39, , 5F
請問~為什麼當初Rangers會把A-Gon放走?
01/27 22:39, 5F

01/27 22:40, , 6F
條子有 Mark Teixeira
01/27 22:40, 6F

01/27 22:42, , 7F
少數幾位新秀還沒收成 評估時間還早了些
01/27 22:42, 7F

01/27 22:44, , 8F
唔 赫然發現Delmon Young竟然只有0.3
01/27 22:44, 8F

01/27 22:44, , 9F
不知道當初Nathan那包賺多少
01/27 22:44, 9F
Player Sent Sent WAR Player Received Received WAR Net Gain ────────────── ─────────────── A.J. Pierzynski 6.8 Joe Nathan 19.8 Francisco Liriano 8.4 Boof Bonser -0.4 ────────────── ─────────────── 6.8 27.8 21

01/27 22:44, , 10F
楊大猛去年打很好只有0.3 之前應該扣不少
01/27 22:44, 10F

01/27 22:48, , 11F
完全可以看出豬頭B跟Z的差別...
01/27 22:48, 11F

01/27 22:48, , 12F
看成十大搶案....
01/27 22:48, 12F

01/27 22:51, , 13F
這故事告訴我們別以為用A咖搶劫對方農場很容易
01/27 22:51, 13F

01/27 22:55, , 14F
樓上的結論反了嗎?
01/27 22:55, 14F

01/27 22:57, , 15F
有嗎?
01/27 22:57, 15F

01/27 23:01, , 16F
沒錯呀 3 6 9都沒搶到什麼好貨
01/27 23:01, 16F

01/27 23:06, , 17F
好文
01/27 23:06, 17F

01/27 23:06, , 18F
我也看成是十大搶案XD
01/27 23:06, 18F

01/27 23:07, , 19F
不知道有沒有那種用A咖洗劫對方農場獲得大成功的案例
01/27 23:07, 19F

01/27 23:08, , 20F
馬林魚有夠慘 兩個第一輪的都等於投資失敗
01/27 23:08, 20F

01/27 23:08, , 21F
我只記得1993年勇士用三個無名的小聯盟球員 搶到McGriff
01/27 23:08, 21F

01/27 23:09, , 22F
另外 勇士在1980年代曾用一個當紅的SP 換到Smoltz
01/27 23:09, 22F

01/27 23:15, , 23F
Nathan那案就是kukki你說的 而且非常慘 科科
01/27 23:15, 23F

01/27 23:16, , 24F
可惜Bonser受傷壞掉了 要不然這交易還更扯
01/27 23:16, 24F

01/27 23:18, , 25F
8.8 那個好高
01/27 23:18, 25F

01/27 23:20, , 26F
Haren那個交易真的把D-Backs洗乾淨了
01/27 23:20, 26F

01/27 23:22, , 27F
現在要搶水兵幾乎是不可能了....
01/27 23:22, 27F
※ 編輯: Westmoreland 來自: 118.160.65.224 (01/28 01:25)

01/28 02:52, , 28F
當年八頭龍的那個交易就算拿A咖洗劫農場吧
01/28 02:52, 28F

01/28 07:09, , 29F
水兵迷如我早已麻木XD
01/28 07:09, 29F

01/28 08:46, , 30F
不考量年紀、薪資這樣比較實在沒啥意義…
01/28 08:46, 30F

01/28 11:42, , 31F
不考慮薪資真的沒什麼意義..
01/28 11:42, 31F

01/28 11:48, , 32F
拿A咖洗劫農場 還有鐵爺交易
01/28 11:48, 32F

01/28 11:48, , 33F
Andrus和Feliz都長出來了 結果反倒是真主菜的Salty...
01/28 11:48, 33F

01/28 11:55, , 34F
$$.....像運動家拋售Holliday那個交易
01/28 11:55, 34F

01/28 12:50, , 35F
沒辦法看出省的$
01/28 12:50, 35F

01/28 13:04, , 36F
Bavasi和大Z的功力一眼就可看出...
01/28 13:04, 36F

01/28 13:40, , 37F
Andrus這樣算長出來喔?雖然他防守很好啦...
01/28 13:40, 37F

01/28 17:12, , 38F
他只是砲管沒出來而已
01/28 17:12, 38F

01/28 20:07, , 39F
難道要像小亨利或是06~08年的Reyes那樣才算有長出來?
01/28 20:07, 39F

01/28 22:24, , 40F
養雞撿到Swisher算不算?
01/28 22:24, 40F

01/28 23:05, , 41F
Andrus這樣還不算長出來??? = =
01/28 23:05, 41F

01/29 12:54, , 42F
考慮了薪資後是不是又要開始算通膨?講考慮薪資才有意義的
01/29 12:54, 42F

01/29 12:54, , 43F
是不是該先提供個能讓人接受的算式出來?
01/29 12:54, 43F

01/30 03:47, , 44F
很簡單阿 以某個年份為基準年 換算出各年物價
01/30 03:47, 44F

01/30 03:48, , 45F
然後再跟這個數字合在一起考量 比如單純的除下去
01/30 03:48, 45F
文章代碼(AID): #1DGO7gqo (MLB)