[考題] while&but

看板Eng-Class作者 (德加斯一號)時間13年前 (2013/01/25 12:18), 編輯推噓2(2推 0噓 22→)
留言24則, 5人參與, 6年前最新討論串1/1
. Kids don’t usually like radishes（小蘿蔔）, _____ if kids cut them up and put them in the salad, they will love the dish. (A) while (B) so (C) but (D) then 答案 C A為什麼不行? -- -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 111.249.167.45
推
01/26 20:07, , 1F
But才有轉折語意的意思，while是雖然，不能表示前後意思
01/26 20:07, 1F
→
01/26 20:07, , 2F
得轉變
01/26 20:07, 2F
推
01/26 21:24, , 3F
while擺句中通常表示「兩個主體」有不一樣的情況(對比)
01/26 21:24, 3F
→
01/26 21:25, , 4F
這裡的句中是指接前面的kids don't...，所以若用while
01/26 21:25, 4F
→
01/26 21:25, , 5F
應該是要接說[某人卻喜歡吃]。
01/26 21:25, 5F
→
01/26 21:26, , 6F
while擺句首，是有一意思用來表達轉折語意，等於although
01/26 21:26, 6F
→
01/26 21:28, , 7F
目的就是為了讓後方的主要子句變得聽起來[較驚人]
01/26 21:28, 7F
→
01/26 21:29, , 8F
但這裡空格後方已經有表達條件的連接詞if了，可以推測不
01/26 21:29, 8F
→
01/26 21:29, , 9F
應把這裡的while硬解釋成表轉折although之意。
01/26 21:29, 9F
→
01/26 21:30, , 10F
可參考朗文的例句
01/26 21:30, 10F
→
01/26 21:31, , 11F
(1) Schools in the north tend to be better equipped,
01/26 21:31, 11F
→
01/26 21:31, , 12F
while those in the south are relatively poor.
01/26 21:31, 12F
→
01/26 21:31, , 13F
(2) While there was no conclusive evidence, most
01/26 21:31, 13F
→
01/26 21:31, , 14F
people thought he was guilty.
01/26 21:31, 14F
→
01/26 21:33, , 15F
簡單來說，空格but在這邊是為了連接kids...和if...
01/26 21:33, 15F
→
01/26 21:34, , 16F
if則是負責連接kids...和they will...
01/26 21:34, 16F
→
01/28 09:12, , 17F
這邊是可以填 although 的，字典中就有列這個用法
01/28 09:12, 17F
→
01/28 09:13, , 18F
但是雖然 while 可以當 although 解，although 可以當 but 解
01/28 09:13, 18F
→
01/28 09:14, , 19F
在這個情形下是不能遞移的，因為 while 不等同這個用法的
01/28 09:14, 19F
→
01/28 09:14, , 20F
although..不知道這樣講會不會時很花 XD
01/28 09:14, 20F
→
01/28 09:14, , 21F
時-> X
01/28 09:14, 21F
→
09/07 00:15, , 22F
while those https://daxiv.com
09/07 00:15, 22F
→
12/02 18:29, , 23F
while擺句首，是有 https://daxiv.com
12/02 18:29, 23F
→
04/13 22:48, 6年前 , 24F
可參考朗文的例句 https://moxox.com
04/13 22:48, 24F
‣ 更多 imdegas1 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1H0WU1ym (Eng-Class)