[文法] 未來完成式...兩個句子問題
請教一下
我看書上寫
Next April, I will have worked here for 20 years.
那如果我這樣子寫
Next April, I will have been worked here for 20 years.
^^^^
這樣子意思是差不多的嗎?
只是想了解一下，為什不加been呢?
謝謝幫忙。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.136.149.125
→
05/13 17:06, , 1F
05/13 17:06, 1F
→
05/13 17:06, , 2F
05/13 17:06, 2F
→
05/13 17:10, , 3F
05/13 17:10, 3F
→
05/13 17:10, , 4F
05/13 17:10, 4F
→
05/13 17:11, , 5F
05/13 17:11, 5F
→
05/13 17:21, , 6F
05/13 17:21, 6F
可是書上另一個例子:
In tow more minutes, she will have been talking on the phone for three hours!
^^^^
可是這樣子他就有加been
這樣子就不是被動嗎?
然後有點搞不太清楚，被動和持續差在哪..
我加上been只是想表示持續而已
但是好像很奇怪..
謝謝幫忙
※ 編輯: bernachom 來自: 140.136.149.125 (05/13 17:34)
→
05/13 18:18, , 7F
05/13 18:18, 7F
→
05/13 18:18, , 8F
05/13 18:18, 8F
→
05/13 18:19, , 9F
05/13 18:19, 9F
→
05/13 18:20, , 10F
05/13 18:20, 10F
我看了書上幾個例子，我覺我搞錯方向..
為了避免我的問題太複雜..冏
我只是想問說
我原本的問題:
Next April, I will have worked here for 20 years.
書上其它的例子:
Come back at 5:00. your car will have been fixed by then.
In two more minutes, she will have been talking on the phone for three hours!
為什麼書上其它兩個例子都有加been
然後我問的這個第一個例子就不需要加been呢?
加been和不加been是差在哪呢?
然後什麼時後需要加呢?
謝謝幫忙
※ 編輯: bernachom 來自: 140.136.149.125 (05/13 18:27)
→
05/13 18:31, , 11F
05/13 18:31, 11F
→
05/13 18:31, , 12F
05/13 18:31, 12F
→
05/13 18:32, , 13F
05/13 18:32, 13F
我在想是不是應該原本的句子要改成:
Next April, I will have been working here for 20 years.
這樣子句子才正確?
謝謝幫忙
※ 編輯: bernachom 來自: 140.136.149.125 (05/13 19:25)
→
08/06 07:26, , 14F
08/06 07:26, 14F
→
09/06 23:52, , 15F
09/06 23:52, 15F
→
12/02 18:14, , 16F
12/02 18:14, 16F
→
04/13 22:29,
5年前
, 17F
04/13 22:29, 17F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇)：