[請益] 本句who之前是否應加上逗號

看板Eng-Class作者 (tucson)時間11年前 (2014/06/12 00:15), 11年前編輯推噓3(305)
留言8則, 4人參與, 最新討論串1/1
Mrs. Norpa was new to our school. Mrs. Norpa was this little English teacher from USA ____ always wore a black leather skirt, even though she was fifty years old. (a) who (b),who (c) which (d) ,which 請問答案應該哪一個? (a.) 或 (b.)?? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 61.64.178.76 ※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1402503334.A.6AA.html

06/12 00:48, , 1F
B
06/12 00:48, 1F

06/12 00:51, , 2F
字句為非限定
06/12 00:51, 2F

06/12 01:13, , 3F
"Practical English Usage" by Michael Swan, 3e
06/12 01:13, 3F

06/12 01:13, , 4F
130 cleft sentences (1): ....
06/12 01:13, 4F

06/12 01:13, , 5F
-> 1 ...
06/12 01:13, 5F
C大用非限定講法選(b) P大指的PEU用強調講法選的是(a) 那到底應該是(a)還是(b)??? PEU的例句: Mary was the person who kept a pig in the garden shed. The person who kept a pig in the garden shed was Mary. A pig was what Mary kept in the garden shed. You are the woman (that) I'll always love best, Casablanca is a film (that) I watch again and again. 如果以PUE給的加強句 cleft sentences來看 先行詞都是簡單的the person, a pig, the woman,a film 跟原題給的先行詞this little English teacher from USA似乎有點不太一樣 不知道這樣的先詞還可以在PUE的加強句 cleft sentences用法中嗎? 所以應該是限定/加強句 cleft sentences(a) 還是 非限定(b)???

06/12 08:30, , 6F
我覺得是那個USA把teacher&who隔開,所以不能用限定修飾
06/12 08:30, 6F
※ 編輯: tucson (219.85.143.97), 06/12/2014 10:04:42

06/12 14:00, , 7F
我也覺得是(b)是非限定用法,先行詞所指涉的東西已經
06/12 14:00, 7F

06/12 14:00, , 8F
很清楚了,關代沒有特別幫到甚麼忙。
06/12 14:00, 8F
文章代碼(AID): #1Jc82cQg (Eng-Class)