[問題] 填空一題請教

看板GRE作者 (Metonymia)時間11年前 (2013/06/13 18:04), 編輯推噓4(4推 0噓 13→)
留言17則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/3 (看更多)
The postulates of economics are claimed, on the one hand, to refer to generla laws of human behavior, and on the other, to be ____(1)____ and hence know by intuition. Representatives of rival schools of economics, in ____(2)____ this claim, have all called into question validity of the theory, arguing that far from being ___(3)___, these postulates may even be specious. (1) (2) (3) A. a priori D. antagonism to G. valuable B. clandestine E. support for H. axiomatic C. comprehensive F. contest for I. universal 已知答案: (1) A, (2) D, (3)?? 我覺得是H (對比specious), 可是不知道為何也有可能是I, 請高手幫忙<(_ _)> 謝謝!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.230.47.229
推
06/13 20:02, , 1F
以下乃個人淺見: I指的是可以apply to all the thing
06/13 20:02, 1F
→
06/13 20:02, , 2F
or conditions
06/13 20:02, 2F
→
06/13 20:03, , 3F
specious 應該是指 superficially good or true
06/13 20:03, 3F
→
06/13 20:03, , 4F
所以我覺得答案為H
06/13 20:03, 4F
→
06/13 20:09, , 5F
我跟你想的一樣, universal在這沒有反義詞~不該選
06/13 20:09, 5F
推
06/13 22:33, , 6F
沒人覺得第一格選A很奇怪的嗎...，拜託各位幫忙解釋
06/13 22:33, 6F
→
06/13 22:41, , 7F
a priori: 非經驗可知的, 故只能仰賴intuition直覺
06/13 22:41, 7F
→
06/13 22:54, , 8F
謝謝M大，字神培訓營翻開沒有就沒查MW了= =
06/13 22:54, 8F
推
06/14 14:28, , 9F
我認為應該選I 因為該對手school對理論的validity
06/14 14:28, 9F
→
06/14 14:28, , 10F
提出question 所以因對應到有效性相關的選項
06/14 14:28, 10F
→
06/14 14:29, , 11F
即universal
06/14 14:29, 11F
→
06/14 14:30, , 12F
universal對應到關鍵字validity
06/14 14:30, 12F
→
06/14 16:30, , 13F
可是universal跟validity的關係是?
06/14 16:30, 13F
→
06/14 16:30, , 14F
universal是普遍的, 沒說對或錯呀
06/14 16:30, 14F
推
06/16 00:17, , 15F
我的想法: 一個理論有不有效, 要看這理論的預設是不
06/16 00:17, 15F
→
06/16 00:18, , 16F
是對的 而一個對的預設 是指它在所有情況下都成立
06/16 00:18, 16F
→
06/16 00:19, , 17F
所以用universal在postulate上時 是有對錯判判斷的
06/16 00:19, 17F
‣ 更多 Metonymia 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HkPabl0 (GRE)
‣ 更多 Metonymia 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HkPabl0 (GRE)