[新聞] Twitch主播因cos Apex的生命線而被封

看板C_Chat作者 (瘋法師)時間5年前 (2019/04/16 11:34), 5年前編輯推噓230(27141258)
留言570則, 302人參與, 5年前最新討論串1/12 (看更多)
Twitch Punishes White Apex Legends Cosplayer Who Painted Her Face Black http://tinyurl.com/yxg43erh Twitch has temporarily banned a Lithuanian streamer after she cosplayed the Apex Legends character Lifeline using blackface makeup. On Saturday, Karina “Karupups” Martsinkevich was streaming herself preparing her Lifeline cosplay in Twitch’s “Just Chatting” section to roughly 160 viewers. Martsinkevich, who had dyed her hair and put on a white shirt and surgical mask, then applied a dark foundation to her face to mimic Lifeline’s appearance. “On my stream, I wanted to show the viewers, how hard is to prepare for a cosplay, how much time the make up, costume and another details can take,” Martsinkevich said in an email to Kotaku. The final result of Martsinkevich’s cosplay is what’s commonly recognized as blackface—when a non-black person attempts to caricature or present as a black person. It originated in the 1800s when white actors used shoe polish or burnt cork, sometimes on top of highlighting their lips or other features, to perform exaggerated and racist stereotypes of black people. Martsinkevich’ s stream was taken down before she could finish her cosplay preparation in what constitutes a direct denouncement of blackface on Twitch. After announcing her apparently 30-day suspension, Martsinkevich posted a YouTube video in which she explained that she was banned for “engaging in hateful conduct against a person or group of people.” She went on to contend that she “just wanted to be similar to Lifeline from Apex...it wasn’t meant to have [sic] a joke of anyone. It was just a cosplay, guys, for my favorite legend from a computer game.” The Twitch streamer says that she didn’t mean for her cosplay “to be painful for anyone” and apologized to those who were hurt. Twitch did not respond to a request for comment. In the cosplay community, blackface is extremely controversial and widely looked down on. White cosplayers of brown or black characters like Overwatch’ s Sombra and Michonne from The Walking Dead have been lambasted for the practice. While aesthetic fidelity can be a primary concern for cosplayers, altering racial appearance easily devolves into stereotyping and recalls the history of the practice. On top of that, black cosplayers have faced numerous barriers getting into the cosplay scene because, traditionally, there are comparatively few characters in video games, comics and anime who appear black or dark-skinned. According to several black cosplayers interviewed by Kotaku in 2016, they sometimes receive pushback and criticism for dressing up as characters who are not black. After her ban, Martsinkevich again posted the picture of herself in the cosplay on the Russian social media app VK. She added the caption, “Thank you for the enormous support. Thank you for not leaving me alone in such a situation. So, guys and girls, what do you think about Cosplay?” ==== 簡單來說,這位妹子。 https://i.imgur.com/jfByZuu.png
因為想向自己的觀眾展示Cosplay的難度,而選擇了 Apex 的生命線進行cos。 https://i.imgur.com/BO5xpmL.png
然後就犯禁而被封了。因為她為了扮黑人把自己塗黑。 問題在黑臉在美國被視為是一種嘲笑黑人的妝扮,因為以前有種搞笑劇就是白人塗黑臉扮 黑人來搞笑。 -- 「星耀如眼,賜吾輩目光。 取吾奉獻,予吾輩力量。 此等威力,暗夜淚光芒。」 ─黑暗祭禮 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.233.154.5 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/C_Chat/M.1555385664.A.0FD.html

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 1F
這世界真的病了
04/16 11:35, 1F
※ 編輯: wizardfizban (36.233.154.5), 04/16/2019 11:35:28

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 2F
惹到黑人就是不行啊 只有黑人可以扮演其他人種
04/16 11:35, 2F

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 3F
政治不正確 幫QQ
04/16 11:35, 3F

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 4F
政治正確
04/16 11:35, 4F

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 5F
here's your birthday present~
04/16 11:35, 5F

04/16 11:35, 5年前 , 6F
有一種騎士叫我覺得你騎士
04/16 11:35, 6F

04/16 11:36, 5年前 , 7F
好萊屋都不敢得罪了
04/16 11:36, 7F

04/16 11:36, 5年前 , 8F
這世界有病?
04/16 11:36, 8F

04/16 11:36, 5年前 , 9F
希望黑人也不要Cos其他膚色角色 看了很礙眼
04/16 11:36, 9F

04/16 11:36, 5年前 , 10F
黑人說歧視就是歧視
04/16 11:36, 10F

04/16 11:36, 5年前 , 11F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 12F
麥可:
04/16 11:37, 12F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 13F
除了黑人誰都不能學黑人
04/16 11:37, 13F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 14F
支....支那...?
04/16 11:37, 14F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 15F
COSPLAY也有事?
04/16 11:37, 15F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 16F
黑人怎麼cos其他膚色
04/16 11:37, 16F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 17F
騎士自助餐
04/16 11:37, 17F

04/16 11:37, 5年前 , 18F
好扯 角色就黑的不然哩
04/16 11:37, 18F

04/16 11:38, 5年前 , 19F
只有我覺得他膚色變成古銅色比原本膚色更性感的嗎
04/16 11:38, 19F

04/16 11:38, 5年前 , 20F
只有我們黑人可以扮演其他人種 其他人種扮演黑人就是歧視
04/16 11:38, 20F

04/16 11:38, 5年前 , 21F
所以以後都不能演黑人就對了
04/16 11:38, 21F

04/16 11:38, 5年前 , 22F
當年小勞勃到底怎麼有辦法在開麥拉驚魂演黑人啊XD
04/16 11:38, 22F

04/16 11:38, 5年前 , 23F
SJW這種玩法怎麼26的言論檢舉有點像...
04/16 11:38, 23F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 24F
三小
04/16 11:39, 24F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 25F
可憐,有夠玻璃
04/16 11:39, 25F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 26F
黑人扮其他人種也會被批鬥
04/16 11:39, 26F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 27F
真衰小 被覺得騎士
04/16 11:39, 27F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 28F
等等,生命線不是亞洲人嗎?
04/16 11:39, 28F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 29F
電影小姐好白表示
04/16 11:39, 29F

04/16 11:39, 5年前 , 30F
所以白人不能COS黑人就是了?
04/16 11:39, 30F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 31F
樓下支援黑色雷姆
04/16 11:40, 31F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 32F
低能左膠
04/16 11:40, 32F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 33F
膚色是黑的
04/16 11:40, 33F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 34F
說玻璃還是怎樣的麻煩自己去Google “塗黑臉”,都有美
04/16 11:40, 34F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 35F
國州長因為這件事下台了
04/16 11:40, 35F

04/16 11:40, 5年前 , 36F
黑人會把劇本魔改成角色本來就是黑人R
04/16 11:40, 36F

04/16 11:41, 5年前 , 37F
美國州長這樣下台不是代表更玻璃?
04/16 11:41, 37F

04/16 11:41, 5年前 , 38F
塗黑臉成為禁忌的時候可沒有什麼政治正確跟SJW
04/16 11:41, 38F
還有 492 則推文
04/16 21:03, 5年前 , 531F
化內涵都沒有
04/16 21:03, 531F

04/16 21:20, 5年前 , 532F
黑人自助餐喔
04/16 21:20, 532F

04/16 21:43, 5年前 , 533F
建議這位主播用原本膚色再COS一次,以示對黑人的尊重
04/16 21:43, 533F

04/16 22:52, 5年前 , 534F
有夠白癡
04/16 22:52, 534F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 535F
你怎麼會認為黑人只有被美國霸凌過?
04/16 23:02, 535F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 536F
的確單純感到受傷不完全等於歧視
04/16 23:02, 536F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 537F
但當他們感受到被歧視就是了
04/16 23:02, 537F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 538F
難不成歧視要由其他不相干的人來判定?
04/16 23:02, 538F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 539F
我沒有說過當成我的文化準則= =
04/16 23:02, 539F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 540F
我是說他們有那種文化背景的人應該要理解遵守
04/16 23:02, 540F

04/16 23:02, 5年前 , 541F
更不用說twitch是哪裡的公司了
04/16 23:02, 541F

04/16 23:05, 5年前 , 542F
有道理耶 不塗黑 說不定一樣被說歧視==
04/16 23:05, 542F

04/16 23:19, 5年前 , 543F
快點把做日光浴的人通通抓去槍斃啊
04/16 23:19, 543F

04/17 00:30, 5年前 , 544F
黑人別鬧了
04/17 00:30, 544F

04/17 00:53, 5年前 , 545F
全身都有塗欸
04/17 00:53, 545F

04/17 00:58, 5年前 , 546F
現在是在討論blackface還是黑人被霸凌的問題拜託先搞清
04/17 00:58, 546F

04/17 00:58, 5年前 , 547F
楚ok? 歧視指的是某個人基於特地族群定位而非個人特質
04/17 00:58, 547F

04/17 00:58, 5年前 , 548F
給予不同的待遇或想法 今天這個coser的行為明顯完全無關
04/17 00:58, 548F

04/17 00:58, 5年前 , 549F
歧視 只能說誤觸文化禁忌罷了 硬要幫人家扣上歧視帽子?
04/17 00:58, 549F

04/17 00:58, 5年前 , 550F
什麼叫做覺得被歧視就是歧視我看不懂==
04/17 00:58, 550F

04/17 01:01, 5年前 , 551F
那種文化背景又是什麼意思?照你說的來看所有白人都是同
04/17 01:01, 551F

04/17 01:01, 5年前 , 552F
一個文化背景?所以世界上只有三種族群這樣?白人黃人黑
04/17 01:01, 552F

04/17 01:01, 5年前 , 553F
人?
04/17 01:01, 553F

04/17 02:19, 5年前 , 554F
又沒吃炸雞
04/17 02:19, 554F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 555F
提到霸凌那句並不是在回你
04/17 03:33, 555F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 556F
用維基並無法完全代表定義
04/17 03:33, 556F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 557F
究竟有沒有歧視不是你或我說了算,我並沒有扣帽子
04/17 03:33, 557F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 558F
進行動作的人到底有無惡意也沒有關聯
04/17 03:33, 558F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 559F
這並沒有這麼難懂
04/17 03:33, 559F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 560F
或許我說的不夠嚴謹
04/17 03:33, 560F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 561F
找了篇文給你參考
04/17 03:33, 561F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 562F
04/17 03:33, 562F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 563F
另外我並沒有說相同,如果你不認為她跟這文化背景有關係
04/17 03:33, 563F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 564F
至少不管怎樣她都是在twitch這平台上
04/17 03:33, 564F

04/17 03:33, 5年前 , 565F
被twitch ban真的非常合理
04/17 03:33, 565F

04/17 07:31, 5年前 , 566F
低能種族
04/17 07:31, 566F

04/17 07:33, 5年前 , 567F
一堆人扮亞洲人沒事 黃皮膚在美國有少被歧視嗎
04/17 07:33, 567F

04/17 10:25, 5年前 , 568F
照某些智障邏輯,之前傳出某舞台劇讓黑人演聖女貞德,有網
04/17 10:25, 568F

04/17 10:25, 5年前 , 569F
民在網上譏諷是演火刑後的版本,這種言論不能算歧視對吧,
04/17 10:25, 569F

04/17 10:25, 5年前 , 570F
錯就錯在他們不該參演異種異色的角色,被罵剛好。
04/17 10:25, 570F
文章代碼(AID): #1SjKr03z (C_Chat)
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 12 篇):
文章代碼(AID): #1SjKr03z (C_Chat)