[文法] 同位語要不要用冠詞?

看板Eng-Class作者 (Chemical Romance)時間14年前 (2010/06/21 14:41), 編輯推噓1(1010)
留言11則, 4人參與, 最新討論串1/1
題目:活用圖解B p-19 Hemingway, _____ of "The Old Man and the Sea," killed himself in 1961. A) an author B) the author C) one author D) author 答案為D ,一開始我的想法為B 。我是把句子還原成 "who is the author of...."因此應保留the ,但是 答案的解釋為「人名之後的同位語,名詞之前不加冠 詞。」確實在該書的前面也提到類似觀念。 Brown, leader of our class, is an able man. 我書唸的不是很多,但是我在網路上面看到很多跟這 有些微衝突的說法。 http://grammar.about.com/od/basicsentencegrammar/a/buildappositive.htm Jimbo Gold, a professional magician, performed at my sister's birthday party. http://www.chompchomp.com/terms/appositive.htm During the dinner conversation, Clifford, the messiest eater at the table, spewed mashed potatoes like an erupting volcano. 因此我是有點混亂,因為就我本人使用以及過往的語 感(當然有可能是錯的)我是認為冠詞應該是存在的 。 麻煩有經驗以及熟悉這塊文法的高手,幫忙指點迷津。:) 感謝萬分。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.39.1.95

06/21 14:51, , 1F
XXX of XXX 不加冠詞
06/21 14:51, 1F

06/21 14:52, , 2F
Barack Obama, president of the United States,......
06/21 14:52, 2F

06/21 14:53, , 3F
Barack Obama, the first black president,.....
06/21 14:53, 3F

06/21 14:54, , 4F
Barack Obama, a popular president at home and overseas,
06/21 14:54, 4F

06/21 22:23, , 5F
"答案的解釋為「人名...名詞之前不加冠詞.."-> "不加冠詞"
06/21 22:23, 5F

06/21 22:23, , 6F
是用法之一,但這並不是唯一的用法。加the的用法也有,尚
06/21 22:23, 6F

06/21 22:24, , 7F
未到"錯誤"的地步-> http://ppt.cc/0,vI (點選幾個例子,
06/21 22:24, 7F

06/21 22:25, , 8F
看內容,多看幾個)
06/21 22:25, 8F

06/21 23:53, , 9F
thanks a billion. :)
06/21 23:53, 9F

06/22 14:10, , 10F
我看過類似的解釋,像是Hemingway這種幾乎是家喻戶曉
06/22 14:10, 10F

06/22 14:11, , 11F
的人,同位語通常都不加冠詞;反之則通常加a 或 the
06/22 14:11, 11F
文章代碼(AID): #1C7mc39U (Eng-Class)