[請益] will/is going to/ is being

看板Eng-Class作者 (嗨)時間9年前 (2016/03/13 18:20), 9年前編輯推噓2(2017)
留言19則, 4人參與, 最新討論串1/1
最近在這個文法上遇到了不少挫折 以下題目是錯的刪掉 It's not a deep, but it _______ a scar a. will leave b. is going to leave c. is leaving ”錯的是c“ a和b在在解答裡對此題都有相似的意思 以下是我自己分析的差別 不知道合不合理 will leave 的意思因該是帶點預測 is going to leave 應該是比will leave 較肯定點 is leaving 和 is going to leave 照理講意思應該一樣啊 都是比較肯定的 但為何答案卻寫is leaving 不成立? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.137.14.244 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1457864440.A.944.html

03/13 19:09, , 1F
只有來去動詞進行式才能表未來式吧?這邊leave v.留下
03/13 19:09, 1F

03/13 19:09, , 2F
;而不是來去動詞的leave v.離開。
03/13 19:09, 2F
Present continuous we can often use either the present contunuous or be going to with a similar meaning to talk about planned future . The present continuous indicates that we have a firm intention or have made a definite decition to do something , although this may not already be arranged 會不會是因為這不是人“主動”去做的關係 ※ 編輯: stayhome (223.137.14.244), 03/13/2016 19:36:07

03/13 19:47, , 3F
覺得無關。畢竟「颱風這周末會來」你也是可以說:
03/13 19:47, 3F

03/13 19:47, , 4F
The typhoon is coming this weekend.
03/13 19:47, 4F
go 和come 是例外 ※ 編輯: stayhome (223.137.14.244), 03/13/2016 20:20:15

03/13 20:27, , 5F
所以才說通常「來去動詞」可以進行式表未來式,而來去
03/13 20:27, 5F

03/13 20:28, , 6F
動詞不僅有go和come,arrive, return這種表位移的都是
03/13 20:28, 6F

03/13 20:28, , 7F
leave也有可能是,如果當「離開」解的話,可是你這邊的
03/13 20:28, 7F

03/13 20:29, , 8F
leave很明顯就是指「留下」疤痕。
03/13 20:29, 8F

03/13 20:37, , 9F
題目的邏輯應該是ab是未來式,c是現在進行式,如此而已
03/13 20:37, 9F
"are you seeing the doctor again next week?"="are you going to see..."" "i am not asking Tom to the party"="i am not going to ask.." 以上都不是來去動詞喔~ ※ 編輯: stayhome (223.137.14.244), 03/13/2016 21:01:44 ※ 編輯: stayhome (223.137.14.244), 03/13/2016 21:02:34

03/13 21:19, , 10F
be + Ving 表計畫或安排中 的未來
03/13 21:19, 10F

03/13 22:19, , 11F
"to talk about planned future"-> "傷口留疤"不是你一步
03/13 22:19, 11F

03/13 22:19, , 12F
一步計畫好(事先定好的)的未來(這是自然形成的,和你的"p
03/13 22:19, 12F

03/13 22:20, , 13F
plan(s)"無關)
03/13 22:20, 13F

03/13 22:21, , 14F
It's not a deep cut/It's not deep 你少打一個字/多打一
03/13 22:21, 14F

03/13 22:21, , 15F
個字
03/13 22:21, 15F

03/13 22:26, , 16F
看樣子是出自Advanced Grammar in Use. 接下來的"However
03/13 22:26, 16F

03/13 22:26, , 17F
"的說明也很重要"... over which we have no control....
03/13 22:26, 17F

03/13 22:26, , 18F
arrange these ..." 等等等等。
03/13 22:26, 18F

03/13 22:26, , 19F
總之「整個」看(提供到版上),不要只抓你想要的一小段
03/13 22:26, 19F
文章代碼(AID): #1MvJxub4 (Eng-Class)