Re: [問題] 起手洗掉會重複抽到嗎?
有點訝異似乎大多數人不知道"換牌Mulligan"的機制
這邊直接先講結論:
Mulligan掉的牌是不會回來的
Mulligan掉的牌是不會回來的
很重要講兩次就好,換句話說系統是先將你打叉的牌
放一旁,讓你重新抽滿該抽的張數後把剛剛打叉的放
回。這是很棒的方式,因為換牌的選擇畢竟是透過你
的經驗,當做出打叉這項決定就已經等同於我判定這
個match這張牌起手時不需要,遊戲規則上獎勵你讓
你不會在換到它,多多少少有辦法提升高手的勝率,
這是少數爐石比較不靠賽的機制。
其實我從開始接觸這遊戲就有這個疑問,也問過朋友
我們共同測試到現在好說也上萬場的賽局,很巧的沒
有任何一場換過的牌有再來,當然你可以說"ㄚ~你
靠賽" 首先,看我ID-reall1992賽個ㄐㄐ?再來,
或許這上萬場賽局窮舉例子在歸納出來結論真的就
是那麼巧都剛好換了沒來,的確有可能這樣也不能
算是一個完整的證明,但樣本數畢竟不小姑且有些
參考價值。要證明換了不會回來很難,但你要證明
換了會回來卻簡單,你只要提供一場換牌換回來的
影片就得證,也可以解開我玩這麼久的疑惑。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 49.217.192.14
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Hearthstone/M.1486572272.A.74A.html
推
02/09 00:46, , 1F
02/09 00:46, 1F
推
02/09 00:48, , 2F
02/09 00:48, 2F
推
02/09 00:50, , 3F
02/09 00:50, 3F
推
02/09 00:51, , 4F
02/09 00:51, 4F
推
02/09 00:54, , 5F
02/09 00:54, 5F
推
02/09 00:56, , 6F
02/09 00:56, 6F
推
02/09 00:57, , 7F
02/09 00:57, 7F
推
02/09 01:00, , 8F
02/09 01:00, 8F
推
02/09 01:02, , 9F
02/09 01:02, 9F
推
02/09 01:03, , 10F
02/09 01:03, 10F
推
02/09 01:06, , 11F
02/09 01:06, 11F
推
02/09 01:06, , 12F
02/09 01:06, 12F
推
02/09 01:07, , 13F
02/09 01:07, 13F
推
02/09 01:10, , 14F
02/09 01:10, 14F
→
02/09 01:10, , 15F
02/09 01:10, 15F
推
02/09 01:10, , 16F
02/09 01:10, 16F
推
02/09 01:11, , 17F
02/09 01:11, 17F
→
02/09 01:11, , 18F
02/09 01:11, 18F
推
02/09 01:11, , 19F
02/09 01:11, 19F
推
02/09 01:13, , 20F
02/09 01:13, 20F
推
02/09 01:14, , 21F
02/09 01:14, 21F
推
02/09 01:21, , 22F
02/09 01:21, 22F
推
02/09 01:26, , 23F
02/09 01:26, 23F
推
02/09 01:34, , 24F
02/09 01:34, 24F
推
02/09 01:37, , 25F
02/09 01:37, 25F
推
02/09 01:40, , 26F
02/09 01:40, 26F
推
02/09 01:42, , 27F
02/09 01:42, 27F
推
02/09 01:43, , 28F
02/09 01:43, 28F
推
02/09 01:44, , 29F
02/09 01:44, 29F
推
02/09 01:46, , 30F
02/09 01:46, 30F
推
02/09 01:46, , 31F
02/09 01:46, 31F
推
02/09 01:51, , 32F
02/09 01:51, 32F
推
02/09 01:55, , 33F
02/09 01:55, 33F
推
02/09 02:03, , 34F
02/09 02:03, 34F
推
02/09 02:03, , 35F
02/09 02:03, 35F
推
02/09 02:07, , 36F
02/09 02:07, 36F
推
02/09 02:08, , 37F
02/09 02:08, 37F
推
02/09 02:09, , 38F
02/09 02:09, 38F
推
02/09 02:16, , 39F
02/09 02:16, 39F
還有 97 則推文
推
02/09 16:20, , 137F
02/09 16:20, 137F
推
02/09 16:25, , 138F
02/09 16:25, 138F
推
02/09 16:30, , 139F
02/09 16:30, 139F
推
02/09 16:39, , 140F
02/09 16:39, 140F
推
02/09 16:42, , 141F
02/09 16:42, 141F
推
02/09 16:45, , 142F
02/09 16:45, 142F
推
02/09 17:03, , 143F
02/09 17:03, 143F
推
02/09 17:11, , 144F
02/09 17:11, 144F
推
02/09 17:11, , 145F
02/09 17:11, 145F
推
02/09 17:15, , 146F
02/09 17:15, 146F
推
02/09 17:38, , 147F
02/09 17:38, 147F
推
02/09 18:15, , 148F
02/09 18:15, 148F
噓
02/09 18:17, , 149F
02/09 18:17, 149F
推
02/09 18:57, , 150F
02/09 18:57, 150F
推
02/09 19:28, , 151F
02/09 19:28, 151F
推
02/09 19:50, , 152F
02/09 19:50, 152F
推
02/09 20:55, , 153F
02/09 20:55, 153F
推
02/09 21:35, , 154F
02/09 21:35, 154F
推
02/09 21:49, , 155F
02/09 21:49, 155F
推
02/09 21:58, , 156F
02/09 21:58, 156F
推
02/09 22:54, , 157F
02/09 22:54, 157F
推
02/09 23:42, , 158F
02/09 23:42, 158F
推
02/10 00:13, , 159F
02/10 00:13, 159F
推
02/10 00:48, , 160F
02/10 00:48, 160F
→
02/10 01:35, , 161F
02/10 01:35, 161F
推
02/10 01:47, , 162F
02/10 01:47, 162F
推
02/10 02:27, , 163F
02/10 02:27, 163F
推
02/10 02:28, , 164F
02/10 02:28, 164F
推
02/10 07:30, , 165F
02/10 07:30, 165F
推
02/10 09:17, , 166F
02/10 09:17, 166F
推
02/10 10:18, , 167F
02/10 10:18, 167F
推
02/10 13:24, , 168F
02/10 13:24, 168F
推
02/11 10:52, , 169F
02/11 10:52, 169F
推
02/11 15:00, , 170F
02/11 15:00, 170F
推
02/11 21:16, , 171F
02/11 21:16, 171F
推
02/13 07:49, , 172F
02/13 07:49, 172F
推
02/13 11:01, , 173F
02/13 11:01, 173F
推
02/13 18:06, , 174F
02/13 18:06, 174F
推
02/19 14:04, , 175F
02/19 14:04, 175F
推
08/01 23:50, , 176F
08/01 23:50, 176F
討論串 (同標題文章)