[分享] 為什麼台灣覺得英文難

看板Eng-Class作者 (鋼筆)時間9年前 (2014/12/17 03:39), 9年前編輯推噓12(12047)
留言59則, 11人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
Hi there I am Kare I am a Taiwanese oversea student currently studying in Singapore I am here to share some observation that I have made for the past 7 years English like Chinese is one of the most widely used language of around the wor ld But Taiwanese seems to struggle with it, I had not only heard once or twice th at my friends' complaining about the difficulty of English and having trouble to soak it into the mighty brain of ours Here are some reasons I think as of why. 1. Difficulty in defining words In English we have to Define what we say Especially a specific word we use. For example " I am Home ", base on this sen tence you cannot fully explain where am I, I could be at airport of my homelan d or at my own house or at where I was born, and because I did not define "hom e" or elaborate on the sentence result in a chaotic confusion. When there is a Confusion we would try not to touch it, try not to understand it Despite that in Chinese we also have to define word but unlike English, Chines e word usually have a more specific meaning attach to the word, which we could have a picture of it when we think of it, but English is a language that was formed from many different civilization considering that English is not a nati ve language. This is the main different More in Chinese we describe big as 大 but in English? Etc : Humongous, huge, gigantic, large. All these words is replacement of big. And you have to know at least a few so that when you need to explain them you know what it is After talking about the cause I need to define "define" I believe, in English, to define is to explain and elaborate a meaning of the word. Especially in an argumentative, If I give a title : Should Student have a boyfriend and girlfriend relationshi p? In this case you have to define 3 things : students, girl-boy friend , relatio nship so as to talk about it, but the problem lies here how do we define in En glish? To tackle this kind of confusion you can solve it by understanding English, wh ich is understand the meaning and know how to use but not just memorize what i t means and how it was spelt You have to know if a word is a noun,verb,adjective or adverb. Trust me more than 50% of the people cannot identify it. 2. Pronunciation / Afraid of Speaking Eng / Non- English Speaking background To learn a Language it not simply just to memorize it, this category falls at oral skill, to proudly say that you speak a certain tongue you must have the ability to write and speak and even understand that language. But in Taiwan or I should Chinese English Learner we are afraid and not capable of speaking En glish. I summed up a few points A. We are afraid we pronounce some words wrong and we would get mocked with B. We are not sure if our Accent is some sort of funny C. We do not speak English at home at School or at any other places And in Taiwan oral skill has been neglected which is a big blockade in Learnin g a language. Imagine the word 美麗 and imagine you do not know how to read th at word but you know the word base on the look itself, trust me, you are not g onna go far in learning Chinese. Project it to English the word beauty if you only know the look of it but you don't know how it is Pronounced you gonna hav e problem in a conversation. Language is something you can use quite often in real life unlike Sin Cos Tan. If you cannot use a language that you learnt in real life you do not need to consider yourself learning, perhaps a reader who does not know what he himself is reading To tackle this problem is the hardee it requires high amount of effort and bas ic memorizing use a dictionary on how every alphabet is pronounced and practic e it everyday until you get it to the tip of your finger and then start to lea rn how to pronounce a full word and slowly build up the speed of learning woul d directly proportional in a increasing manner. 3. Chinese way of thinking We are too used to Chinese writing style that we will often brought it into En glish for example 現在幾點 we might say " what time is it?", but the correct w ay of speaking is saying " What is the time now?" To tackle this little problem just remember the way you write your English Ful l Name Let say if my name is 張小華 to write my name in English it is Xiaohua Zhang/C hang So project it back 現在幾點 現在 - now 幾點 - time And it become : what is the time now English is a worldwide language if you can hold it in your hand, a higher chan ce that you would do great and have a bright future Thank you for your attention 以上皆是個人觀點 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.136.120.182 ※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1418758781.A.3DE.html

12/17 13:05, , 1F
Maybe redo proofreading and layout...
12/17 13:05, 1F
Sorry has a rush on posting it was sleepy

12/17 13:06, , 2F
謝謝分享,我覺得主要問題出在教育方式,當台灣國高中英文課
12/17 13:06, 2F

12/17 13:07, , 3F
永遠只是著重在背單字,文法與重閱讀,聽寫說都被忽略了...
12/17 13:07, 3F

12/17 13:08, , 4F
只要我們的教育模式與思想不改,真的很難進步,因為學語文到
12/17 13:08, 4F

12/17 13:09, , 5F
最後,都變成了要應付考試,國高中6年天天碰英文,老實說程度
12/17 13:09, 5F

12/17 13:09, , 6F
應該不會這麼差才是...
12/17 13:09, 6F
When I read what my friend is writing I found out that They have a knowledge on English But they do not know how to use a word correctly and when I try to teach them to speak english Problems appear They cannot get a pronounciation right or at least I have to keep on repeating it

12/17 13:18, , 7F
不同意...如果連字彙跟閱讀都沒有基礎,聽說寫也很難好
12/17 13:18, 7F

12/17 13:18, , 8F
奇時真的很難衡量。每個人天賦,投入,目的都不同
12/17 13:18, 8F
To talk about this I have to admit Yes you need a certain amount of Vocab however just vocab is not enough A lot of Discipline is needed it not like any other subject that you can Memorize a formula and use it Everywhere

12/17 13:53, , 9F
一樓讚!
12/17 13:53, 9F

12/17 13:55, , 10F
And, please something real about language teaching and
12/17 13:55, 10F

12/17 13:55, , 11F
learning. don't just think you know it
12/17 13:55, 11F

12/17 13:55, , 12F
read something real
12/17 13:55, 12F
I believe experience is a good teacher

12/17 14:32, , 13F
小朋友就像海綿一樣,教啥就會啥,學不好,當然是老
12/17 14:32, 13F

12/17 14:33, , 14F
師和教材爛。結果他們卻賴到學生
12/17 14:33, 14F

12/17 14:34, , 15F
不努力。拜託,臺灣學生很用功的。
12/17 14:34, 15F

12/17 15:47, , 16F
我只是在說在學習上缺失的東西 導致學英文的困難
12/17 15:47, 16F

12/17 15:48, , 17F
我是手機拍版-。-
12/17 15:48, 17F

12/17 15:49, , 18F
Kee32 這就是在說少教了哪些
12/17 15:49, 18F

12/17 15:51, , 19F
語言是很難教 我不否認
12/17 15:51, 19F

12/17 15:51, , 20F
但是台灣也懶的想方法教
12/17 15:51, 20F

12/17 15:51, , 21F
就是單字ㄧ直背 sentence structure 爛到爆
12/17 15:51, 21F

12/17 17:31, , 22F
I mostly do not object to what you said here, but
12/17 17:31, 22F

12/17 17:31, , 23F
please learn to properly punctuate your sentences...
12/17 17:31, 23F

12/17 17:32, , 24F
People are very quick to dismiss you when they see that
12/17 17:32, 24F

12/17 17:33, , 25F
you can't even use comma properly.
12/17 17:33, 25F
Handphone layout is a B1tch

12/17 18:55, , 26F
你在第一線看過,觀察過,再講這些還不遲
12/17 18:55, 26F

12/17 22:26, , 27F
想當然爾很容易,台灣英文教育不算差,真的
12/17 22:26, 27F

12/17 22:28, , 28F
很現實就是台灣不說英文,再怎麼提倡都有個極限
12/17 22:28, 28F

12/17 22:29, , 29F
教材、老師再好只能領進門,學生願意花的時間就那樣
12/17 22:29, 29F

12/17 22:30, , 30F
現在學生要學的東西很多,你說英文重要,每科也認為自己很重
12/17 22:30, 30F

12/17 22:30, , 31F
12/17 22:30, 31F

12/17 22:32, , 32F
台灣英語程度從來就不是學校教育的問題,問題在你下課後還願
12/17 22:32, 32F

12/17 22:32, , 33F
意花多少時間,畢了業還願意花多少時間
12/17 22:32, 33F

12/17 22:34, , 34F
語言作為一種技能,是培養出來的,本來教不是說上完幾堂課就
12/17 22:34, 34F

12/17 22:34, , 35F
一定有多強的能力
12/17 22:34, 35F
語言是極需Self-Discipline的 不管甚麼語言都是 我了解你說的 我承認錯想了台灣教育 我其實應該把這篇分享那些在外學英文的華人 而不是台灣本土

12/17 22:37, , 36F
其實我在文章裡也有提到 non-english speaking fam
12/17 22:37, 36F
※ 編輯: Kare112233 (111.240.218.164), 12/17/2014 23:12:24

12/17 23:52, , 37F
我實在不知道,學哪樣東西,Self-Discipline不重要?
12/17 23:52, 37F

12/17 23:53, , 38F
你把學習的通則,拿來套到學英文或學語言上,就明顯是外行
12/17 23:53, 38F

12/17 23:53, , 39F
你乾脆說,學語言是需要花時間的.廢話,學哪樣東西不需要?
12/17 23:53, 39F

12/18 01:55, , 40F
看不下去 超爛文法 還handphone勒
12/18 01:55, 40F

12/18 13:07, , 41F
我覺得可能系統英文沒學到ㄧ定程度,然後英文大部分是從生
12/18 13:07, 41F

12/18 13:09, , 42F
活和對話中擷取,文章只部份片語貌似道地,但其實似是而非
12/18 13:09, 42F

12/18 13:10, , 43F
句構,或者我們說的grammar更是導致你這篇文不讓人信服
12/18 13:10, 43F

12/18 13:11, , 44F
很多地方的謬誤不是手機PO文能解釋的...
12/18 13:11, 44F

12/18 14:49, , 45F
講難聽點,就是喝過點洋墨水的孩子以為自己是英語教學專家
12/18 14:49, 45F

12/18 14:49, , 46F
12/18 14:49, 46F

12/19 16:02, , 47F
只有abc或是國外長大的敢說英文好吧。後來學的根本上
12/19 16:02, 47F

12/19 16:02, , 48F
就很難完美。
12/19 16:02, 48F

12/19 16:16, , 49F
把目標放在完美,就不用學了
12/19 16:16, 49F

12/20 05:03, , 50F
讀起來有點像高中作文練習應該能拿18.5/20
12/20 05:03, 50F

12/21 04:23, , 51F
就完全是看有沒有願意與努力學而已
12/21 04:23, 51F

12/21 04:24, , 52F
就像我們的國語&中文那麼難 還是有以英語為母語的
12/21 04:24, 52F

12/21 04:24, , 53F
美國人學得很好
12/21 04:24, 53F

12/21 04:24, , 54F
也有美國人在台灣超過十年了 就是不學
12/21 04:24, 54F

12/21 04:26, , 55F
台灣人學習英語的情況也差不多啦
12/21 04:26, 55F

12/21 04:26, , 56F
有的人就是不願意好好地學
12/21 04:26, 56F

12/21 04:27, , 57F
有的人沒去過英語系國家 英語聽說讀寫都精通
12/21 04:27, 57F

12/21 04:27, , 58F
所以 完全是看個人
12/21 04:27, 58F

12/21 09:33, , 59F
歸因於個人努力,等於是廢話
12/21 09:33, 59F
文章代碼(AID): #1Ka8fzFU (Eng-Class)
文章代碼(AID): #1Ka8fzFU (Eng-Class)