Re: [心得] 哭哭星期天v.s.超級淚光大道
※ 引述《hong888 (tip)》之銘言:
: 這篇寫在blog裡
: 花了蠻多時間分析的哩
: 不過用字蠻尖銳的
: http://tw.myblog.yahoo.com/jw!.oVaEqqAGRT0SEnUcs8yGg--/
本來不想回的在這個版有出現我文章的部份也只有"李明依"的文= =
可是有人說要知道哪裡不中肯,所以我只好出來。
看快天是從魚庠拳之後,看自己喜愛的歌手進而到校園。
印象最深刻是艾偉在棚內被刷下來,哭的西哩嘩啦那集。
那時候只覺得這男生怎麼會邊哭邊用手搧著眼睛,雖然這樣想,
但我的眼淚也跟著不爭氣的流呀流,甚至整張衛生紙濕到一整個誇張的地步。
最驚人的是,我爸也跟著我哭XD
再來就是卓幫主令人驚艷的高音,還記得那集強打著評審猛搖頭不知東海高人眾多的點。
以上是想讓小安知道我不討厭艾,但我真的認為男女還是要有一定的保持距離,
所以我才會有那樣的推文。
以 下 是 正 文
我把個人認為不中肯的地方PO出來
1.星光把參賽者偶像化功力一流
因為星光的節目關係,所以每集的那些人就是會上台唱歌。
我覺得他們之所以會這麼紅是因為每個禮拜的出現以及本身有其實力。
假使快天也這樣撥出,卓幫主、艾、鄭博、楊、呂也不會輸給他們。
還有,楊怎麼樣唱歌怎麼樣的站姿實在不是一個專業的影評人該有的批評。
2.快天刺激度強,塑造偶像不易
我覺得三位老師的講話有時候很好笑阿,比李小姐好太多了吧= =
灑狗血的選歌也不行嗎?他的拿手曲風就是這樣阿
4.節目戲劇化
艾可以哭成這樣,為什麼星光幫不能哭?
評審會哭也是因為長期的相處下來呀!這樣也要指教,我真覺得有點太偏頗。
單曲唱片在休息室,我是認為是製作單位很怪。
要特別的拍休息室等於是要製造緊張氣氛,這樣在棚內應該更可以吧!
比較表部分,評審專業方面我認為星光是要其他演藝圈的意見。例如林志炫。
至於僅聞、麻吉葛格,我真覺得製作單位腦殘。
我是兩邊都看的觀眾捧友。兩邊節目屬性雖同,但,目的不同。
拿來做比較實在是中蘋果毒太深。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.167.183.96
→
06/11 01:22, , 1F
06/11 01:22, 1F
→
06/11 01:23, , 2F
06/11 01:23, 2F
推
06/11 01:22, , 3F
06/11 01:22, 3F
→
06/11 01:23, , 4F
06/11 01:23, 4F
→
06/11 01:24, , 5F
06/11 01:24, 5F
→
06/11 01:24, , 6F
06/11 01:24, 6F
推
06/11 01:24, , 7F
06/11 01:24, 7F
→
06/11 01:25, , 8F
06/11 01:25, 8F
→
06/11 01:25, , 9F
06/11 01:25, 9F
→
06/11 01:26, , 10F
06/11 01:26, 10F
推
06/11 01:25, , 11F
06/11 01:25, 11F
→
06/11 01:26, , 12F
06/11 01:26, 12F
→
06/11 01:26, , 13F
06/11 01:26, 13F
推
06/11 01:28, , 14F
06/11 01:28, 14F
→
06/11 01:28, , 15F
06/11 01:28, 15F
→
06/11 01:29, , 16F
06/11 01:29, 16F
→
06/11 01:29, , 17F
06/11 01:29, 17F
→
06/11 01:30, , 18F
06/11 01:30, 18F
→
06/11 01:31, , 19F
06/11 01:31, 19F
推
06/11 01:30, , 20F
06/11 01:30, 20F
→
06/11 01:31, , 21F
06/11 01:31, 21F
→
06/11 01:32, , 22F
06/11 01:32, 22F
→
06/11 01:32, , 23F
06/11 01:32, 23F
推
06/11 01:33, , 24F
06/11 01:33, 24F
→
06/11 01:34, , 25F
06/11 01:34, 25F
推
06/11 01:36, , 26F
06/11 01:36, 26F
→
06/11 01:36, , 27F
06/11 01:36, 27F
→
06/11 01:38, , 28F
06/11 01:38, 28F
推
06/11 01:39, , 29F
06/11 01:39, 29F
→
06/11 01:39, , 30F
06/11 01:39, 30F
推
06/11 01:40, , 31F
06/11 01:40, 31F
→
06/11 01:41, , 32F
06/11 01:41, 32F
→
06/11 01:42, , 33F
06/11 01:42, 33F
推
06/11 01:52, , 34F
06/11 01:52, 34F
→
06/11 01:54, , 35F
06/11 01:54, 35F
推
06/11 01:57, , 36F
06/11 01:57, 36F
→
06/11 01:59, , 37F
06/11 01:59, 37F
→
06/11 01:59, , 38F
06/11 01:59, 38F
→
06/11 02:01, , 39F
06/11 02:01, 39F
推
06/11 02:02, , 40F
06/11 02:02, 40F
→
06/11 02:03, , 41F
06/11 02:03, 41F
→
06/11 02:04, , 42F
06/11 02:04, 42F
→
06/11 02:04, , 43F
06/11 02:04, 43F
→
06/11 02:05, , 44F
06/11 02:05, 44F
→
06/11 02:05, , 45F
06/11 02:05, 45F
→
06/11 02:07, , 46F
06/11 02:07, 46F
→
06/11 02:08, , 47F
06/11 02:08, 47F
→
06/11 02:09, , 48F
06/11 02:09, 48F
推
06/11 02:11, , 49F
06/11 02:11, 49F
→
06/11 02:11, , 50F
06/11 02:11, 50F
→
06/11 02:12, , 51F
06/11 02:12, 51F
推
06/11 02:15, , 52F
06/11 02:15, 52F
→
06/11 02:15, , 53F
06/11 02:15, 53F
→
06/11 02:15, , 54F
06/11 02:15, 54F
推
06/11 02:16, , 55F
06/11 02:16, 55F
→
06/11 02:17, , 56F
06/11 02:17, 56F
→
06/11 02:18, , 57F
06/11 02:18, 57F
→
06/11 02:19, , 58F
06/11 02:19, 58F
→
06/11 02:19, , 59F
06/11 02:19, 59F
→
06/11 02:19, , 60F
06/11 02:19, 60F
→
06/11 02:20, , 61F
06/11 02:20, 61F
討論串 (同標題文章)