Re: [問題] 調碰包一問
關於MJ羅漢的規則,雖然有部分我無法接受(如過水之解除)
但就錯碰之處理,代位賠付之概念,基本上我是認同的
然而代位賠付此一概念,是否僅適用於錯碰?我想也有討論空間
--
七八年前吧,跟朋友打小牌,接近海底時輪上家出牌
此時對家整理牌牆留八墩,上牌時不慎將牌牆下一張待摸牌弄倒
導致下一張與下下張混淆,無法確定孰先孰後
並且此兩張牌恰有一張見光=七索
一般做法,也只能把兩張牌喇喇勒再疊回去吧(有不同意見?)
然而我恰好聽七索,也恰好地自摸
如果你是另兩家,怎麼說??
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 122.116.70.38
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/MJ/M.1430195673.A.6FF.html
→
04/28 18:29, , 1F
04/28 18:29, 1F
→
04/28 18:29, , 2F
04/28 18:29, 2F
推
04/29 11:12, , 3F
04/29 11:12, 3F
→
04/29 11:12, , 4F
04/29 11:12, 4F
→
04/29 20:27, , 5F
04/29 20:27, 5F
→
04/29 20:30, , 6F
04/29 20:30, 6F
→
05/05 18:35, , 7F
05/05 18:35, 7F
→
05/05 18:35, , 8F
05/05 18:35, 8F
→
05/05 22:25, , 9F
05/05 22:25, 9F
→
05/05 22:26, , 10F
05/05 22:26, 10F
→
05/05 22:27, , 11F
05/05 22:27, 11F
→
05/05 22:27, , 12F
05/05 22:27, 12F
→
05/05 22:28, , 13F
05/05 22:28, 13F
→
05/05 22:28, , 14F
05/05 22:28, 14F
→
05/05 22:46, , 15F
05/05 22:46, 15F
推
05/06 00:33, , 16F
05/06 00:33, 16F
→
05/06 00:33, , 17F
05/06 00:33, 17F
→
05/06 00:34, , 18F
05/06 00:34, 18F
→
05/06 00:34, , 19F
05/06 00:34, 19F
推
05/06 08:08, , 20F
05/06 08:08, 20F
→
05/06 08:08, , 21F
05/06 08:08, 21F
→
05/06 08:09, , 22F
05/06 08:09, 22F
→
05/11 01:40, , 23F
05/11 01:40, 23F
→
05/11 01:41, , 24F
05/11 01:41, 24F
→
05/11 01:43, , 25F
05/11 01:43, 25F
→
05/11 01:43, , 26F
05/11 01:43, 26F
→
05/11 01:44, , 27F
05/11 01:44, 27F
→
05/11 01:45, , 28F
05/11 01:45, 28F
→
05/11 01:46, , 29F
05/11 01:46, 29F
討論串 (同標題文章)