[請益] 酒後亂性的刑責和可罰性
請教各位先進,
Q:今成年人甲酒醉自陷無責任能力,而後對路邊不認識之乙女為強制性交,則甲之刑責?
情感上覺得甲之行為應罰,
但甲行為時無責任能力而不罰,
就算以過失原因自由行為來討論,強制性交罪亦不罰過失犯,
而甲也無自陷無責任能力以行強制性交之故意,無法以故意原因自由行為論罪,
刑責較輕的酒後傷人可以用過失原因自由行為入罪,
刑責較重的強制性交卻無法,
這樣是不是造成一個可罰性漏洞?
請問實務上是怎麼處理這種酒後亂性的問題?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.235.43.84
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/LAW/M.1432810999.A.559.html
推
05/28 19:17, , 1F
05/28 19:17, 1F
→
05/28 19:26, , 2F
05/28 19:26, 2F
→
05/28 19:27, , 3F
05/28 19:27, 3F
推
05/28 19:40, , 4F
05/28 19:40, 4F
推
05/28 19:44, , 5F
05/28 19:44, 5F
→
05/28 19:50, , 6F
05/28 19:50, 6F
推
05/28 20:00, , 7F
05/28 20:00, 7F
推
05/28 20:02, , 8F
05/28 20:02, 8F
→
05/28 20:02, , 9F
05/28 20:02, 9F
推
05/28 20:59, , 10F
05/28 20:59, 10F
→
05/28 20:59, , 11F
05/28 20:59, 11F
→
05/28 20:59, , 12F
05/28 20:59, 12F
→
05/28 20:59, , 13F
05/28 20:59, 13F
→
05/29 09:01, , 14F
05/29 09:01, 14F
→
05/29 09:48, , 15F
05/29 09:48, 15F
→
05/29 09:49, , 16F
05/29 09:49, 16F
→
05/29 09:50, , 17F
05/29 09:50, 17F
→
05/29 09:57, , 18F
05/29 09:57, 18F
→
05/29 13:41, , 19F
05/29 13:41, 19F
→
05/29 13:41, , 20F
05/29 13:41, 20F
→
05/29 13:42, , 21F
05/29 13:42, 21F
→
05/29 13:43, , 22F
05/29 13:43, 22F
→
05/29 13:43, , 23F
05/29 13:43, 23F
→
05/29 13:44, , 24F
05/29 13:44, 24F